[Smithy]

Wagner. but she deserves to stay over him

[dannyboy]

I hope they save Katie over Mary! I really want that bore out, possibly even more than i want wagner out! i think next time katie's bottom 2 they will get rid of her though.

[tate]

the possible katie v Wagner is interesting

Treyc beat Katie hands down for vocal talent
Katie beats Wagner hands down for vocal talent

BUT ... Cowell decided to keep Katie over Treyc based on who he found interesting and entertaining

So, should those 2 be in the bottom this week how exactly will it be judged? Given that the voting public is obviously more supportive (so far) of Wagner it would be very interesting to see how Cowell would cast his vote on these 2 given his reasoning last weekend

[fancydressmasks]

Originally Posted by tate

It is trivialising him but until they do something completely out of left field with him and show some versatility then he will unfortunately be sold like a trend puppet - remember his 1st audition? Totally different to anything he has done ont eh live shows where they seem to insist on him portraying a dark, intense almost character

I also agree that I feel he is a lot more than this but unfortunately the tweens vote ... i would just love to see him do something more upbeat to showcase that fab personality

I agree. I actually do love the darkness and intensity and I think that is partly Aiden, but it's quite obviously not all he is. I really think they need to shake it up a bit, and let him do some more upbeat stuff. I'd love it if he performed Gold Digger in full one show, because that was incredible.

It is like they're trying to make him into a character, which is obviously to make him 'interesting' but I feel they've missed the point that he already was interesting. Even watching his Gold Digger performance, I still feel he's got everything that's in his current performances - although it is an upbeat song there's still an intensity about the way he performs, and he still looks completely engrossed/lost in the song, which is one of the main things I love about Aiden. Only difference is he looks a lot more relaxed somehow than he does now in the live shows. They don't need to make him dark to make him interesting. I sometimes feel that they underestimate the public's intelligence - like the public wouldn't find Aiden interesting unless they stamped a character onto him.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Niamhxo

Personally I think that as all of the contestants left bar Katie have never been in the bottom 2 and this will be Katies 4th time then they shouldn't save her over anyone, including Wagner. If they save her again Simon is just saying a big ****** you to everyone who wasted their money voting

i agree with this 100%,why should anybody think its acceptable for wagner to lose to katie but not anyone else whoes never hit the bottom 2 before?