[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by JamesWBB

What has she actually done wrong herself? I was watching Xtra Factor yesterday, and a caller was insulting almost everything about her, and what puzzles me is that she doesn't even know Katie as a person.

We dont know any of them as a person...therefore we have to judge on how they appear on screen, as the caller said.

I think some of the hate came from her being picked over gamu, which wasnt her fault. And some came from the judges obvious favoritism...which isnt her fault either.

However, I havent really seen anything I could class as 'hate' over here(DS is another matter...some people there are awful), more just people being sick of her being back week after week after being in the bottom two. And the fact that she is not a good singer, has forgot her words a few times...and the whole 'sod it' giving up performance. And she DOES come across as way too desperate, and spoilt IMO.