[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by MB.

afaik that was the only thing about CeCe (wasn't she the one who moved halfway across the country just to have a better chance of being cast on Survivor? A fact which was never even mentioned?)

I can't remember as CeCe never really interested me very much.

[EspeonBB]

I think Game Changers is around mid table for me too. It wasn't awful like the seasons I have at the bottom (RI, One World etc.) and the pre-merge was very strong but it started to fizzle out a bit by the mid-merge and the last two episodes in particular were terrible. Also the editing wasn't very good, with new different relationships forming every episode without any explanation (like Andrea and Aubry suddenly becoming tight).

Thinking about the pre-merge as a tribute to Sandra and the post-merge as a tribute to Cirie makes things better though <3

[Calderyon]

Can´t make a list atm. Or could, but it would be very hard, since i don´t remember most of them anymore and can´t be bothered to rewatch.

I might try make a list at some point. Heroes vs Villains is at the top though.

[Calderyon]

Hmm... maybe it would be easier to rewatch them at 2x speed.

[JerseyWins]

I watched them on a site called alluc. It had all the seasons and just about every single episode (sometimes they're just a little harder to find or you have to go a few pages into the search).

[TomC]

^ I see what you're saying. I adored a lot of DvG but the Idol Nullifier is acc a pretty gross advantage, and once again, too many idols.

[DouglasS]

I always think Blood vs Water is underrated here. I thought the cast was brilliant and so many people were rootable [Tina, Hayden,Katie, Laura]. Even Candice and Ciera [The only time both have actually been good in a season..].

I also think the format/twist worked really well. Rupert/Laura was cute. It was easy to watch and enjoyable.

[TomC]

Originally Posted by DouglasS

I always think Blood vs Water is underrated here. I thought the cast was brilliant and so many people were rootable [Tina, Hayden,Katie, Laura]. Even Candice and Ciera [The only time both have actually been good in a season..].

I also think the format/twist worked really well. Rupert/Laura was cute. It was easy to watch and enjoyable.

I really like BvW. I think it's like the prelude to the Survivor renaissance of Cagayan etc.

[iRyan]

Micronesia, Heroes vs. Villains, China, Gabon, Amazon, and Philippines standout most in my memory

[Koadey]

Glad to see that a lot of people liked San Juan del Sur. I might do a ranking later, and a lot of the red colored seasons from Macie's would also be colored red for me as well.

[Calderyon]

Heroes vs Villains still. SRV19 as runner up.

Maybe a full list someday.

[Macie Lightfoot]

I didn't know it was possible for a human being to rank Samoa as their second favorite season of all time. A true Christmas miracle.

[Matthew.]

1. Gabon
2. Panama
3. San Juan Del Sur
4. Micronesia
5. Cagayan
6. The Amazon
7. Pearl Islands
8. Nicaragua
9. Borneo
10. Vanuatu
11. South Pacific
12. Kaoh Rong
13. Heroes vs Villains
14. David vs. Goliath
15. Africa
16. China
17. Marquesas
18. Blood vs. Water
19. The Australian Outback
20. Game Changers
21. Guatemala
22. Heroes vs. Hustlers vs. Healers
23. Thailand
24. Tocantins
25. Edge of Extinction
26. All Stars
27. Philippines
28. Island Of The Idols
29. Fiji
30. Caramoan
31. Winners At War
32. Samoa
33. Cambodia
34. Worlds Apart
35. One World
36. Palau
37. Ghost Island
38. Millennials vs. Gen X
39. Cook Islands
40. Redemption Island

[Calderyon]

Originally Posted by Macie Lightfoot

I didn't know it was possible for a human being to rank Samoa as their second favorite season of all time. A true Christmas miracle.

Well i'm not a human being. Fully, at least.

[Jigs]

Heroes vs. Villains
Cagayan
Micronesia


the top 3

[Jigs]

Ok lemme give this a whirl x
I haven't seen/only watched parts of Africa, Marquesas, Thailand, Amazon, All Stars, Vanuatu, Palau, Ghost Island and HvHvH so I won't rank those.


1. Heroes vs. Villains
2. Cagayan
3. Micronesia: FvF
4. China
5. Pearl Islands
-
6. Cambodia
7. David vs. Goliath
8. Tocantins
9. Philippines
10. Australian Outback
11. Gabon
12. Caramoan: FvF2
13. Borneo
14. Samoa
15. Island of the Idols
-
16. Kaôh Rōng
17. San Juan Del Sur
18. Panama: Exile Island
-
19. Millennials vs. Gen-X
20. Game Changers
21. World's Apart
22. Blood vs. Water
23. Nicaragua
24. Guatemala
25. Edge of Extinction
-
26. South Pacific
27. One World
28. Cook Islands
-
29. Fiji
30. Redemption Island


What I've concluded is that I love seasons with very clear-cut storylines and character arcs. That's why seasons like MvGX, Game Changers and EoE ranked so low because I felt they were way too messy compared to seasons like HvV, China and Micronesia which followed a plot and took you on a journey that just made sense. The only exception to this rule is Cagayan which had an incredibly nonsensical boot order at times but was the most delightful mess regardless

[armand.kay]

not me voting Gabon ffffff

[armand.kay]

1) China
2) The Amazon
3) Cagayan
4) Micronesia
5) Panama
6) Heros vs Villains
7) Perl Island
8) Marquesas
9) Africa

10) Bourne
11) Guatemala
12) Tocantins
13) Gabon
14) Vanuatu
15) Kao Rong
16) Blood vs Water
17) San Juan Del Sur
18) David vs Goliath
19) Philippines
20) Winner's at War
21) Samoa

22) Heroes vs Healers vs Hustlers
23) Cook Island
24) South Pacific
25) Millennials vs Gen X
26) Game Changers
27) Worlds Apart
28) Island of The Idols

29) Fiji
30) Palau
31) Cambodia
32) Edge Of Extinction
33) Caramoan

34) Australia

35) Ghost Island
36) Nicaragua
37) All-Stars
38) One World
39) Redemption Island
40) Thailand

[Legrand]

Currently on a massive chronological (re)watch so I'll just dump it here for now:

1) Vanuatu
2) Marquesas
3) South Pacific
4) Gabon
5) Guatemala
6) Nicaragua
7) Panama
8) Borneo
9) Kaôh Rōng
10) Worlds Apart
11) Palau
12) Africa
13) Philippines
14) The Australian Outback
15) Samoa
16) Caramoan
17) Cagayan
18) China
19) Thailand
20) One World
21) Cook Islands

[Mystic Mock]

God I loved Pearl Islands and China.