[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Lostie!

I have heard something about that Hanna twin theory actually. Someone pointed out two occasions where Red Coat stops and looks at Hanna as she's looking at her reflection (in a window and in a mirror), it would be interesting if that was intentional. And then there's Hanna being the only one Alison had to pull out of the lodge fire, meaning whoever pulled the others out left Hanna.

Though, I don't want A to be someone's twin, because that's just having it be a someone we don't know, which I hate in mysteries. I want it to be someone we know properly.

I'm still hoping for Wren (obviously working with a woman, unless he crossdresses every now and again ).

Yep, and there was an ending where A took a blowtorch to a hanna doll and and the end of S4E1 (i think) after black widow has been to the funeral she takes her veil off and her alison mask is half burnt

I think whoever A is has really bad facial scars

edit; found the theory

Spoiler: