[Lostie!]

Originally Posted by LukeB

yeah, when he thought Spencer was the mother?

Yeah. I read a theory that suggested he is Wren's father (his father had schizophrenia and I read that older people with that can have a higher risk of dementia).

Obviously the Wren theories are my favourites . So, knowing my luck, he'll never be seen again.

I love these sort of theories that link together characters who have no apparent connection and make you look at everything in a new light, I find it really interesting. And also, even when they turn out wrong, it's cool to see people go into so much detail and think of really cool scenarios.

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Lostie!

Yeah. I read a theory that suggested he is Wren's father (his father had schizophrenia and I read that older people with that can have a higher risk of dementia).

Obviously the Wren theories are my favourites . So, knowing my luck, he'll never be seen again.

I love these sort of theories that link together characters who have no apparent connection and make you look at everything in a new light, I find it really interesting. And also, even when they turn out wrong, it's cool to see people go into so much detail and think of really cool scenarios.

I want to read them now

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Lostie!

So, what you read isn't merely a theory but a 100% iron-clad spoiler of an A reveal? Because the official reveal isn't even coming until next season.

There are clues pointing in various directions, to be fair. I've seen convincing theories about different characters.

Still, if yours turns out to be correct, I certainly won't claim to have known all along. Not sure why I would tbh.

The Charles reveal I read is correct, which pointed towards one thing which can only lead to one person

A lot of the fan theories online (if not all of them) have 0 revealed motive for A, whereas Marlene has said numerous times that if you watch closely enough it's already been revealed and there are numerous clues pointing in their direction

[Lostie!]

Originally Posted by Smithy

The Charles reveal I read is correct, which pointed towards one thing which can only lead to one person

A lot of the fan theories online (if not all of them) have 0 revealed motive for A, whereas Marlene has said numerous times that if you watch closely enough it's already been revealed and there are numerous clues pointing in their direction

Sorry if I'm sounding arsey, it's not meant in that way, but my point was just that what you read has to have been a theory rather than a flat-out reveal because we're not getting that yet. A highly likely theory with convincing evidence to back it up sure, but there's a difference between that and finding out for a fact.

I like to keep my options open until the show confirms something without a shadow of a doubt. As I said, it's all part of the fun. We all have our theories that we like to consider, and good on whoever gets it right.

[Jessica.]

I just read this but it doesn't really give any proper evidence. Link

[Lostie!]

Originally Posted by Jessica.

I just read this but it doesn't really give any proper evidence. Link

Interesting article, thanks. I hadn't considered CeCe as

Spoiler:

Varjack.

One part irks me:

CeCe is the only person in the whole series that knew that Ali was actually alive this whole time

just because we know of a few others who knew Alison was alive, but the rest is really interesting.

[Jessica.]

Originally Posted by Lostie!

Interesting article, thanks. I hadn't considered CeCe as

Spoiler:

Varjack.

One part irks me:



just because we know of a few others who knew Alison was alive, but the rest is really interesting.

Yeah, that's why I don't see it as entirely reliable but some of it makes sense.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Lostie!

Sorry if I'm sounding arsey, it's not meant in that way, but my point was just that what you read has to have been a theory rather than a flat-out reveal because we're not getting that yet. A highly likely theory with convincing evidence to back it up sure, but there's a difference between that and finding out for a fact.

I like to keep my options open until the show confirms something without a shadow of a doubt. As I said, it's all part of the fun. We all have our theories that we like to consider, and good on whoever gets it right.

No, i know what you mean but what i've read it stands for is..

Spoiler:

Charles De Gaulle Airport, and who do we know that just got back from france?

[Smithy]

ALSO

Spoiler:

who left in 5x1 only for the girls to have 4 episodes without an A Message? then we see A moving into a new apartment at the end of 5x5

[Lostie!]

Originally Posted by Smithy

No, i know what you mean but what i've read it stands for is..

Spoiler:

Charles De Gaulle Airport, and who do we know that just got back from france?

Oooh that's interesting tbh. I'd read theories about the finale and her, but they were just

Spoiler:

"Maybe her real name is Charles" etc, which I'm not really buying.

Your's is intriguing, though.

[Daniel-X]

I've finished series 1! So after two weeks I've finished series 1. It really was a brilliant series and has left me with a lot of unanswered questions for Series 2 which I'm sure will be picked up and explained upon during the series. The finale episode was fanastic it had me on the edge of my couch with suspense. Garrett mg: I thought he may be one of the nice guys in the series perhaps but he's AWFUL. Jenna really has begun to intrigue me as the series went along the situation with her and the girls etc was one of the main storylines I indulged in the most throughout the series. Spencer is really becoming more and more likeable as the episodes go on her genuine concern over Melissa after the crash made me sad and I think she's great at playing the tragic heroine who seems like she has it all but doesn't.

