[jet]

Originally Posted by rusticgal

I haven’t seen any logic on here other than my own

Your logic makes perfect sense to me. It is my opinion also that they should be stripped of all titles. They have effectively emotionally abandoned the royal family, are estranged from them, been disrespectful and cruel with how they have gone about things and caused stress and heartache to a grandmother in her mid 90's and a ill grandfather approaching 100.
They made their big leaving announcement without telling the Queen first and the same with this Oprah interview. Their reply to her kind statement today was so disrespectful, a disgrace. They have, and are, showing themselves as selfish, self absorbed, uncaring and having no class.
The Queen won't do it,unfortunately. William could, when he becomes king - he didn't 'gift' it to them! So they might not have the titles for life....