[Me. I Am Salman]

If she was so much in the limelight, You Da One would at least have reached the top 10

[Vladimir]

Oh ffs, WFL was HUGE and overshadowed it. YDO shoudn't have been released in the first place, it's one of Rihanna's worst singles.

[Callum]

You Da One bombed because it was crap, should never have been released as a single let alone made the album.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by Vladimir

Oh ffs, WFL was HUGE and overshadowed it. YDO shoudn't have been released in the first place, it's one of Rihanna's worst singles.

That's what I said and someone disagreed with it

And YDO wasn't her worst song, although I do agree that she shouldn't have released it

The title of worst single goes to anything from Rated R

[Callum]

Originally Posted by Salman!

That's what I said and someone disagreed with it

And YDO wasn't her worst song, although I do agree that she shouldn't have released it

The title of worst single goes to anything from Rated R

Rated R >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> anything from TTT bar Where Have You Been and WFL.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by Callum

Rated R >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> anything from TTT bar Where Have You Been and WFL.

Almost threw up on my screen
Rated R deserves a slow, painful death, its so miserable and emo-ish
TTT is way better
and where have you been and wfl aren't even all that

-Cockiness
-Birthday Cake
-Watch N Learn
-Talk That Talk
-Do Ya Thang
-Red Lipstick

> Rated R


Rated R makes me feel suicidal

[Callum]

Originally Posted by Salman!

Almost threw up on my screen
Rated R deserves a slow, painful death, its so miserable and emo-ish
TTT is way better
and where have you been and wfl aren't even all that

-Cockiness
-Birthday Cake
-Watch N Learn
-Talk That Talk
-Do Ya Thang
-Red Lipstick

> Rated R


Rated R makes me feel suicidal

It also happens to be her most critically acclaimed album.

All them songs you listed are mediocre at best. TTT has like three or four good tracks, the rest are dull filler material. Every song on Rated R is amazing.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by Callum

It also happens to be her most critically acclaimed album.

All them songs you listed are mediocre at best. TTT has like three or four good tracks, the rest are dull filler material. Every song on Rated R is amazing.

But it also happens to be a flop saleswise (sold less than its predecessor and successor)

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by Callum

It also happens to be her most critically acclaimed album.

All them songs you listed are mediocre at best. TTT has like three or four good tracks, the rest are dull filler material. Every song on Rated R is amazing.

But it also happens to be a flop saleswise and on the charts (sold less than its predecessor and successor) Therefore there was something wrong with it.

[Doogle]

Tracks like Hard, Fire Bomb & G4L will always be better than songs like Skin, Watch N Learn, Roc Me Out etc.

[Callum]

Originally Posted by Salman!

But it also happens to be a flop saleswise and on the charts (sold less than its predecessor and successor) Therefore there was something wrong with it.

So what? Sales mean nothing, it doesn't have to be a huge seller to be amazing. Loud sold millions of copies and it's a load of crap.

[Niall]

I think I'm starting to hate her.

I wish she'd just go away for a while ffs.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by Doogle

Tracks like Hard, Fire Bomb & G4L will always be better than songs like Skin, Watch N Learn, Roc Me Out etc.

your making me vomit seriously
Skin was the best track on Loud
an Watch N Learn is one of the best tracks of TTT
Roc Me Out is okay

But they all own that crap album RR

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by Callum

So what? Sales mean nothing, it doesn't have to be a huge seller to be amazing. Loud sold millions of copies and it's a load of crap.

Can't believe you would say something so disgusting
Loud is my second favourite album.. if not my favourite album.. OF ALL TIME.

[Callum]

Originally Posted by Salman!

Can't believe you would say something so disgusting
Loud is my second favourite album.. if not my favourite album.. OF ALL TIME.

You really do have appalling music taste.

[Niall]

Originally Posted by Salman!

your making me vomit seriously
Skin was the best track on Loud
an Watch N Learn is one of the best tracks of TTT
Roc Me Out is okay

But they all own that crap album RR

Rated R's reviews and critical reception:

Spoiler:

Rated R received positive reviews from most music critics.

Chicago Sun-Times writer Jim DeRogatis noted a maturity from Rihanna, calling it her "best, most layered and most heartfelt effort". NME's Ailbhe Malone called it "a startlingly masculine record – in sound and in attitude". Ed Potton of The Times gave it four out of five stars and described it as "By turns syrupy and strident, part lament, part tooled-up revenge fantasy... the best record Rihanna has made".

From Wikipedia.

TTT's critical reception:

Spoiler:

"Behind Good Girl Gone Bad and Rated R, this is Rihanna's third best album to date. Minus the fluff, it's close to the latter's equal." - Andy Kellman from Allmusic.

Jason Lipshutz of Billboard also gave the album a positive review, but commented on its feeling of having been "rushed". "After reclaiming her crown on Loud... Rihanna is not about to take any sort of break to let her pop princess competitors catch up" He also said, "[Talk That Talk is] an oddly rushed-out release to the objective music fan. Why not wait a bit and let the buzz of Loud set in?." Matthew Cole from Slant Magazine gave the album 2.5 stars out of 5, saying it is "pretty easily the worst Rihanna album yet, though I wouldn't be surprised to see her break that record next November"

From Wikipedia.

yoU ARE WRONG NOW BE QUIET.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Yes but critics arselick emotional crap
I hate emotional crap
unless its a R&B ballad

[Me. I Am Salman]

And btw 64/100 is a good score
Rated R just scored 12 higher

[Niall]

Originally Posted by Salman!

Yes but critics arselick emotional crap
I hate emotional crap
unless its a R&B ballad

They "arselick emotional crap" because that's what makes great music! Its not some barefaced attempt at topping the charts with ****ty filler throughout!

JESUS.

[Callum]

Originally Posted by Salman!

Yes but critics arselick emotional crap
I hate emotional crap
unless its a R&B ballad

No they don't, they loved it because it's a great album. I pity anyone who can't see that or who would rather listen to crappy autotuned tracks on Talk That Talk or Loud.

[Niall]

Originally Posted by Callum

No they don't, they loved it because it's a great album. I pity anyone who can't see that or who would rather listen to crappy autotuned tracks on Talk That Talk or Loud.

[Jords]

Rated R


Salman you are trying to hate it too much.

[Jords]

Originally Posted by Salman!

Yes but critics arselick emotional crap
I hate emotional crap
unless its a R&B ballad

Youtube video

This is amazing.

[Me. I Am Salman]

The Last Song is one of the worst

compare it to hate that i love you

Youtube video

and you'll see what i mean when I say that its crap

tell me how the last song is better

[Niall]

Originally Posted by Salman!

tell me how the last song is better

It's better. Much much much better.

Now please stop fgs.