[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by jaxie

Sam nominates Jack at every opportunity and she isnt particularly friendly with him so why would he save her? You claim Harry as the better person but she ate Jack's letter quick enough because she doesn't really like him. IMO these hypothetical are always a bit silly because it didn't happen that way and the circumstances and feelings of those involved are different when you put someone else in there so the what if situation is therefore a completely different set of circumstances.

She had to eat someones letter though, it's not like she had the choice to read one but decided nah I'll eat Jacks letter instead Also she didn't eat it quick enough, you say that like she was chomping at the bit to do it when quite clearly she was the most upset out of any of them for having to do it.

If you find the thread subject so silly you don't need to reply btw