[Alf]

Originally Posted by Apple202

Whether she's a saint or not has nothing to do with this, Tulisa was giving valid criticism and because he had no withstanding response Gary resorted to immaturely insulting her.

valid criticism? she wasn't even critiqueing (is that a word?) the singer, she was trying to score points against barlow and got shut down

[Apple202]

Originally Posted by wannashag

valid criticism? she wasn't even critiqueing (is that a word?) the singer, she was trying to score points against barlowm and got shut down

She was critiquing the choices Gary had made for Chris' song choices, and I'm quite certain that the judges have always, since the start, passed judgement on the song choices, and who are these chosen by? The mentors. I don't get what's not valid about her criticism.