[Hunx1985]

UBB has failed because not enough argumentative HM's have returned. And when they DID bring back a few good ones, they either kicked them out (Coolio) or let them fall victim to the public vote (McCririck).

Here's what the line up should have been:

1) Science
2) Victor
3) McCririck
4) Maxwell
5) Saskia
6) Derek
7) Makosi
8) Coolio
9) Charley
10) Marcus
11) Freddie
12) Bea
13) Ahmed
14) Channelle
15) Stephen Baldwin
16) Vinne Jones

The above 16 would have guaranteed entertainment. There are enough polar opposites there also to ensure arguments would be commonplace.

So far, we have Victor who MIGHT cause conflict but this is unlikely as he has no one to really argue with. Coolio MIGHT have been a potential rival but he was booted out (pathetic). If the above list was in we'd see a LOT more entertainment. So far though, it's been either spoiled by BB interfering (i.e. Telling McCririck to be 'nice'/throwing Coolio out) or ruined because BB didn't put in enough argumentative HMs.

Get Brian, Chantelle, Preston and Ulrika out!

[yousoboo!]

i really want to disagree with you but the last 4 days have been meh

[eye sea]

I disagree. I'm still finding UBB 100 times better than dreary BB11.

[Hunx1985]

Sea, I mentioned NO ONE from BB11. So your comment is null and void I'm afraid.

I agreed with you on another post in my other thread, but here you've really made a silly post.

[iRyan]

I disagree, and your list sucks.

Although I do agree Charley should be there.

[Hunx1985]

iRyan, my list includes the greatest HM's with most of them involved in heated arguments. The only exception really was Baldwin, but he was entertaining just being himself.

Now, iRyan, what would YOUR list be?

Go on, let's hear the bores YOU would include.

[eye sea]

Originally Posted by Hunx1985

Sea, I mentioned NO ONE from BB11. So your comment is null and void I'm afraid.

I agreed with you on another post in my other thread, but here you've really made a silly post.

The general view is to compare both BBs this summer.

[Hunx1985]

No, Sea, it is NOT.

The point of UBB was to bring back, you know, ULTIMATE HMs from BB past. The only BB11 HM to be included was this years winner, which is fair enough. That's why I didn't include Sam in my list (the only entertaining HM in BB11).

So, Sea, I'm afraid your previous post WAS pointless.

Anyway, I'd like to see WHY you think my list isn't a fantastic one. I think you'll find that the proposed list is far better than the current line up. BB history is proof of this, i.e. the HMs listed all provided much airtime/debate/arguments.

[icecakes]

my list would be
science
victor
liam
charlie
bubble
brian
rex
shabnam
emily
stuart
siavash
craig
sam

[Hunx1985]

Icecakes, not a bad list. Better than the current one but not quite up to my standards. 5/10.

[icecakes]

Originally Posted by Hunx1985

Icecakes, not a bad list. Better than the current one but not quite up to my standards. 5/10.

i missed sunshine off the list
carnt believe youve got derek on yours worst hm ever

[Lex]

Originally Posted by Hunx1985

UBB has failed because not enough argumentative HM's have returned. And when they DID bring back a few good ones, they either kicked them out (Coolio) or let them fall victim to the public vote (McCririck).

Here's what the line up should have been:

1) Science
2) Victor
3) McCririck
4) Maxwell
5) Saskia
6) Derek
7) Makosi
8) Coolio
9) Charley
10) Marcus
11) Freddie
12) Bea
13) Ahmed
14) Channelle
15) Stephen Baldwin
16) Vinne Jones

The above 16 would have guaranteed entertainment. There are enough polar opposites there also to ensure arguments would be commonplace.

So far, we have Victor who MIGHT cause conflict but this is unlikely as he has no one to really argue with. Coolio MIGHT have been a potential rival but he was booted out (pathetic). If the above list was in we'd see a LOT more entertainment. So far though, it's been either spoiled by BB interfering (i.e. Telling McCririck to be 'nice'/throwing Coolio out) or ruined because BB didn't put in enough argumentative HMs.

