[Lostie!]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Welp, found out what CHARLES is for the season finale, perched for everyone doubting my A theory to come running saying that they knew all along

You found out or read a theory?

All we have right now are theories to be fair. Not even all of the actors know who A is yet.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Lostie!

You found out or read a theory?

All we have right now are theories to be fair. Not even all of the actors know who A is yet.

found out

Even if the actors don't know, there's been enough clues in the show for people to work out

[Lostie!]

Originally Posted by Smithy

found out

Even if the actors don't know, there's been enough clues in the show for people to work out

So, what you read isn't merely a theory but a 100% iron-clad spoiler of an A reveal? Because the official reveal isn't even coming until next season.

There are clues pointing in various directions, to be fair. I've seen convincing theories about different characters.

Still, if yours turns out to be correct, I certainly won't claim to have known all along. Not sure why I would tbh.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Lostie!

So, what you read isn't merely a theory but a 100% iron-clad spoiler of an A reveal? Because the official reveal isn't even coming until next season.

There are clues pointing in various directions, to be fair. I've seen convincing theories about different characters.

Still, if yours turns out to be correct, I certainly won't claim to have known all along. Not sure why I would tbh.

The Charles reveal I read is correct, which pointed towards one thing which can only lead to one person

A lot of the fan theories online (if not all of them) have 0 revealed motive for A, whereas Marlene has said numerous times that if you watch closely enough it's already been revealed and there are numerous clues pointing in their direction

[Lostie!]

Originally Posted by Smithy

The Charles reveal I read is correct, which pointed towards one thing which can only lead to one person

A lot of the fan theories online (if not all of them) have 0 revealed motive for A, whereas Marlene has said numerous times that if you watch closely enough it's already been revealed and there are numerous clues pointing in their direction

Sorry if I'm sounding arsey, it's not meant in that way, but my point was just that what you read has to have been a theory rather than a flat-out reveal because we're not getting that yet. A highly likely theory with convincing evidence to back it up sure, but there's a difference between that and finding out for a fact.

I like to keep my options open until the show confirms something without a shadow of a doubt. As I said, it's all part of the fun. We all have our theories that we like to consider, and good on whoever gets it right.