[Tom4784]

They say the meaning of life can be found within his eyebrows.

[Saph]

he creeps me out

[Niall]

Coven > Asylum >>>> Murder House.

I thought Coven was best because it didn't have the sheer amount of gaping plot holes like Asylum or the complete disarray that Murder House suffered from. It was the most cohesive.

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by Niall

Coven > Asylum >>>> Murder House.

I thought Coven was best because it didn't have the sheer amount of gaping plot holes like Asylum or the complete disarray that Murder House suffered from. It was the most cohesive.

[Niamh.]

Come back to planet Earth Niall

[Jamesy]

Asylum for me. Despite it's plot holes and certain stories going no where (Nazi's and Aliens for example) - I loved it from start to finish. I love dark stories and Asylum grasped a dark setting perfectly.

Murder House is great though and Coven is too. I try not to compare them much because they are individual mini-series (if you like) and are meant to be different between one another.

[Jamesy]

Coven... most cohesive... If anything it was more of a mess than the previous two!

[Mystic Mock]

I haven't seen Coven yet, but Murder House is better than Asylum for me as it held it's quality throughout, Asylum was losing it towards the end as there was no planning for the ending at all, but I did still enjoy it as Bloody Face was a brilliant edition/addition to the franchise.

[swinearefine]

Asylum > Murder House > Coven

Asylum is miles above the other two though. It's definitely a contender for the best TV show I've ever seen, just flawless from beginning to end After the premiere of Coven I thought it was going to be the best season, but it just got worse and worse until the January episodes except the finale which was an abomination.