[Marcus.]

so far two act gone for joke acts

[Samuel.]

Watching people get over dramatic over X Factor is a lot more enjoyable than watching the show itself.

[Maia]

Mock is on fire tonight

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

But District3 aren't characters, they are just a very boring boyband and at best average vocalists (that's me being kind btw) noway should they have stayed tonight.

Yes Im quite well aware of that...

Just saying if there hadnt been such a 'shock' elimination last week (though it wasnt a shock really) I doubt anyone would be getting so worked up this week over the result. There HAD to be a 'shock' last week because of who the b2 were.

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

Yes Im quite well aware of that...

Just saying if there hadnt been such a 'shock' elimination last week (though it wasnt a shock really) I doubt anyone would be getting so worked up this week over the result. There HAD to be a 'shock' last week because of who the b2 were.

Yeah, thinking about it outside of what happened last week it just seems like a standard elimination

[Black Dagger]

She's a stupid bitch.

But Melanie came last in the votes, so I can't really rage.

It was a fair enough decision.

[Merry Mockmas]

Originally Posted by Apple202

Yeah, thinking about it outside of what happened last week it just seems like a standard elimination

How? Melanie was very good where as District3 sing out of tune with each other, even the teenage girls aren't voting for them fgs, they should have gone.

[Marcus.]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

How? Melanie was very good where as District3 sing out of tune with each other, even the teenage girls aren't voting for them fgs, they should have gone.

Well said

[Vicky.]

I dont think Melanie was very good in the singoff if Im honest. I seriously expected her to wipe the floor with the boyband, but she just shouted her way through a song that I had never heard before. Gary made a horrible song choice for her yesterday too, same as he did with Carolyn last week. Melanie, if given the right songs, would have made it at least past the halfway point IMO.

[Black Dagger]

Originally Posted by Jamie585

first bad decision and everyone hates her suddenly? She hasn't made one bad decision yet, he's been the best mentor so far, She has picked great songs for all her acts and is the only Judge not to have had a contestant in the bottom 2, says it all really

She has good acts... (well those liked within the GBP anyway) if she mentored Carolynne/Melanie I'm sure they'd have still gone.

I don't see how this makes her superior to everybody else because she has 3 well liked acts who were never going to be B2 in the early weeks.

[Merry Mockmas]

Originally Posted by Black Dagger

She's a stupid bitch.

But Melanie came last in the votes, so I can't really rage.

It was a fair enough decision.

So when Olly Murs came last over Jedward a few years ago should he have gone then? or these same people that are saying about Melanie came last in the votes tbf argument but in the same breath complain about Simon's decision to evict Lucie Jones over Jedward can't really have it both ways as tbf he sent it to deadlock and Lucie came bottom of the votes.

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

How? Melanie was very good where as District3 sing out of tune with each other, even the teenage girls aren't voting for them fgs, they should have gone.

I know Melanie is very good, but I'm not going to hold this against Tulisa. I didn't with Louis and I'm not going to with Tulisa either. Besides, technically public vote is the best and fairest way of deciding who leaves.

[Jamie585]

tbh.. Melanie is great!! but she wouldn't get that far.. young viewers wouldn't spend money on her.. because there too busy getting wet over the 'boybands' haha

[Marcus.]

melaine was better the out of tune district3

[Jamie585]

why do you have them in your sig then? ^^

[Doogle]

Originally Posted by Jamie585

tbh.. Melanie is great!! but she wouldn't get that far.. young viewers wouldn't spend money on her.. because there too busy getting wet over the 'boybands' haha

But Matt and Rebecca managed to consistently get more votes than 1D, and I bet when we see the final results the boybands won't be anywhere near top of the votes, that's what I don't get. It was just an unlucky week for her I think.

[Vicky.]

Originally Posted by Jamie585

why do you have them in your sig then? ^^

[Merry Mockmas]

Originally Posted by Jamie585

why do you have them in your sig then? ^^

Because his got them in the Sweepstake I think.

[Jamie585]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

Because his got them in the Sweepstake I think.

hmm.. still if you hate an act i wouldn't have them in my sig

[Merry Mockmas]

Originally Posted by Jamie585

hmm.. still if you hate an act i wouldn't have them in my sig

Neither would I but it's his very brave choice I suppose.

[Marcus.]

Originally Posted by Jamie585

why do you have them in your sig then? ^^

my sweepstake judge as soon as they are out the well gone

[Jake.]

so i take it the boy band stayed?

[Marcus.]

Originally Posted by The Mockinator

Neither would I but it's his very brave choice I suppose.

judge sweepstake that the only thing why it in mu sig as soon as they are out they gone

[Merry Mockmas]

Originally Posted by JH95

so i take it the boy band stayed?

Sadly yes.

[Marcus.]

Originally Posted by JH95

so i take it the boy band stayed?

yes they are