[Crimson Dynamo]

Just shows you that the judges talk out of their arses.

Grimshaw has got nothing, no charisma, no x-factor. he is just a young David Seaman look-a-like.

I expect he may get booted tonight, next week for sure.

[fruit_cake]

what a load of rubbish he's lovely

[Adamw92]

He's overrated, last night was an awful performance and it proved there are some serious limitations in his voice

[Smithy]

Simons been up all the acts arses this year, even when the performances have been s*it, he needs to go back to his old ways and tell him 'em how it is

[Bazladoo]

he was awful but will get the sympathy vote

[Jamietwo]

aiden was car crash tv last night. but he will stay

[joeysteele]

I think Simon is starting to get worried as to Mary actually, when it comes big band week is another week she will really excel at, as for Aiden, it was clear in rehearsals he had a problem with the song, Mostly he performed it well, its not one of my favourite Lennon songs.

However, having said that,Aiden has a unique style which will be suited to certain songs as with Mad World last week, Simon is right to say he has 'all' the attributes of a pop star and he will really bounce back next week I would expect,Dannii will take no more risks with a song he doesn't totally nail at rehearsals several times.

He doesn't need a sympathy vote, he does have immense talent and a very unique voice.As Matt does too.

[Crimson Dynamo]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

I think Simon is starting to get worried as to Mary actually, when it comes big band week is another week she will really excel at, as for Aiden, it was clear in rehearsals he had a problem with the song, Mostly he performed it well, its not one of my favourite Lennon songs.

However, having said that,Aiden has a unique style which will be suited to certian songs as with Mad World last week, Simon is right to say he has 'all' the attributes of a pop start and he will really bounce back next week I would expect,Dannii will take no more risks with a song he doesn't totally nail at rehearsals several times.

He doesn't need a sympathy vote, he does have immense talent and a very unique voice.As Matt does too.

eh?

can you explain "immense talent" ?

[alc09]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Simons been up all the acts arses this year, even when the performances have been s*it, he needs to go back to his old ways and tell him 'em how it is

This, he gives credit to **** performance like this one and Chers.

[reece(:]

Why does he always talk like he's a bit slow in the head or something.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Just shows you that the judges talk out of their arses.

Grimshaw has got nothing, no charisma, no x-factor. he is just a young David Seaman look-a-like.

I expect he may get booted tonight, next week for sure.

I think Simon knows more about the music business than most of us.

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

eh?

can you explain "immense talent" ?

Yes I can easily, his performance last week showed great intensity and was alao the most acclaimed performance of the night with his moody delivery of the song.
He didint do well last night but that will be a likely one off.

Aiden excelled at the auditions, boot camp and also the judges house.
He has a unique voice and also a unique style,very strong stage presence,and also a likeable persoanality.
That's enough to be going on with I think and there's likely loads more of his immense talent to come yet. As also there is with Matt too.

[joeysteele]

Immense talent as in stage presence, he conquered all before him last week, he excelled at the auditions, boot camp and judges house, he didn't do well ont he song last night but I think you will find most people agree that he has originality, has a unique voice, can deliver a song in various ways, such as last week, with a very moody and intense performance, actually, thats enough to be going on with as to clearly detailing his immense talent.

[Kazanne]

people moan when Simon is harsh and tells it like it is,when he softenes up ,this too is not good enough,lol,he cannot be everything to everyone,personally I liked it more when he was harsh,lol

[Jamietwo]

he frightened my elderly pussy last night

[Crimson Dynamo]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

Immense talent as in stage presence, he conquered all before him last week, he excelled at the auditions, boot camp and judges house, he didn't do well ont he song last night but I think you will find most people agree that he has originality, has a unique voice, can deliver a song in various ways, such as last week, with a very moody and intense performance, actually, thats enough to be going on with as to clearly detailing his immense talent.

yes, in other words you made it up

[Crimson Dynamo]

Originally Posted by kazanne

I think Simon knows more about the music business than most of us.

sometimes one needs to stand apart from it to see it for what it is

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by kazanne

I think Simon knows more about the music business than most of us.

I'm not sure thats true. He knows about making money in the music business but what does he know about Hip hop, urban etc. I always think Simon would be more at home on Dragons Den than on X-Factor. He's a money maker but what does he know about music on the streets other than its an area in which he has no credible artists. Hence the Cher hype.

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by kazanne

I think Simon knows more about the music business than most of us.

How true, he hasn't made his millions from backing pop stars and not being able to recognise true talent has he.He has been behind some really big stars.He will of course make mistakes too but they are few.

Simon does know what he is talking about and no 'leather trumpet', I made nothing up,????confusing statement since I answered in detail., I listed several main attributes needed to assume strong talent in an act, if you cannot see that then thats your problem, however I think even on here as to Aiden, a lot more people see the things I have listed in him than do not.Howver I have answered your question, sorry you don't like the answer.

[Crimson Dynamo]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

How true, he hasn't made his millions from pop stars backing and not being able to recognise true talent has he.He ahs been behind some really big stars.

Simon does know what he is talking about and no 'leather trumpet', I made nothing up, I listed several main attributes needed to assume strong talent in an act, if you cannot see that then thats your problem, however I think even on here as to Aiden, a lot more people see the things I have listed in him than do not.Howver I have answered your question, sorry you don't like the answer.

Simon knows about tv shows not music, hence his song choices and his poor form with winners.

Grimshaw is a hopeless case and just because you fancy him does not make him a star.

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Simon knows about tv shows not music, hence his song choices and his poor form with winners.

Grimshaw is a hopeless case and just because you fancy him does not make him a star.

You show some ignorance there and also supposition, first of all I am male so have no interest in Aiden in the offensive way you put it.
Simon has also been heavily involved in many stars careers, and if you are saying to name 2 that Leona Lewis and Westlife are are not massive stars(whether you like them or not) then you are very misgiuded.

I will ignore your insult as to your offensive and totally wrong comment on my sexual orientation and since I find no point in trying to reason with you I think its best we agree to disagree, however may I suggest you hold off insulting people personally as to who they may fancy or not, what their sexuality may be especially since you don't know them.

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Simon knows about tv shows not music, hence his song choices and his poor form with winners.

Grimshaw is a hopeless case and just because you fancy him does not make him a star.

I don't facy Aiden Grimshaw either,Simon?well that's a different kettle of fish,lol, I bet Simon has more money than most who claim to know 'more' about music than he does,so why aren't they fronting the X factor?difference is he has made millions,that was not done by accident ,he worked for it,unless of course these people who know 'better' are keeping quiet about their millions.

[Crimson Dynamo]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

You show some ignorance there and also supposition, first of all I am male so have no interest in Aiden in the offensive way you put it.
Simon has also been heavily involved in many stars careers, and if you are saying to name 2 that Leona Lewis and Westlife are are not massive stars(whether you like them or not) then you are very misgiuded.

I will ignore your insult as to your offensive and totally wrong comment on my sexual orientation and since I find no point in trying to reason with you I think its best we agree to disagree, however may I suggest you hold off insulting people personally as to who they may fancy or not, what their sexuality may be especially since you don't know them.

oh it was you who pressed the alert button

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

oh it was you who pressed the alert button

I haven't a clue what you are on about but please stop making direct comments to me because I find you extremely unreasonable and offensive.Thank you.

[sooty]

It is funny. I thought about Simon Cowell as well last night.

I said to my husband, what matter with him this year.