[Tom4784]

Gamu or Treyc's gonna be back come saturday anyway since the other acts don't stand a chance in the wildcard. Cher was a mistake but I can see why she chose Katie, she's different and has an intriguing voice. It's not always about singing ability but style and substance. Look at Leona, all voice no substance or atistic merit.

I'm hoping for Gamu for the wild card although I'd support Treyc if it was her although she'd be this year's Rachel.

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

Cheryl won the last 2 years because she had the best category, nothing at all to do with her personally imo. I'm not twisting anything, she won because she had Alexandra and Joe and the other acts weren't good enough. Again this year she was handed the best category but she's really messed up in her choices............again, she may get away with it again because she has Rebecca.

I don't think the boys were the best group really, it's just that there were so many bad choices throughout last year that Joe won by default. If Dannii and Simon hedged their bets a bit more they'd have triumphed.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

I don't think the boys were the best group really, it's just that there were so many bad choices throughout last year that Joe won by default. If Dannii and Simon hedged their bets a bit more they'd have triumphed.

ah she did, there was no one going to beat Joe really, I think last year was a very bad year in the talent stakes, this year looks a hell of a lot better but I think it's going to be between Matt and Rebecca for the win.

[MeMyselfAndI]

http://www.facebook.com/pages/Gamu-s...197756?ref=sgm

god i hate Cheryl dumb idiot.

Gamu,TreyC and Cher! Rebbecca for Wildcard

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Zippy

What a silly thing to say. The very idea that you need to have a great voice yourself to judge others is so bogus. We all have ears an opinions. And following your logic NONE of the judges should be there. Indeed most judges on most talent shows all over the world shouldnt be there!

Cheryl came from these TV talent shows. In that respect she is more qualified than all the judges because she knows exactly how they are feeling and what it takes to succeed. She has also tasted huge success in both a group AND a solo artist. She knows the business and what they will be required to do...all the hard work, all the media crap. EVERYTHING.

So piss off with all this "she isnt qualified" BS. She most certainly is....far more so than Louis or even Simon. They are just 2 middle aged business men with the musical taste of 2 middle aged women. Cheryl knows more about whats current and what is in the charts.

and...

Cheryl rocks!!

actually simon owns a record label and louis manages musicians,so they deserve to be there more than somebody that cant sing,makes crap records and really shouldnt be judging people that sing better than her.

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

ah she did, there was no one going to beat Joe really, I think last year was a very bad year in the talent stakes, this year looks a hell of a lot better but I think it's going to be between Matt and Rebecca for the win.

I disagree, Stacey could have had it if Dannii wasn't hellbent on turning her into Leona Lewis and Olly could have won if Simon had focused on him more instead of on Danyl. That's just off the top of my head. Bad choices is what lead to Cheryl winning again, not because she had the best category. I'd say the Girls were the best last year but Rachel was a mistake and Lucie was never utilised properly.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

I disagree, Stacey could have had it if Dannii wasn't hellbent on turning her into Leona Lewis and Olly could have won if Simon had focused on him more instead of on Danyl. That's just off the top of my head. Bad choices is what lead to Cheryl winning again, not because she had the best category. I'd say the Girls were the best last year but Rachel was a mistake and Lucie was never utilised properly.

I think we'll have to agree to disagree on this one tbh I couldn't stand Stacey and I do think that Simon did the best he could with Olly, I actually preferred Olly to Joe but Joe had a far better voice

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

and louis manages musicians

no, he manages Boyzone and Westloif.