[Mystic Mock]

Hypothetically speaking, if you were a Faithful in this series of The Traitors, do you think that you would've been able to guess all four Traitors?

Because it's easy for us watching the Show wondering how the Traitors aren't getting caught etc. But if you were to put yourselves in their shoes, do you think that you would've done any better?

If I'm being honest, I think that I would've gotten three of them this series as certs in my mind. They are Stephen, Hugo, and Fiona.

My reasons:
Stephen - For having a Novel's worth of evidence stacked against him.

Hugo - For being incredibly obvious, with all due respect.

Fiona - For her concentrated attack on Rachel.


If I were to be suspicious of a fourth Traitor, knowing how my mind tends to work, I think that I would've looked at one of Matthew, Ellie, or Rachel, and I probably would've leaned into thinking Ellie tbh.

[GoldHeart]

If I'm being honest,I lost interest in this series and I bowed out after the first episode .

But I'd guess all the Traitors,and make the final and win . I'd have a sprinkle of Jaz's strategy of biding my time but more polished & strategic .

And I'd have someone better opposite me in the final , with their wits about them ..... than dozy Mollie . Someone who isn't goo goo eyed by another cocky Harry .Sounds like most the faithfuls are once again thick as mince meat this year! .

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by GoldHeart

If I'm being honest,I lost interest in this series and I bowed out after the first episode .

But I'd guess all the Traitors,and make the final and win . I'd have a sprinkle of Jaz's strategy of biding my time but more polished & strategic .

And I'd have someone better opposite me in the final , with their wits about them ..... than dozy Mollie . Someone who isn't goo goo eyed by another cocky Harry .Sounds like most the faithfuls are once again thick as mince meat this year!.

I would say that it depends on the Faithful and what their position is in the game. Some of them are incredibly bad though.

[Benjamin]

I may have got one or two but not all.

It’s very easy for people to say they would nail it, but because we know who they are. But if you were actually in the situation you’d have no clue a lot of the time (watch The Mole and see if you can guess The Mole straightaway).

[Ammi]

…I recall when Ellie was a huge favourite/choice for being the secret red traitor because it was said that it was a tall person and it was actually Fiona who was probably the shortest person in there…where did the ‘tall speculation’ come from, I don’t know but I have to say that in the end I just went with it……

[GoldHeart]

Originally Posted by Benjamin

I may have got one or two but not all.

It’s very easy for people to say they would nail it, but because we know who they are. But if you were actually in the situation you’d have no clue a lot of the time (watch The Mole and see if you can guess The Mole straightaway).

I guessed the mole in the first season,but I admit it was between a few .

[Livia]

I would have suspected Rachel because she said she's had FBI training. That would have rung massive alarm bells with me. And the fact that despite her saying that, despite Fiona and Harriet, she's slipped back under the radar. No one suspects her and that would make me suspicious. I guess it's quite easy to say when you're not inside the game. People would think I was a traitor I'm sure. I don't trust anyone straight off the bat, I'm not naturally gregarious and if I don't like you straight away I'll probably never like you and make no effort. I just can't fake it with people I don't like. Consequently, week 1... "Livia, you have received the most votes and are banished from the castle".

[bots]

with so many faithful spouting rubbish, it would make it very difficult to identify traitors

[Oliver_W]

Rachel seems to have been blessed with inhabiting a blind spot. I swear she could swank in wearing her Traitor Cloak, and everyone would compliment her earrings.

But based on watching, I don't know how good I'd be. A lot of the guesses seem to be based on "you blinked three times instead of seven when the third group of people arrive at breakfast" or "you hold that banana as if it's a quill" or other random stuff, who's to say I wouldn't do the same?

[rusticgal]

I wouldn't have guessed Stephen but I would be gunning for Rachel now without a doubt. Her FBI confession and her mention of notes about everyone would be a great reason for a Traitor to murder her... why this has not been raised I don't know.

[Ray.]

I have a habit of thinking the sweetest, kindest and most unassuming people are secretly full of spite, betrayal and hatred. It's partly why I don't trust @Ammi. So I like to think I would have cottoned onto Stephen and Fiona at least. In fact I did correctly guess Fiona was the secret traitor before her reveal.

[Ammi]

Originally Posted by Ray.

I have a habit of thinking the sweetest, kindest and most unassuming people are secretly full of spite, betrayal and hatred. It's partly why I don't trust @Ammi. So I like to think I would have cottoned onto Stephen and Fiona at least. In fact I did correctly guess Fiona was the secret traitor before her reveal.