[Livia]

Originally Posted by BBXX

While I don't see the LGBT poppy as a necessity, I can see why the RBL might want to offer a symbol of an apology of their previous discrimination as an organisation, that's all.

I don't see how creating a new, extra Poppy devalues the other one and therefore I personally don't see the issue either way. If it was replacing the standard poppy, well that's a different thing.

A symbol of apology? To whom? Just LGBT people? How about women, who were excluded from many roles for years and had to leave immediately if they got pregnant? And black and other ethnic soldiers who were discriminated against by certain regiments? Singling out one group alienates those who put aside their differences to honour the all those who defend us.

Remembrance isn't about airing these grievances, it's about remembering those, of all backgrounds, religions, persuasions and other things that divide us, and acknowledging their sacrifice.