[The Slim Reaper]

Can I have my 2 point score back from Parmy please? He said it didn't fit the the dance, so that extra 5 points shouldn't be added, especially when it wasn't for any reason.

[Holly Christmas]

Originally Posted by The Slim Reaper

Can I have my 2 point score back from Parmy please? He said it didn't fit the the dance, so that extra 5 points shouldn't be added, especially when it wasn't for any reason.

No Slim. You are entitled to those points. Parmy broke the rules. What an ass.

[The Slim Reaper]

Originally Posted by Kate!

No Slim. You are entitled to those points. Parmy broke the rules. What an ass.

I'm not entitled to them. He thought my entry was appalling, as he stated, so if that's the case it deserves no more than 2 points, and this post round trying to make new rules up to try and make it fair isn't how the game should work. Liam only gave it a 5 in total, so I obviously got this one completely wrong, again, just like the other rounds. I should have used achey breaky heart the same as everyone else would, and got a 26 rather than offering anything original or interesting. That's on me, not Parm.

[Cherry Christmas]

It isn’t a new rule though for the past few games it has been 5 if you meet the theme then the remainder for the dance, that just got lost in transit I think...

[The Slim Reaper]

Mine didn't meet either apparently, so I deserve my 2 points however we get there.

[Holly Christmas]

Originally Posted by The Slim Reaper

Mine didn't meet either apparently, so I deserve my 2 points however we get there.

Yours DID fit the criteria, as did mine. Its hardly our fault Parm is a crappy judge.

[Parmy]

Originally Posted by Kate!

Yours DID fit the criteria, as did mine. Its hardly our fault Parm is a crappy judge.

I dont see anyone else complaining but you Kate..

Both my fellow judges thought your entry wasnt up to scratch.

One of my fellow judges thought slims were wasnt either.

I gave both a 2 because I forgot about the theme rule of five points because I want aware of the theme being the 90s.

I've offered to amend with the 5 extra points for both you and slim for your songs being from the 90s.

Perhaps you should be having a word with liam, the experienced judge. He has seemingly gave you 5 points for meeting the criteria of theb90s theme..and then a paultry 1 point for your effort.

My other fellow judge deducted points because she didnt like the song.

Dont see you hassling them for their scores, or reasons for scoring!!!!



Hypocrite.