[Forever_Young]

Originally Posted by KERRYJ

even at 25 if you like someone its hard enough if you are not sure how they feel about you throw in the fact they are in the big brother house and that adds another element to the whole thing. I like Josie even without the whole John James story and anyone who says she is not pretty take a look at this photo




Attachment 852

I agree, in my opinion its obvious that the two really genuinely like each other, and the fact that they are in the big brother house yes it makes it an unnatural environment, with heightened emotions etc. Ok she has maybe taken her insecurities slightly too far at times but she admits that herself, I honestly feel she has been let down in the past and at times shes just been putting up a bit of a guard in order to not get hurt.

Regardless of the whole john james story I do find her to be a really interesting and funny woman (the thumb sucking does annoy me but we all have bad habbits!) I also think she is very attractive and all the fat, ogre, pig etc comments on here are quite immature and saddening. You can express that you dont like her looks without all that.

Yes everyones entitiled to their opinion but I agree with the original poster that the hatred is a bit too far, come on its a tv show!! I am certainly sticking by her, she makes me laugh so much!!

[WOMBAI]

Originally Posted by Forever_Young

I agree, in my opinion its obvious that the two really genuinely like each other, and the fact that they are in the big brother house yes it makes it an unnatural environment, with heightened emotions etc. Ok she has maybe taken her insecurities slightly too far at times but she admits that herself, I honestly feel she has been let down in the past and at times shes just been putting up a bit of a guard in order to not get hurt.

Regardless of the whole john james story I do find her to be a really interesting and funny woman (the thumb sucking does annoy me but we all have bad habbits!) I also think she is very attractive and all the fat, ogre, pig etc comments on here are quite immature and saddening. You can express that you dont like her looks without all that.

Yes everyones entitiled to their opinion but I agree with the original poster that the hatred is a bit too far, come on its a tv show!! I am certainly sticking by her, she makes me laugh so much!!

Like each other, yes - but love/romance - different story!

And thumbsucking at the age of 25 is more than a bad habit - especially on public tv! Either attention seeking or a sign of someone who is emotionally immature and insecure!

I don't care about her looks - that is not the issue - it is the way she is manipulating their relationship for airtime - and increasing her chance of walking away with the 100K - that is what annoys me!

[Jedward]

Originally Posted by Stacey.x

She ****s me off so much.. hate her the most in there.

She's so on/off with John.. anything he says that she doesn't want to hear, and she'll go off in a mood for the next 2 hours and bitch about him to someone. She leads Andrew on constantly, especially when she's had a bit of a falling out with John just to make her feel better or something. Gets jealous over any other girl being with John, also her thinking he actually fancies her LOL!

this... xxxxx

[housemate]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

Like each other, yes - but love/romance - different story!

And thumbsucking at the age of 25 is more than a bad habit - especially on public tv! Either attention seeking or a sign of someone who is emotionally immature and insecure!

I don't care about her looks - that is not the issue - it is the way she is manipulating their relationship for airtime - and increasing her chance of walking away with the 100K - that is what annoys me!

Wow!! Manipulating thir relationship? How do you know this for sure? I think she's 100 petcent in Love with him, its a shame people assume that shes being false without providing proof!

[Forever_Young]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

Like each other, yes - but love/romance - different story!

And thumbsucking at the age of 25 is more than a bad habit - especially on public tv! Either attention seeking or a sign of someone who is emotionally immature and insecure!

I don't care about her looks - that is not the issue - it is the way she is manipulating their relationship for airtime - and increasing her chance of walking away with the 100K - that is what annoys me!

Im not saying that they will be together forever or anything..reality is it WILL be different when they get out, it might not work. but I still believe that they do care about each other in a loving way and enjoy spending time with each other, I honestly dont think its for the cameras, you cant fake the way they are with each other (I beleive).

The thumbsucking, yes it could well be a sign that she is insecure as she has shown signs of this but at the end of the day I dont think shes doing it deliberately for attention, and it doesnt make me think any less of her as a person.

