[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

Originally Posted by Jarvio

When people say "this person should have gone in" etc, it really baffles me - why? Why should have they gone in? You know nothing about the hopefulls (or the current hms yet), so how can you say that "this person would have been a great HM" etc if you don't know? Excuse to complain methinks

alister would have been a great hm you only have to look at him to know that

[Jarvio]

Originally Posted by simonsays

alister would have been a great hm you only have to look at him to know that

That's complete speculation though.

You might be right, he might have been great - but there is an equal chance that he may have been awful. Nobody knows