[Saph]

britney and the spice girls were the first two things I stanned for when I was young

[reece(:]

Originally Posted by Saph

britney and the spice girls were the first two things I stanned for when I was young

and still to this day, both have iconic music catalogues

[Daniel.]

I used to be ****ing obsessed with the spice girls..hats, posters, the dvd on all the time, duvet cover and constantly playing the albums

[reece(:]

Originally Posted by Daniel_

I used to be ****ing obsessed with the spice girls..hats, posters, the dvd on all the time, duvet cover and constantly playing the albums

correct this error.

[Joelle.]

Originally Posted by Z

They put out 12 singles and 3 albums over 4 years, it's not like they were around for a particularly long time. The bloody Saturdays have lasted longer than them and had more hits! And we all know they couldn't hold a tune to save their lives. There's no denying how huge they were and how much of a cultural impact they had but I feel like people overhype their music.

What kinda Saturdays drag?

Also Spice Up Your Life is better than anything by Girls Aloud, Sugababes or The Sats. Iconic anthem.

[james130]

Originally Posted by Juan_Sheet

Also Spice Up Your Life is better than anything by Girls Aloud, Sugababes or The Sats. Iconic anthem.

Sexy! No No No... >>>>>>

[Pete.]

Confirmed

[Jake.]

Well all of their songs are overrated so I couldn't possibly comment

[Z]

Originally Posted by Juan_Sheet

What kinda Saturdays drag?

Also Spice Up Your Life is better than anything by Girls Aloud, Sugababes or The Sats. Iconic anthem.

Spice Up Your Life is better than anything else by the Spice Girls but I'd say Girls Aloud and Sugababes each have at least half a dozen songs that **** all over the Spice Girls' discography

[james130]

Originally Posted by Z

Spice Up Your Life is better than anything else by the Spice Girls but I'd say Girls Aloud and Sugababes each have at least half a dozen songs that **** all over the Spice Girls' discography

[Samm]

Originally Posted by Juan_Sheet

Also Spice Up Your Life is better than anything by Girls Aloud, Sugababes or The Sats. Iconic anthem.

This. but

Sound of the underground & Push the button

[iRyan]

Originally Posted by Saph

britney and the spice girls were the first two things I stanned for when I was young

Flawless taste

[iRyan]

You can't compare Spice Girls and Girls Aloud music in my opinion, that's two completely different eras of music. Obviously Girls Aloud music sounds better in comparison because of modern technological advances in music production and additional years of inspiration and references. But Girls Aloud probably would never have existed if it weren't for the Spice Girls. The Spice Girls, at the time, were so fresh and like no other girl group that ever existed. And also, don't get me wrong I love Girls Aloud, but they do not have the same star quality and enigmatic personalities the Spice Girls had. Spice Girls knew they were not the most vocally talented but they made up for it in all other areas.

Xenomania is one of the main reasons Girls Aloud was great.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Girls Aloud & Spice Girls are both overrated
Sugababes & PCD **** on lives >>

[iRyan]

Originally Posted by Salman!

Girls Aloud & Spice Girls are both overrated
Sugababes & PCD **** on lives >>

I refuse to even accept PCD as a legitimate girl group. It's Nicole Scherzinger and her troupe of dancers with 1 or 2 who occassionally provide background vocals.

[Me. I Am Salman]

i wouldn't have had it any other way. they'd have been terrible otherwise

[reece(:]

Originally Posted by Salman!

i wouldn't have had it any other way. they'd have been terrible otherwise

this is completely wrong

jessica and melody both have great voices

[reece(:]

Still iconic

[Marc]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Youtube video

A classic

[LaLaLand]

This >>

Youtube video

[MB.]

Say You'll Be There > everything

[Marsh.]

Stop right now.

[Marsh.]

Thank you very much.

[Z]

Originally Posted by iRyan

You can't compare Spice Girls and Girls Aloud music in my opinion, that's two completely different eras of music. Obviously Girls Aloud music sounds better in comparison because of modern technological advances in music production and additional years of inspiration and references. But Girls Aloud probably would never have existed if it weren't for the Spice Girls. The Spice Girls, at the time, were so fresh and like no other girl group that ever existed. And also, don't get me wrong I love Girls Aloud, but they do not have the same star quality and enigmatic personalities the Spice Girls had. Spice Girls knew they were not the most vocally talented but they made up for it in all other areas.

Xenomania is one of the main reasons Girls Aloud was great.

All valid points which I accept but musically, Girls Aloud (and Sugababes) are far superior to Spice Girls, which is where it counts when discussing music, of course. The Spice Girls were about many things and the music they released was secondary to their personalities, the wave of feminism and the other media forays they made. Do you think Geri Halliwell got four #1 singles because she's a fantastic popstar or because she was the first Spice Girl to jump ship because she knew she had to take advantage of how fast paced their careers had been and she wanted to be "the first" at the next step in their career? I'd say the latter. She can't hold a tune to save her life, she knows that better than anyone, she just rode their wave of popularity to the best of her abilities, as they all ended up doing. They're celebrities who happen to be popstars, not the other way round. In that sense, Girls Aloud and Spice Girls are comparable, except not every member of Girls Aloud is determined to be famous (Nadine and Nicola) like the Spice Girls are.

[BigSister]

Yes thank you someone else who loves love thing. That's my fave spice girl song
Although out of all the singles probably say you be there for me as that was the first spice girl single I loved. then probably spice up your life and Too much