[Dominic]

Justice 4 President Hali

[JerseyWins]

Went through another season already, practically pulling an all nighter.

Caramoan... reeeeally good. Possibly #1 or maybe #2 after Cagayan. Probably 2 just cause the final 3 was pretty bad IMO.


---(the faves)---
1. Malcolm
2. Brenda
3. Corinne
4. Eddie
5. Michael
6. Matt
---(cool)---
7. Andrea
8. Laura
---(lmao)---
9. Brandon (legendary exit)
10. Shamar
---(average & very interchangeable)---
11. Allie
12. Cochran
13. Erik
14. Francesca (seemed so nice though & can't believe she's first out twice)
---(could do without; but no one was really a major dislike for me this season)---
15. Phillip (what a nutjob)
16. Sherri
17. Hope
18. Reynold
19. Julia
20. Dawn (I'm not even sure what character trait it is exactly I just never really liked her at all... I think a big factor is honestly just taking out all my faves )

[JerseyWins]

I kinda want to start from the beginning now (to avoid spoilers) but I 100% have to see Malcolm's other season after watching this one.

[Macie Lightfoot]

oh dear.

[VanessaFeltz.]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

Went through another season already, practically pulling an all nighter.

Caramoan... reeeeally good. Possibly #1 or maybe #2 after Cagayan. Probably 2 just cause the final 3 was pretty bad IMO.


---(the faves)---
1. Malcolm
2. Brenda
3. Corinne
4. Eddie
5. Michael
6. Matt
---(cool)---
7. Andrea
8. Laura
---(lmao)---
9. Brandon (legendary exit)
10. Shamar
---(average & very interchangeable)---
11. Allie
12. Cochran
13. Erik
14. Francesca (seemed so nice though & can't believe she's first out twice)
---(could do without; but no one was really a major dislike for me this season)---
15. Phillip (what a nutjob)
16. Sherri
17. Hope
18. Reynold
19. Julia
20. Dawn (I'm not even sure what character trait it is exactly I just never really liked her at all... I think a big factor is honestly just taking out all my faves )

[Dominic]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

Caramoan... reeeeally good. Possibly #1 or maybe #2 after Cagayan.
1. Malcolm
2. Brenda
3. Corinne
16. Sherri
20. Dawn

[Black Dagger]

oh @ Malcolm

[Macie Lightfoot]

alol I think the thing I'm most perplexed about is Michael and Matt being top six

[AarynGriesfan]

Originally Posted by Macie Lightfoot

oh dear.

Haha I said the same thing.

[Natalie.]

Just started 25

[JerseyWins]

What are the oh dears about?

1) Malcolm was awesome. One of my favs overall in Survivor as of right now. Seemed both good at the game (even though he got played by Dawn lol) and was just such a generally chill and likable guy. Very interesting/entertaining player.

2) What's wrong with Michael & Matt? Or is it just "perplexing" cause they're not much of main characters of the season? I really liked how they were playing in the early game and then they linked up with most of the people I liked at the tribes switch / merge so that was a plus as well. Overall I literally didn't dislike anything about them so that's how they're higher than certain others who may have been more entertaining but may have annoyed me at times.

[Macie Lightfoot]

I just think that Malcolm and Matt and Michael, much like Caramoan itself, were very boring :3 Like, for someone as much of A Big Character as Malcolm, what did he even do besides have long hair and win ICs and get a good amount of confessionals? What did Michael do besides be fetishized as Corinne's pet gay what did Matt do besides have an ugly beard and ugly tattoos?

[JerseyWins]

He was always a centerpiece in the game @ Malcolm. He got a good amount of confessionals cause he was entertaining in them lol. And that entertainment made him my favorite. Plus, the double immunity idols move to get Phillip out was crazy and up there as one of my favorite Survivor moments.

Michael & Matt were strategic / pretty good players throughout. I usually like a good strategic pair in reality TV, shout outs to Dan & Memphis, Cody & Derrick, certain showmances that were actually strategic and likable, etc. etc.

Corinne was messy which is what made her hilarious. I don't think Michael was a "pet gay" at all but it was funny to see that whole situation for like the episode or two that it lasted. Besides that has nothing to do with Michael really and all that basically was is a good friendship... another pair that I liked in the game. (Side note, Michael did get pretty irrelevant towards the end of his game but already established himself as one of my favs so it didn't matter)

In Matt's case, what is wrong with him? And what's wrong with an ugly beard and tattoos? The guy never gave me a reason to dislike him, he was pretty involved in the game, and I loved the Michael/Matt duo so yeah he fits in my top 6.

[VanessaFeltz.]

1) Brenda
2) Laura
20) Dawn easily

[LukeB]

Jersey Brenda should be your #1

[JerseyWins]

She would be #1 tbh if Malcolm wasn't a Survivor legend.

[JerseyWins]

Just watched the first episode of Philippines. I LOVE the entire tribe that Malcolm's on. The first tribal council sucked tho as Russell is probably my least favorite out of them and Zane seemed hilaaaaaarious.

[Macie Lightfoot]

I know some people are going to twist themselves into loving any cute azn girl but Brenda sucks :3

[AarynGriesfan]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

What are the oh dears about?

1) Malcolm was awesome. One of my favs overall in Survivor as of right now. Seemed both good at the game (even though he got played by Dawn lol) and was just such a generally chill and likable guy. Very interesting/entertaining player.

2) What's wrong with Michael & Matt? Or is it just "perplexing" cause they're not much of main characters of the season? I really liked how they were playing in the early game and then they linked up with most of the people I liked at the tribes switch / merge so that was a plus as well. Overall I literally didn't dislike anything about them so that's how they're higher than certain others who may have been more entertaining but may have annoyed me at times.

My oh dear was about Caramoan being ranked #2. It had the worst pre merge episodes ever and really was just an atrocious season with a lousy winner. Also not a fan of Malcolm either I think he is highly overrated in almost every aspect of the game.

[AarynGriesfan]

Originally Posted by Macie Lightfoot

I know some people are going to twist themselves into loving any cute azn girl but Brenda sucks :3

This is also unfortunately true. Brenda her second time out was a huge disappointment. In fact she was a disappointment her first time out as well.

[Macie Lightfoot]

I'm also confused as to how Matt and Michael were good players but that's neither here nor there.

[VanessaFeltz.]

Originally Posted by Macie Lightfoot

I'm also confused as to how Matt and Michael were good players but that's neither here nor there.

they got laura out... i hatee those trashy backstabbing
bitches

[JerseyWins]

So I'm 3 episodes into Philippines... of course the tribe I like most is getting dismantled.

Although I'm also liking the tribe with RC & Abi-Marie now... I say those 2 cause they're kinda the focal point (and I constantly forget what the tribe names are ). I have a small liking for that entire tribe just like Malcolm's... But what I like most is the crazy dynamic within that tribe. There's so many different sides that keep getting created and it's hard to tell how that's gonna play out.

[_Tom_]

Corinne at #3

Surprised me how much I liked her in Caramoan after I absolutely despised her guts in Gabon

[JerseyWins]

Can't believe the Malcolm tribe went out 4 straight... But at least Malcolm made it through so I'm ok with it.

Dawson </3 She was hilarious, especially a big highlight in this episode. I literally don't like anyone left on her tribe (except Denise). Not saying they're all bad but they're all pretty boring or not so great. The other tribe is where it's at.