[Benjamin]

Cheers Shaun, as if we were not confused enough as it was.

[Lee.]

Yikes.. be back in 15

[Z]

Nick, Johnny, Morgan, Lewis, Melanie, Michael, Nina, Sarah, Sky
Shore, Strauss, Drake, Woodhouse, Green, Crane, Marshall, Prince, Whitehall

Bit of detective work... If we are to assume that N, M and S are all contained in the killer's name, then the following combinations of names work:

Nick Marshall
Johnny Marshall
Morgan Shore
Morgan Strauss
Morgan Woodhouse
Morgan Marshall
Melanie Shore
Melanie Strauss
Melanie Woodhouse
Melanie Marshall
Nina Marshall


Therefore definitely innocent: Lewis, Michael, Sarah, Sky - because in none of the surnames do the letters M/N or N/S appear together, meaning the killer's surname either has a single M, N, S or the combination of M/S... so Drake and Whitehall are innocent.


^^Updated version of my previous post

Edit: The confirmed names list:

Braden = Nick
GypsyGoth = Johnny
LemonJam = Morgan

happyland = 1 isolation
MTVN = 1 isolation
Zee = 1 isolation

Jordan = 0 isolations
Niall = 0 isolations
ukturtle = 0 isolations

[Benjamin]

Originally Posted by Zee

Nick, Johnny, Morgan, Lewis, Melanie, Michael, Nina, Sarah, Sky
Shore, Strauss, Drake, Woodhouse, Green, Crane, Marshall, Prince, Whitehall

Bit of detective work... If we are to assume that N, M and S are all contained in the killer's name, then the following combinations of names work:

Nick Marshall
Johnny Marshall
Morgan Shore
Morgan Strauss
Morgan Woodhouse
Morgan Marshall
Melanie Shore
Melanie Strauss
Melanie Woodhouse
Melanie Marshall
Nina Marshall


Therefore definitely innocent: Lewis, Michael, Sarah, Sky - because in none of the surnames do the letters M/N or N/S appear together, meaning the killer's surname either has a single M, N, S or the combination of M/S... so Drake and Whitehall are innocent.


^^Updated version of my previous post

And yay for task tonight.

[Niall]

Omg I hope the task ain't too long running. I haz school tomorrow.

[Shaun]

Just to confuse you further

If the Killer is sent to Isolation, they're bound to bring back a false clue. Not saying this has happened, but just something to bear in mind. smug2

[Niall]

^

[Benjamin]

So if we have had one clue which isn't real, that meansx that the killer has already survived?


Did we get a clue when Smithy died?

[Z]

Originally Posted by shaun

just to confuse you further :d

if the killer is sent to isolation, they're bound to bring back a false clue. not saying this has happened, but just something to bear in mind. Smug2

********************************* ********** * ***** ************* **** **** ******* ****!!!!!!

[Z]

But you said we've already had a hoax clue! So does that mean ukturtle, Niall and Jordan are innocent? !!

[Benjamin]

Originally Posted by Zee

But you said we've already had a hoax clue! So does that mean ukturtle, Niall and Jordan are innocent? !!

But we haven't got a clue after every murder and it doesn't mean that the killer has brought back a clue yet. Shaun never said a one of the clues was hoax, he said one of the hints was which included the clues. It could have been one of the other hints that he had in that list.

[Niall]

Originally Posted by Zee

But you said we've already had a hoax clue! So does that mean ukturtle, Niall and Jordan are innocent? !!

[Shaun]

The hoax clue was just a random hoax I threw in.

So there's definitely one false clue. HOWEVER there may be more if the Killer has been sent to Isolation.

Clue 1 - Task 1 - Letter N
Clue 2 - Task 2 - chalk.
Clue 3 - Task 3 - random Isolation, no clue.
Clue 4 - Task 4 - Letter S. Might be a lie.
Clue 5 - Task 5 - Disc with M on it. (the surnames are not lies, these would have been revealed anyway ) The M might be though.

[MTVN]

We thought the chalk may have been a hoax clue and if it was then Claudia, Braden, LemonJam & Zee were the 4 who survived that murder..

Oh the hoax clue was just random

[Benjamin]

The letter s? So not a double 's' but just a single.

[MTVN]

Oh God, I'm so confused

[Benjamin]

Who found the chalk clue?

[Shaun]

Task #6: Deadline
using death puns <3

You have until midnight to carry out a set of specific instructions set out by yours truly. happyland, part of your extra responsibility is to pass on information to those who require it.

I shall PM happyland a series of codes, statements and phrases that need to be posted by detectives before midnight - the deadline.

However, to make things more difficult - ALL detectives must post at least one of the phrases.

Rules:
- happyland has a time limit of an hour between receiving instructions and informing a detective to post her instructions.
- Noone can discuss the instructions in posts - only PMs.
- all 10 words/codes/phrases/instructions must be posted before midnight.
- all 9 detectives must post one.

[Niall]

Tyvm for throwing that spanner in the works Shaun.

And that was Claudia who found the chalk?

[Benjamin]

Jordan isn't here tonight.

[Niall]

Ok guys for that task, ima need to get it out of the way quickly. I need mah sleep.

[Z]

Originally Posted by ukturtle

Jordan isn't here tonight.

and I'm going out and meant to be going to a friend's beforehand in about 10 minutes...


-stays in for longer-

[MTVN]

Hopefully Jordan will be back before midnight..

[Benjamin]

Originally Posted by MTVN

Hopefully Jordan will be back before midnight..

He won't be, he said he was out for the night.

[Benjamin]

Right firstly, who won't be on for much longer?

You guys should post first.

Make a list of the order we go in.


I'll happily go last as I'm here all night.