[Jason.]

If each series had twelve Islanders, which 6 girls and 6 boys would you pick to make up the cast?

[RileyH]

S1 | Cally, Hannah, Jess, Poppy, Rachel, Zoe / Albertis, Chris W, Jordan, Josh, Max
S2 | Cara, Kady, Malia, Malin, Olivia, Sophie / Adam M, Alex, Nathan, Rykard, Scott, Tom
S3 | Amber, Chloe, Gabby, Georgia, Montana, Olivia / Alex, Chris, Dom, Jonny, Sam, Theo
S4 | Ellie, Hayley, Kaz, Laura, Megan, Samira / Adam, Charlie, Eyal, Josh, Niall, Wes
AU | Amelia, Cass, Erin, Millie, Natasha, Tayla / Grant, Jaxon, Josh, Justin, Kory, Teddy

god the women's cast is so much better than the men's

[Jason.]

A few of these I don't like or care for but only picked cos they were relevant to their respective series:

LI1:
Jess, Naomi, Zoe, Bethany, Hannah, Rachel
Max, Josh, Omar, Chris W, Jordan, Twins (counting the twins as one)

LI2:
Cara, Kady, Sophie, Malin, Zara, Liana
Nathan, Scott, Terry, Rykard, Tom, Alex

LI3:
Camilla, Olivia, Montana, Gabby, Georgia, Tyla
Chris, Marcel, Theo, Mike, Jonny, Dom

LI4:
Rosie, Hayley, Laura A, Georgia, Ellie B, Alexandra
Adam, Jack Fo, Wes, Josh, Sam, Eyal

[brat.]

Based off of the purpose to create the most entertaining series rather than my personal favourites

S1
Naomi, Jess, Hannah, Zoe, Rachel, Bethany
Chris W, Josh, Jordan, Max, The Twins

S2
Cara, Malin, Olivia, Zara, Kady, Sophie
Scott, Nathan, Terry, Tom, Rykard, Daniel

S3
Olivia, Amber, Gabby, Georgia, Montanna, Jess
Theo, Mike, Chris, Jonny, Dom, Marcel

S4
Hayley, Georgia, Meg, Laura, Ellie B, Samira
Jack Fowler, Wes, Adam, Idris, Jack Finch, Eyal

AU
Cassidy, Millie, Erin, Tayla, Mac, Amelia
Eden, Grant, Jaxon, Justin, Teddy, Dom

[brat.]

series 4 girls was the hardest to pick

[DouglasS]

I only watched LI 3 and LI 4

3
Boys: Theo, Mike, Chris, Marcel, Jamie,Jonny (for the drama)
Girls: Camilla, Montana, Gabby, Amber, Olivia, one of the randos from casa amor as the rest were all bad casts

4
Boys: Wes, Alex, Jack, Adam, Jack Fo, Niall
Girls: Georgia, Rosie, Laura A, Dani, randos?

God the men’s cast is so much better than the women on LI

[Tony Montana]

Based purely on entertainment factor and how much they contributed to their series.

S1:
Jess, Naomi, Hannah, Bethany, Zoe, Rachel
Jon, Josh, Max, Omar, Travis, Twins

S2:
Olivia, Malin, Kady, Zara, Malia, Sophie
Scott, Javi, Daniel, Tom, Terry, Nathan

S3:
Olivia, Montana, Amber, Jess, Chloe, Tyla
Chris, Kem, Mike, Jonny, Theo, Marcel

S4:
Rosie, Alexandra, Megan, Ellie, Georgia, Hayley
Eyal, Adam, Josh, New Jack, Wes, Niall

Aus:
Millie, Cassidy, Tayla, Erin, Shelby, Mac
Eden, Grant, Justin, Jaxon, Teddy, Dom

[Tony Montana]

Originally Posted by RileyH

god the women's cast is so much better than the men's

Originally Posted by DouglasS

God the men’s cast is so much better than the women on LI

[Tony Montana]

Originally Posted by brat.

series 4 girls was the hardest to pick

Tea! Easily the best female cast.

[RileyH]

Originally Posted by Tony Montana

Well when you have to resort to Jon, Travis, Javi, Daniel, Marcel, Eden & Dom to get the numbers I think we both know x

[Tony Montana]

Originally Posted by RileyH

Well when you have to resort to Jon, Travis, Javi, Daniel, Marcel, Eden & Dom to get the numbers I think we both know x

Sweetie i was joking, i know the female cast are miles better.

Also, i actually think Daniel, Javi, Jon and Marcel are good islanders.