[Shaun]

For the makeover? Yeah she should've won that challenge. For the commercial though... it's up for debate with Baga imo (with Blu comfortably the worst).

[Captain.Remy]

Originally Posted by Shaun

For the makeover? Yeah she should've won that challenge. For the commercial though... it's up for debate with Baga imo (with Blu comfortably the worst).

She definitely should have won the makeover one, but I suppose Ru wanted the top 3 to be the most consistent with queens who got the most Ru badges.
I would have rather see The Vivienne won this challenge than Divina tbh

For the commercial, I think she deserved bottom two. I guess Baga's had more "fun" to it. (meaning Baga being just naturally Baga)

[Morgan.]

Originally Posted by Captain.Remy

She definitely should have won the makeover one, but I suppose Ru wanted the top 3 to be the most consistent with queens who got the most Ru badges.
I would have rather see The Vivienne won this challenge than Divina tbh

For the commercial, I think she deserved bottom two. I guess Baga's had more "fun" to it. (meaning Baga being just naturally Baga)

This is a battle I go through in my mind tbh. On one hand I understand why having the 3 most consistent performers in the final is the best way forward, but if everything is judged on track record then there’d be no point in having bottom 2’s and lip syncs etc if the decision is already made.

Cheryl performed by far the best on the makeover, delivered the strongest family resemblance yet landed in the B2 and went home? Because she hadn’t won anything else? Idk that just doesn’t sit right with me.

[Captain.Remy]

Originally Posted by Morgan.

This is a battle I go through in my mind tbh. On one hand I understand why having the 3 most consistent performers in the final is the best way forward, but if everything is judged on track record then there’d be no point in having bottom 2’s and lip syncs etc if the decision is already made.

Cheryl performed by far the best on the makeover, delivered the strongest family resemblance yet landed in the B2 and went home? Because she hadn’t won anything else? Idk that just doesn’t sit right with me.

It's more obvious in those cases where a queen who did well in the challenge still went home because of track record. And then you'll have people complain that one of the top performers of the season (in that case Baga) didn't make the top 3. So it goes both ways really.
It was her second lipsync and she didn't perform that well during the whole competition while it was Baga's first lipsync and did well so far.

That episode was heartbreaking for Cheryl because she should have won, but in hindshight the top 3 was so good that Ru couldn't make another decision. tbh they should have had a top 4 just for Cherly doing so well in the makeover challenge, and her part in the rumix would have slapped!

I hope we get to see her in AS UK or international AS or something to give her another chance.

[Morgan.]

Originally Posted by Captain.Remy

It's more obvious in those cases where a queen who did well in the challenge still went home because of track record. And then you'll have people complain that one of the top performers of the season (in that case Baga) didn't make the top 3. So it goes both ways really.
It was her second lipsync and she didn't perform that well during the whole competition while it was Baga's first lipsync and did well so far.

That episode was heartbreaking for Cheryl because she should have won, but in hindshight the top 3 was so good that Ru couldn't make another decision. tbh they should have had a top 4 just for Cherly doing so well in the makeover challenge, and her part in the rumix would have slapped!

I hope we get to see her in AS UK or international AS or something to give her another chance.

See with Baga I wouldn’t have minded her missing F3 so much just because I don’t recall enjoying a single one of her runways. Sure Cheryl’s were cheap and a bit messy but I could see the intention with them all and I think they were fun.

She’s super deserving of a second shot, so yeah I do hope there’s an All Stars (preferably after UK4/5)