[setanta]

Originally Posted by VickyJ

Exactly. An 'alright' voice...when in tune.

That coldplay song was disgraceful. Not one note in tune...

I thought last night was worse to be honest but there's not much in it.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by setanta

I thought last night was worse to be honest but there's not much in it.

Nah, she was better last night, she hit some of the notes.

She even started off on the wrong note on the coldplay one...my dog was howling!

[setanta]

Originally Posted by VickyJ

Nah, she was better last night, she hit some of the notes.

She even started off on the wrong note on the coldplay one...my dog was howling!

I honestly can't understand how people have said her performances have been great.... they're mediocre at best.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by setanta

I honestly can't understand how people have said her performances have been great.... they're mediocre at best.

Dont get it at all.

And I actually only know 2 people who like her.

I dont get how people say she should go through on 'personality'...honestly, she reminds me of a moose on speed...

[setanta]

Originally Posted by VickyJ

Dont get it at all.

And I actually only know 2 people who like her.

I dont get how people say she should go through on 'personality'...honestly, she reminds me of a moose on speed...

I originally liked her in the auditions but her personality is grating now, which has allowed me to judge her purely on her vocal prowess and she's really lacking in that department.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by setanta

I originally liked her in the auditions but her personality is grating now, which has allowed me to judge her purely on her vocal prowess and she's really lacking in that department.

I didnt even like her in auditions.

Everyone was bleating on about a 'wonderful' audition, and I thought it was very average...

[setanta]

Originally Posted by VickyJ

I didnt even like her in auditions.

Everyone was bleating on about a 'wonderful' audition, and I thought it was very average...

Oh, don't get me wrong, never thought she was amazing- just had a charm to her that offset any problems with her singing. Now that charm is gone for me and I'm left with an average singer. But sure there's alot of average singers in it this year.