[Samm]

Well that got the players down

[Braden]

Sad to see Cuda and Glenn go, both great players.

[Kate!]

Awww Cuda and Glenn

Come up here and share my cloud. I have Vodka and chocolate.

[Shaun]

Now, confusing as I'm sure that all is, the time has come for you all to make your first Stab in the Dark.

In every series of In Cold Blood the "detectives" were given the chance to guess who the killer was. Here, since you're inmates, what you're effectively going to do in the next story is mutiny, and accuse someone else of being the killer. What happens to this player is yet to be decided.

For now, all 13 of you - Ammi, Annie, Braden, Dezzy, Donovan, Drew, Jon, Lucas, Josy, Jake, Marc, Niamh and Sam - must PM me who you think the real killer is. Who decided to kill Glenn and Kate?

To help, I'm going to give you a bag of information that has been released in the stories. The rest is up for you to deduce, or guess

- You know Braden's character's name is Ieva.
- You know DrunkerThanMoses' character's name is Hugh.
- You know that in a case of Kate vs. Braden, someone wanted Kate dead.
- You know that in a case of Glenn vs. DTM, someone wanted Glenn dead.
- You know that if the Killer has already been sent to Isolation, then they had to kill off the other player by default.

I have also teased one or two clues over the course of the game that were probably too subtle to pick up on...

But for now, that's all you've got to go on.

By 7pm tomorrow, I want all 13 of you to PM me the name of who you believe to be the Killer. You must give me a reason (however flimsy ). You cannot discuss your decision with other players. If you have any questions, just ask.

[AnnieK]

Well one Jon too....

[Marc]

I don't know who most people are. Stupid Xmas names

[Samm]

[Samm]

Will have to think about this

[Drew.]

Time for the killer to hand yourself in to make this a lot more easier

[Marc]

Oh SITD

[Shaun]

And I know btw that those really make this more of a guess than anything, but dw, more clues will emerge between now and the second SITD

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Going to be a total guess, good luck guys.

[Glenn.]

-haunts-

[Shaun]

OP table updated.

[Ammi]

..I don't understand, what happens after we make a guess..?..

[AnnieK]

I think that will be revealed Ammi....

[Kate!]

Can I have a confidential guess just for fun

[Ammi]

..good luck everyone..is this the task, then..?..

[Braden]

Originally Posted by Ammi

..I don't understand, what happens after we make a guess..?..

If the majority choose the actual killer then that person is arrested and a new killer is chosen. The first killer is also out of the competition.

If we choose somebody who isn't the killer then a whole load of **** could go down. Sometimes that person is killed off, but there have been twists that have kept people in the game despite being 'stabbed in the dark'.

[Drew.]

Originally Posted by Braden

If the majority choose the actual killer then that person is arrested and a new killer is chosen. The first killer is also out of the competition.

If we choose somebody who isn't the killer then a whole load of **** could go down. Sometimes that person is killed off, but there have been twists that have kept people in the game despite being 'stabbed in the dark'.

Ooh, sounds good

[Marc]

Yeah what Braden said. Shaun could flip it and give the person with the most votes a clue or something instead

[AnnieK]

Omg...

[Samm]

Right done mine, just a random guest

[Shaun]

yes kate go for it

and yeah, as Braden said - if you all get the real killer, they're peacefully removed from the game. Or killed in a psychotic rage by Livia, I'm not sure yet (not impressed by you ignoring her role in the stories tbh).

as for what happens in the likely event that you fail to identify the killer, well that remains to be seen

Oh and to clarify for any first-time players, SITD is compulsory and anyone who fails to vote will receive a vote against themselves

[Shaun]

and no it's not the task task 3 will start tomorrow night after the outcome of this.