[karl100589]

I agree with Macey, Whilst I respect Janelles competition prowess I have always been of the belief that if you rely on comps to remain in the game then it demonstrates the flaws in the rest of your game, and Janelle is evidence of this to me. You just need to look at her four HOH wins as proof of that, in her four reigns she ended up taking out Allison, the most blatant easy target in the game, Diane who couldn't be bothered to play, Marcellas her biggest ally in the game and Chicken George who posed no threat to anyone in the game. Compare that to Will who won absolutely nothing in two seasons and in both seasons mastered the endgame brilliantly and would have won Allstars if not for one slip up.

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by karl100589

I agree with Macey, Whilst I respect Janelles competition prowess I have always been of the belief that if you rely on comps to remain in the game then it demonstrates the flaws in the rest of your game, and Janelle is evidence of this to me. You just need to look at her four HOH wins as proof of that, in her four reigns she ended up taking out Allison, the most blatant easy target in the game, Diane who couldn't be bothered to play, Marcellas her biggest ally in the game and Chicken George who posed no threat to anyone in the game. Compare that to Will who won absolutely nothing in two seasons and in both seasons mastered the endgame brilliantly and would have won Allstars if not for one slip up.

George was a threat though? he would of got votes to win if he was in the F2

[karl100589]

Originally Posted by LukeB

George was a threat though? he would of got votes to win if he was in the F2

Nobody would have voted for George to win in a final two, to the others he was nothing more then a glorified janitor keeping the house clean while the real players did their business. I do love George in Allstars as a great comedy value housemate but I'm the first to admit he was godawful as a player.

[Macie Lightfoot]

Originally Posted by karl100589

I agree with Macey, Whilst I respect Janelles competition prowess I have always been of the belief that if you rely on comps to remain in the game then it demonstrates the flaws in the rest of your game, and Janelle is evidence of this to me.

It's one thing if you just needed to win a competition couldn't. However, Janelle won many comps and had a lot of opportunities to hold some power, but she didn't capitalize on it at all. She sucks.

[reece(:]

Originally Posted by Macie Lightfoot

It's one thing if you just needed to win a competition couldn't. However, Janelle won many comps and had a lot of opportunities to hold some power, but she didn't capitalize on it at all. She sucks.

I thought gameplay didn't count towards your entertainment basis