Fair enough you dont care about her looks, but there are some immature people on here that feel the need to go on about her weight, etc.
I dont think shes doing any manipulating but guess we will have to agree to disagree on this one!

[BBfan46]

Josie will win, mark my words. That same pigeon told me.

[pixee]

I thought people liked her lol.

I went off her when she began to cling to JJ like a Koala bear. Same as when mario just followed ben around, they lose their personality.

[WOMBAI]

Originally Posted by BBfan46

Josie will win, mark my words. That same pigeon told me.

I don't think she will - too many people have opened their eyes - but, if she does, it will be a farce, with a helping hand from bb - who like their romances to increase viewers! It will be a fake win - like everything else fake about her!

[BBfan46]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

I don't think she will - too many people have opened their eyes - but, if she does, it will be a farce, with a helping hand from bb - who like their romances to increase viewers! It will be a fake win - like everything else fake about her!

Josie Gibson ♥

[BBfan46]

Originally Posted by oddballmisfitsFTW

10 things I hate about Josie

1. she is a bitch

2. she plays up to the cameras all the time

3. she is selfish

4. she **** stirs then takes backseat

5. she is lazy slob

6. she has an annoying voice

7. she is bunny boiler

8. she is stone-faced and ugly

9. she has ZERO feminine charm

10. she is VERY VERY DULL to watch

[housemate]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

She would be prettier if she took more care of herself, stopped being so lazy and lost a bit of weight!

But her looks are not the real issue - it is her personality! Everyone with a brain knows that 'romances' in the big brother house get lots of airtime and are popular with the public.

It is no coincidence that she showed such an interest in him from day one! She homed in on the only good-looking one and went for it with everything she had! Even the fact he didn't feel the same way - didn't deter her! She wanted the publicity, so conveniently ignored that - and reeled him in!

He isn't the most stable of characters and was an easy target! He likes her company, especially in such an enclosed, limited environment - and doesn't want to upset her - it has all played very conveniently into her hands!

She is a master manipulator and a bitch!

I think she's soooooooooo pretty and who are you to make nasty comments about he weight? She does alot of the cooking so I don't understand why you think she's lazy? Its only your opinion of her with regard her romance with JJ, you can offer no proof that she doesn't Love him

[WOMBAI]

Originally Posted by housemate

I think she's soooooooooo pretty and who are you to make nasty comments about he weight? She does alot of the cooking so I don't understand why you think she's lazy? Its only your opinion of her with regard her romance with JJ, you can offer no proof that she doesn't Love him

I didn't say she wasn't pretty - but that she would be prettier if she lost a bit of weight! The weight detracts from her looks! They weren't nasty comments - just facts! If she wants to attract the good-looking guys like JJ, then she has to be realistic - and make more effort to lose a bit of weight - no great mystery!

And she is lazy - I have eyes - even the hms now comment about it! She spends most of her time lying in bed - when that is the last thing someone with weight problems should do! She is half-hearted in the tasks, making no real effort. So she cooks a bit - I should hope so - she needs to do something other than fawn over JJ to win that 100k!

[Julie10]

Originally Posted by KERRYJ

even at 25 if you like someone its hard enough if you are not sure how they feel about you throw in the fact they are in the big brother house and that adds another element to the whole thing. I like Josie even without the whole John James story and anyone who says she is not pretty take a look at this photo




Attachment 852

He told her several times he didn't feel for her the way she did for him but she didn't want to hear that.

Big bunny boiler in over drive. Sick of seeing her clinging to him and humping him like a dog in season trying to get airtime. Very sad and awful to watch.

[Julie10]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

She would be prettier if she took more care of herself, stopped being so lazy and lost a bit of weight!

But her looks are not the real issue - it is her personality! Everyone with a brain knows that 'romances' in the big brother house get lots of airtime and are popular with the public.

