[toby843]

Originally Posted by stonedape

She chose crab because she thinks those options mean something for the task and it's up to her to choose the option she wouldn't usually pick. That's why no HMs see her as disloyal for the choice, and no sane audience member should. As far as the thong lie, it was stupid but mostly said to lessen the chance of conflict, and she copped to it seconds later. Hardly falls in line with evil manipulator storyline some are going for here. Say JJ1 did buy the thong lie, what does that change at all? It's harmless, albeit stupid.

Sorry but neither of those options were ones that she wouldn't normally do. She picked the crab thing on purpose to upset JJames over the arguments they had before or to cause an argument.
I'm not into the whole manipulator thing but it does seem now Josie has her pass she is gunning for anyone who she thinks might be popular. Look at all the arguments yesterday and see where Josie fits into each one, right in the middle.
She is very disloyal, look at everything, remember the scrooge task? How often did we see her stuffing her face then without asking for a coin.
How often do we see her getting along with sam and saying she likes him, then how often do we see her saying she hates him to someone else.
How often do we see her start an argument then walk off and let them fight.
the whole Keeva thing, the playing JJames as much as he played her.
I'm sorry mate but Josie is devious and disloyal, she will always choose the task that works out best for her over the house.