Spoiler:

YES at Ian dying I was thrilled with his death it was chilling though seeing his body hanging in the ropes of the church bell. I wonder what's happened to his body I definitely think A has got the body but i keep changing my mind on who I think A is at first I thought it was Maya then Melissa but now I'm beginning to think Mike We've just not seen a lot of him and he can act a bit strange sometimes so I just have a sneak feeling it could be him but saying this ill probably change my mind sometime again soon The final scene with Spencer and Ian was really intense also and wonderfully written

Season 1 rankings:

1. Hanna
2. Spencer
3. Alison
4. Emily
5. Aria

[andybigbro]

Who is Charles have I missed something

[andybigbro]

Originally Posted by LuciaX

I've finished series 1! So after two weeks I've finished series 1. It really was a brilliant series and has left me with a lot of unanswered questions for Series 2 which I'm sure will be picked up and explained upon during the series. The finale episode was fanastic it had me on the edge of my couch with suspense. Garrett mg: I thought he may be one of the nice guys in the series perhaps but he's AWFUL. Jenna really has begun to intrigue me as the series went along the situation with her and the girls etc was one of the main storylines I indulged in the most throughout the series. Spencer is really becoming more and more likeable as the episodes go on her genuine concern over Melissa after the crash made me sad and I think she's great at playing the tragic heroine who seems like she has it all but doesn't.

Spoiler:

YES at Ian dying I was thrilled with his death it was chilling though seeing his body hanging in the ropes of the church bell. I wonder what's happened to his body I definitely think A has got the body but i keep changing my mind on who I think A is at first I thought it was Maya then Melissa but now I'm beginning to think Mike We've just not seen a lot of him and he can act a bit strange sometimes so I just have a sneak feeling it could be him but saying this ill probably change my mind sometime again soon The final scene with Spencer and Ian was really intense also and wonderfully written

Season 1 rankings:

1. Hanna
2. Spencer
3. Alison
4. Emily
5. Aria

Aww I'm glad you're really enjoying it Lucia! And happy hanna is your fave!

[LukeB]

3 more episodes left then I will be on S5

[LukeB]

wow what a wicked last episode of season 4!
My love for Alison grows each time!

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by LuciaX

I've finished series 1! So after two weeks I've finished series 1. It really was a brilliant series and has left me with a lot of unanswered questions for Series 2 which I'm sure will be picked up and explained upon during the series. The finale episode was fanastic it had me on the edge of my couch with suspense. Garrett mg: I thought he may be one of the nice guys in the series perhaps but he's AWFUL. Jenna really has begun to intrigue me as the series went along the situation with her and the girls etc was one of the main storylines I indulged in the most throughout the series. Spencer is really becoming more and more likeable as the episodes go on her genuine concern over Melissa after the crash made me sad and I think she's great at playing the tragic heroine who seems like she has it all but doesn't.

Spoiler:

YES at Ian dying I was thrilled with his death it was chilling though seeing his body hanging in the ropes of the church bell. I wonder what's happened to his body I definitely think A has got the body but i keep changing my mind on who I think A is at first I thought it was Maya then Melissa but now I'm beginning to think Mike We've just not seen a lot of him and he can act a bit strange sometimes so I just have a sneak feeling it could be him but saying this ill probably change my mind sometime again soon The final scene with Spencer and Ian was really intense also and wonderfully written

Season 1 rankings:

1. Hanna
2. Spencer
3. Alison
4. Emily
5. Aria

Lolololololololol

Originally Posted by andybigbro

Who is Charles have I missed something

Nope, stay perched for the finale though

[Natalie.]

Into season 5 now

Spoiler:

Who hit Ali and who killed her Mom?

[Daniel-X]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Lololololo

So I'm guessing some things aren't explained upon I just meant like the Jackie Molina Page thing and Who took Ian's body and who A is etc.

[Daniel-X]

Originally Posted by andybigbro

Aww I'm glad you're really enjoying it Lucia! And happy hanna is your fave!

Thanks Andy! It's a really really good show. I love the whole suspense of who A is. Yeah Hanna's my favourite but I've got to say I'm loving Spencer more and more I'm sure Hanna will stay perched at the top of my list though.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by LuciaX

So I'm guessing some things aren't explained upon I just meant like the Jackie Molina Page thing and Who took Ian's body and who A is etc.

Well, we're about to finish season 5 and we still don't know who killed Ian so

[LukeB]

Smithy season 4 finale slayed me!!

Season 5 today!

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Smithy

Well, we're about to finish season 5 and we still don't know who killed Ian so

Spoiler:

We know who pushed him though to save Spencer

[Smithy]

Yaas it was really good, EP 1 of S5 is like a direct continuation, it should have really been a two hour premiere instead of of a finale and a premiere

[Smithy]

Might want to put that in a spoiler luke, Lucia isn't that far along

[LukeB]

Spoiler:

i think melissa killed that girl who is meant to be dead ali and yass at the mother being dead