It is no coincidence that she showed such an interest in him from day one! She homed in on the only good-looking one and went for it with everything she had! Even the fact he didn't feel the same way - didn't deter her! She wanted the publicity, so conveniently ignored that - and reeled him in!

He isn't the most stable of characters and was an easy target! He likes her company, especially in such an enclosed, limited environment - and doesn't want to upset her - it has all played very conveniently into her hands!

She is a master manipulator and a bitch!

Have to agree with this.

[housemate]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

I didn't say she wasn't pretty - but that she would be prettier if she lost a bit of weight! The weight detracts from her looks! They weren't nasty comments - just facts! If she wants to attract the good-looking guys like JJ, then she has to be realistic - and make more effort to lose a bit of weight - no great mystery!

And she is lazy - I have eyes - even the hms now comment about it! She spends most of her time lying in bed - when that is the last thing someone with weight problems should do! She is half-hearted in the tasks, making no real effort. So she cooks a bit - I should hope so - she needs to do something other than fawn over JJ to win that 100k!

Blimey!! I thought we lived in a more tolerant, less judgemental society now!
Your saying that in order to be attractive she needs to lose weight? That all men will only go for the skinny gals, regardless of personality, kindness or emotion? WOW!!

Josie brings smiles to the house, she is loved by all of them, Dave even said he loved her .. I havent witnessed anybody making comments about her .. I think you've made that up to sway good opinion of her because you clearly don't like her.
As far as the tasks are concerned, she tries really hard ... what are you on about?
She cleans the bathroom, washes the dishes, tidies the garden AND cooks, what more do you want

[Stacey.]

Originally Posted by BBfan46

Josie will win, mark my words. That same pigeon told me.

That same one that told you Sunshine would win?

[troy4783]

Originally Posted by angiec

Just wondering why the dislike.

When I was younger and really liked a guy I wanted to spend all my time with them, even going as far as to miss my grans birthday when i was 16, this did not make me EVIL or anything else, it made me a girl who really liked someone and wanted to spend all my time with them,

It is boring seeing them under the duvet but isn't that normal behaviour, meaning wanting to spend all her time with someone she really likes, AND she does like him.

Maybe because its on tv we are all suddenly critics but if it were ourselves or a friend would we still judge if they wanted to spend all the time with someone they liked.

As for Andrew she was just being herself and Andrew has admited that she has built his confidence but he knows nothing is going to happen so what is bad here,

Before anyone says yes but I was 16 at 28 when I met my hubby all I wanted to do was spend all my time with him as well,

It changes after 12 years of course but can still remember those days were it felt exciting etc.

This is not a post for an argument just a civil debate please

well said

[WOMBAI]

Originally Posted by housemate

Blimey!! I thought we lived in a more tolerant, less judgemental society now!
Your saying that in order to be attractive she needs to lose weight? That all men will only go for the skinny gals, regardless of personality, kindness or emotion? WOW!!

Josie brings smiles to the house, she is loved by all of them, Dave even said he loved her .. I havent witnessed anybody making comments about her .. I think you've made that up to sway good opinion of her because you clearly don't like her.
As far as the tasks are concerned, she tries really hard ... what are you on about?
She cleans the bathroom, washes the dishes, tidies the garden AND cooks, what more do you want

Are you at all perceptive and realistic about life!

I am saying if Josie is so shallow and judges the men in her life by their looks (as she clearly does by her comments about his looks and the way she homed in on him from the start) then she has to be realistic enough to realise that they will probably judge her the same way - and will be put off by her weight! Fact of life - so get off your unrealistic high horse!

btw - do you actually watch the show - several hms have made comments about her and JJ lying in bed all day!

[housemate]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

Are you at all perceptive and realistic about life!

