[vesavius]

Originally Posted by Claymores

OK - she wound Sunshine over crisps purely to try get the girl up for eviction. She smirked when the lass got uprset. She then used this ammunition with Shabby/Caoimmhe

Thats really how you saw it? I am suprised tbh

My perspective on it was that even the HLs showed her saying to SS 'If you don't share the crisps you will look tight', and that was the truth.

By not sharing the crisps SS DID look tight in the eyes of the house... thats just a fact, and she would have looked a lot worse as time went on without being told that.

Josie did not give her a sniff of grief over it past that point, and even her saying to the house what she had said to SS stopped the more hostile bitching from going on and on (though it obviously didnt halt it completely).

If I was in that house and I had the crips I personally would have thrown them in to the group pot, but thats me. Maybe thats why I see it differently to most here.

She later sat repeatedly and listened to SS air her view point calmly, even on the subject of her fears of being the most hated in the house (even to the point of saying she was on her period and she would soon be the most hated herself to make SS feel better)

Josie always smiles, when she is happy or when she is upset or nervous. In the latter it's obviously a defense mechanism that she uses to try to defuse situations that make her uncomfortable. It dosent make her evil or nasty.

Josie is used to communal living where everyone mucks in and throws it all into the pot for sharing ('care and share, thats the point') and I have no doubt she found it distasteful anyone having a personal food supply, but at least she said it directly to SS in a reasonable calm way. The fact that SS chose her later to sit with and chat about her perspective later on, when Josie actually comforted her, shows that she trusts Josie and wasnt offended with her in any way.

I know none of this will change your perspective, and nor do I expect it to, but it's just how I saw things.