[Legend killer]

So with two of The most laughable teams in the premier league to the final do you think the cup has lost its appeal. I think so like the Carling Cup the Big Teams are using it as a way giving playing time to the reserves and those returning from injury which shows gone are the days where the cup ment something and was a major note on your calender

[King Gizzard]

..would you be saying this if United had gotten through?

The FA Cup is fine, the only thing that needs changing is the Semi's played at Old Trafford/Emirates instead of Wembley

[Mystic Mock]

Your right Legend Killer, to be honest I think I actually prefer The Carling Cup to The FA Cup now, especially when they allow Referee's that favour a team to be incharge of a semi final match between that favoured team and another team.

[Locke.]

Both are better than the league and champions league to be fair, everyone knows this.

[Legend killer]

Johnstone paint trophy owns the FA Cup in passion and thats what the cup should be about

SAD BUT TRUE

[Legend killer]

Johnstone paint trophy owns the FA Cup in passion and thats what the cup should be about

SAD BUT TRUE

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Locke.

Both are better than the league and champions league to be fair, everyone knows this.

I completely disagree with this, I think The Champions League and Premier League are much stronger.

[Locke.]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

I completely disagree with this, I think The Champions League and Premier League are much stronger.

That is a very silly way to look at the situation

[Legend killer]

Spoken Like a true Liverpool fan

[MTVN]

These two teams are a lot better than some who have made the final recently; in the last 8 years Stoke, Portsmouth, Cardiff and Millwall have made it, so no I wouldn't say it's got a lot worse this year