I am saying if Josie is so shallow and judges the men in her life by their looks (as she clearly does by her comments about his looks and the way she homed in on him from the start) then she has to be realistic enough to realise that they will probably judge her the same way - and will be put off by her weight! Fact of life - so get off your unrealistic high horse!

btw - do you actually watch the show - several hms have made comments about her and JJ lying in bed all day!

So how come JJ thinks the World of her AS she is? He is repulsed by comments about appearance!
What 'men in her life'? Do you know what her type is? Heres another fact of life for you, ..it takes allsorts, people like You judge her ... other People 'probably' don't, certainly not on the basis of her weight or perceived motives.
btw - other HMs JOKE about the bed-in! They all Love her to bits! I clealy listend (and watched) more closely .. with an unbiased heart.

[WOMBAI]

Originally Posted by housemate

So how come JJ thinks the World of her AS she is? He is repulsed by comments about appearance!
What 'men in her life'? Do you know what her type is? Heres another fact of life for you, ..it takes allsorts, people like You judge her ... other People 'probably' don't, certainly not on the basis of her weight or perceived motives.
btw - other HMs JOKE about the bed-in! They all Love her to bits! I clealy listend (and watched) more closely .. with an unbiased heart.

He may like her a lot - that is not the same thing! No one likes to see their friends being insulted - quite understandable! But he does not fancy her - that is soooo obvious - wait and see!

Josie has double-standards - she wants the 'fit' ones - but doesn't want them to judge her in the same way! And you support that?

[yellowzebra8]

Originally Posted by angiec

OK did say this was a debate not a list of things you THINK you know about her,

Yeah she got jealous Iv done that but it doesn't make me a bunny boiler and neither is she, think about it, if she was he would not be allowed to speak to anyone at all.

She thought Caiomhe was her friend and she got jelouse of running round after him when she was drunk in a see through shirt, also how close they got, again this is not a bunny boiler, it is normal behaviour in some.

The rest of the list is just silly

You're so right, the hate is just because she was the favourite to win, so some of the fans of all the other HM's try and turn people against her so their fave is more likely to win.
It happened to Kathreya, It happened to Freddie and its happening to Josie... I wouldn't be surprised if people start hating on Corin now.

[housemate]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

He may like her a lot - that is not the same thing! No one likes to see their friends being insulted - quite understandable! But he does not fancy her - that is soooo obvious - wait and see!

Josie has double-standards - she wants the 'fit' ones - but doesn't want them to judge her in the same way! And you support that?

I support the fact that you hate Josie and will fit a theory to any fact in order to blacken her as much as possible. Josie loves Andrew too, how does that fit in with your theory re: 'wanting the 'fit' ones'? You make no sense atall.
JJ doesn't judge people on appearance because he was bullied as a child, he more than 'likes' her and she is like a love sick puppy, she adores him!

[WOMBAI]

Originally Posted by yellowzebra8

You're so right, the hate is just because she was the favourite to win, so some of the fans of all the other HM's try and turn people against her so their fave is more likely to win.
It happened to Kathreya, It happened to Freddie and its happening to Josie... I wouldn't be surprised if people start hating on Corin now.

Some might be hate - the rest is pure logic and commonsense!

Josie is manipulating the relationship for airtime and votes - clear as crystal!

[housemate]

Originally Posted by WOMBAI

Some might be hate - the rest is pure logic and commonsense!

Josie is manipulating the relationship for airtime and votes - clear as crystal!

Yours is clearly based on hate! Whose common sense and logic ... yours? You asume she is being false in a bid to win and so its suddenly supposed to be crystal clear?
Are you for real ?

[WOMBAI]

Originally Posted by housemate

Yours is clearly based on hate! Whose common sense and logic ... yours? You asume she is being false in a bid to win and so its suddenly supposed to be crystal clear?
Are you for real ?

I assume nothing - it is obvious - the way she homed in on JJ right from day one harping on about his good looks!

As we all know that 'romance', fake or otherwise - get lots of attention on bb -commonsense dictates it was a lot more than coincidence that she 'fell' for him almost immediately!