[Tom]

Originally Posted by lili

Public vote from week one.

Everything on the one night.. no matter whether it's Saturday or Sunday..

I reckon the sing off should stay but I don't think the judges should decide, over an ad break the public should decide who they want to save

With mentors and what not its a bit biased atm and sometimes a tad unfair. If it was Pop Idol format with a sing off Louis would not have kept J&E over Lucie (for example)

[Stacey.]

Hey bauble
welcomee
hope you Enjoy your time here
haha,i would like dannii to go,, And a nice new young girl to come in as a judge

[Jack_]

Similar to what Tom said, if they're doing the two night format again and are going to scrap the sing off, announce the bottom two on Saturday, public gets 24 hours to save one - they leave on Sunday.

I'd like to see a Wildcard round too if Simon's having 16 acts. The twelve that don't make it from the Judge's homes can be voted for by the public and one act from each category with the most votes goes through.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Similar to what Tom said, if they're doing the two night format again and are going to scrap the sing off, announce the bottom two on Saturday, public gets 24 hours to save one - they leave on Sunday.

I'd like to see a Wildcard round too if Simon's having 16 acts. The twelve that don't make it from the Judge's homes can be voted for by the public and one act from each category with the most votes goes through.

He could get an extra week out of that, think Pop Idol and American Idol middle stages where it goes live but it isn't in the main studio.

And if there are 16 acts next week, rather than extending the show I hope they split the 16 acts into two groups, 8 performing on Saturday with the results at the end, and the same on the Sunday with 2 in total going home each weekend. It might be a bit fairer too like the second or third one on stage out of 16 acts is at an obvious disadvantage, plus it would drag on.

Then they can join the groups up in week 4 or 5 when they're down to what the numbers would normally be. Make this the new big band week (make an event of it).

[BB_Eye]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

A cheap happy hour bar at the audition-stage for those waiting to go on.