Get Brian, Chantelle, Preston and Ulrika out!

You're a genius Hunx!...(except the get Brian out thing)

[icecakes]

Originally Posted by Lex

You're a genius Hunx!...(except the get Brian out thing)

you dont like my list then

[Mystic Mock]

my list
1.luke
2.mario bb9
3.lisa bb9
4.freddie
5.siavash
6.marcus
7.coolio
8.john mccrick
9.michelle bass
10.victor
11.dan bb5
12.charley uchea
13.makosi
14.rebecca bb9
15.benjamin duncan
16.josie gibson

[Big_Kahuna]

Brian is fun. You would leave Luke Skywalker out of Star Wars....

[MusicMan]

For me, arguments do not equal entertainment. Yeah sure a bit of conflict adds to the drama and all but to deliberately put people in for the purpose of regular arguments? It's just uncomfortable viewing for me personally.
I'm rather happy with the lineup we have, bar a few, and I'm glad we got shot of that idiot McCririck off our screens. Disgusting man with horrible values.
I would have liked to see Aisleyne and Rodrigo in there if I were to change the lineup.
But for me, I don't like to see constant arguing on there - it's not nice to watch!

But hey ho, shoot me down for not sharing your opinion

[boomoo]

Originally Posted by MusicMan

For me, arguments do not equal entertainment. Yeah sure a bit of conflict adds to the drama and all but to deliberately put people in for the purpose of regular arguments? It's just uncomfortable viewing for me personally.
I'm rather happy with the lineup we have, bar a few, and I'm glad we got shot of that idiot McCririck off our screens. Disgusting man with horrible values.
I would have liked to see Aisleyne and Rodrigo in there if I were to change the lineup.
But for me, I don't like to see constant arguing on there - it's not nice to watch!

But hey ho, shoot me down for not sharing your opinion

True. But we dont know how many housemates were asked and turned it down or were busy doing something else.

[MusicMan]

Originally Posted by boomoo

True. But we dont know how many housemates were asked and turned it down or were busy doing something else.

Indeed, I suppose we can't take for granted that the housemates we have were the producers first choices

[reece(:]

should be

1. shahbaz
2. mary
3. dawn
4. laura bb11
5. david
6. shanessa
7. donny tourette
8. chris eubank
9. saffia
10. gaeteno
11. sunita
12. kitten
13. lucy pinder
14. bb7 jonathan

and in the bedsit

beinazir and hira

[luminoussun]

I do think your lists are bias towards the later years...you do need a few from 1 2 and 3 but not 3 from bb5 and 100% no dull celebs...as soon as i see preston 2nd person to go in the house i knew what the whole bloody show would be about.

[ange7]

Originally Posted by yousoboo!

i really want to disagree with you but the last 4 days have been meh

I stopped watching after day 3.
So rubbish.

[*mazedsalv**]

Originally Posted by ange7

I stopped watching after day 3.
So rubbish.

Your missing out on a fantastic series... last night was BB gold.

[robb]

Originally Posted by MusicMan

Indeed, I suppose we can't take for granted that the housemates we have were the producers first choices

Kate Lawler said she turned it down........TBH everybody will have a different set of HM'S who they think should be in. There is no guarantee that many of them wouldn't have 'kissed and made up'...after all they are Z listers with a bit of money now......even Victor has mellowed, Bass and Ahmed hugged, so did Hutton and Makosi etc etc.
I think we have to enjoy the entertainment it HAS provided, though I do agree there have been times (at nite!!) when they should have been made to do more. But their budgets would feed half of Pakistan nowadays.......the harsh treatment of the early BB has gone........and with it most of the big arguments.

[ange7]

Originally Posted by Salv

Your missing out on a fantastic series... last night was BB gold.

bb11 was great....ubb is kind of not.
hope they get in an ex hm from a recent series.

[TheEchelonxRawr!KP]

Your missing Sam Pepper and Pete Bennett . Your list is alrighty tbh