[MusicXian]

Originally Posted by bbfan1991

Bitter, although i've always liked Louis as a judge.

Louis has the experience and he's mad some silly choices before but I still believe he's been forced by the producers before to put certain people through and I don't believe that all the judges make their own choices.

Maybe i'm just too suspicious of the producers motives now?

I doubt Louis would really be pressured by the producers, I personally just think that is what he chooses because he realises these wacko acts can go reasonably far for him. More than a talented Carolynne for example as there are younger girls with better voices than her, so he needs to look for something else.

I have no doubt if Louis had the girls this year he would have put Melanie and Jade through instead of Sophie and Amelia or Misha. Simply because he knows he would get the Irish and Scottish vote to get these girls far.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by bbfan1991

Bitter, although i've always liked Louis as a judge.

Louis has the experience and he's mad some silly choices before but I still believe he's been forced by the producers before to put certain people through and I don't believe that all the judges make their own choices.

Maybe i'm just too suspicious of the producers motives now?

This is what I think too.

[AndyEssex1]

I don't like to see any bias on The X Factor but obviously there is plenty. The worst is always from Louie if you're from Dublin. It's almost as if he's blind to anyone else. Mary Byrne (yuk!), Jedward and Nadine Coyle to name three, although Nadine was brilliant in the Irish Pop Idol but got thrown out because she was only 15 but lied to say she was 16. Another stunning voice to get a little lost these days. Shane Ward should have been huge. What is Alexandra really doing these days? Is her singing career over? and what is left of Leona? Her singing style is now quite dated. Times (and charts) have moved on from the Leona/Mariah type.

[newyorkjgjg]

He is so boring and chooses acts based on his sexual fantasies as opposed to real talent that he overlooks...
Goldie and johnny makes the show look like a discrace!


Gary sees that lou is a old boring drag queen you can tell