[Mystic Mock]

I'm watching Survivor: China at the minute, I'm at the top 4, I can't get over that Denise is in there considering she's done absolutely nothing all game.

This is the second series that I've watched of Survivor (Gabon being my first) and whilst I think that Gabon was stronger in the Tribe stages, I do think that China takes it to a whole new level once it hits the merge imo.

And on a shallow front when you didn't think that they'd be able to beat Sugar and Kelly, they decide to throw out Jaime and Amanda.

Although with Amanda her crush on Erik did my head in because she pretended that she wanted to keep him in for “strategy reasons” but she was close to nearly letting Peih Gee and Erik win the whole game with her silly crush, she's just really annoying to me.

Anyway here's my overall rankings as I doubt that much will change between now and tomorrow.

1. Jean Robert
2. Todd
3. Dave
4. Courtney
5. Peih Gee
6. Frosti
7. James
8. Ashley
9. Sherea
10. Chicken
11. Leslie
12. Aaron
13. Erik
14. Amanda
15. Jaime
16. Denise

Away from about 4 or 5 of them, the others was really strong in this series towards their contribution to the series, and bizarrely still being likeable to me, especially the top 7.

[Dominic]

Survivor: China was an amazing season

Random, but here's my ranking:
1. Peih-Gee
2. Courtney
3. Todd
4. Erik
5. Jaime
6. Sherea
7. Leslie
8. Manhanda
9. Aaron
10. Jean-Robert
11. Ashley
12. Frosti
13. James
14. Dave
15. Chicken
16. Denise

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by extracheezz

Survivor: China was an amazing season

Random, but here's my ranking:
1. Peih-Gee
2. Courtney
3. Todd
4. Erik
5. Jaime
6. Sherea
7. Leslie
8. Manhanda
9. Aaron
10. Jean-Robert
11. Ashley
12. Frosti
13. James
14. Dave
15. Chicken
16. Denise

Not a bad list, I can understand why a lot of the contestants could be peoples favourites in this series as it's a great series imo.

I felt sorry for Peih Gee with how she got treated, though it made for great TV with her and James I felt.

[Dominic]

Originally Posted by Mystic Mock

Not a bad list, I can understand why a lot of the contestants could be peoples favourites in this series as it's a great series imo.

I felt sorry for Peih Gee with how she got treated, though it made for great TV with her and James I felt.

Yeah and I feel like she got bad treatment by everyone else in the game.
Have you finished watching, and if not what episode are you on?

[reece(:]

China <3333

1. Courtney
2. Peih-Gee
3. Sherea
4. Jaime
5. Erik
6. Jean-Robert
7. Ashley
8. Todd
9. Amanda
10. James
11. Aaron
12. Leslie
13. Frosti
14. Chicken
15. Dave
16. Denise

[Dominic]

Originally Posted by reece(:

China <3333

1. Courtney
2. Peih-Gee
3. Sherea
4. Jaime
5. Erik
6. Jean-Robert
7. Ashley
8. Todd
9. Amanda
10. James
11. Aaron
12. Leslie
13. Frosti
14. Chicken
15. Dave
16. Denise

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by extracheezz

Yeah and I feel like she got bad treatment by everyone else in the game.
Have you finished watching, and if not what episode are you on?

I'm on episode 14, I know where everybody finishes anyway so you can discuss something that's coming up if you want?

And I agree with you about Peih Gee, maybe it was more of a you had to live in the Tribe sort of thing?

[Dominic]

Originally Posted by Mystic Mock

I'm on episode 14, I know where everybody finishes anyway so you can discuss something that's coming up if you want?

And I agree with you about Peih Gee, maybe it was more of a you had to live in the Tribe sort of thing?

Maybe. I just feel like she always was left out or people barely talked to her about voting off James, Frosti. And Manhanda was kinda r00d to her. Overall I really liked the comeout of the season, but I wish PG and Erik somehow saved themselves. But now PG is in second chances, so she can redeem herself.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by extracheezz

Maybe. I just feel like she always was left out or people barely talked to her about voting off James, Frosti. And Manhanda was kinda r00d to her. Overall I really liked the comeout of the season, but I wish PG and Erik somehow saved themselves. But now PG is in second chances, so she can redeem herself.

Peih Gee will need to pick better allies on her second chance, because people like Erik and Sherea were hopeless at the game in almost every field imo.

Jaime was a decent player if she'd not been targetted.

[Dominic]

Originally Posted by Mystic Mock

Peih Gee will need to pick better allies on her second chance, because people like Erik and Sherea were hopeless at the game in almost every field imo.

Jaime was a decent player if she'd not been targetted.

I think if her tribe was more succesfull at challenges, she could have had a better chance to win, if she entered the merge with majority.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by extracheezz

I think if her tribe was more succesfull at challenges, she could have had a better chance to win, if she entered the merge with majority.

Oh yeah like any Survivor season I'd imagine it's easier when you're in the majority tribe.

[Dominic]

Originally Posted by Mystic Mock

Oh yeah like any Survivor season I'd imagine it's easier when you're in the majority tribe.

But Micronesia (the season after) was when all the blindsides and backstabbing started, mostly because of the Black Widow alliance. Ever since then, tribes don't really matter, cause everyone flips and flops and switches their alliances anyways.

[Mystic Mock]

Micronesia sounds like an interesting season, I'll check it out once I've watched a lot of these contestants original stints.

I've got to say that Amanda is one whiny bitch, she's better than Denise but still there was no need to spoil Todd and Courtney wanting to celebrate making the final.

And well done to Courtney for speaking the truth about Denise.

And Amanda got slaughtered against Todd and Courtney at the Tribal Council didn't she?

[Mystic Mock]

Micronesia sounds like an interesting season, I'll check it out once I've watched a lot of these contestants original stints.

I've got to say that Amanda is one whiny bitch, she's better than Denise but still there was no need to spoil Todd and Courtney wanting to celebrate making the final.

And well done to Courtney for speaking the truth about Denise.

And Amanda got slaughtered against Todd and Courtney at the Tribal Council didn't she?

[Macie Lightfoot]

Originally Posted by extracheezz

But Micronesia (the season after) was when all the blindsides and backstabbing started, mostly because of the Black Widow alliance. Ever since then, tribes don't really matter, cause everyone flips and flops and switches their alliances anyways.

if you REALLY want to go far back, alliance flopping starts back in Amazon and then truly reached a climax in Pearl Islands. Like, those people really forgot that they were on an island because they were so focused on each other and each round was an incredibly short-lived opportunistic alliance to deal with whoever was labeled to be the biggest threat at the moment. Pearl Islands easily has the most fluid gameplay because no one was in a true power position the whole time, and it kinda bums me out that we're probably never going to have a season quite like that again.

[Dominic]

Originally Posted by Macie Lightfoot

if you REALLY want to go far back, alliance flopping starts back in Amazon and then truly reached a climax in Pearl Islands. Like, those people really forgot that they were on an island because they were so focused on each other and each round was an incredibly short-lived opportunistic alliance to deal with whoever was labeled to be the biggest threat at the moment. Pearl Islands easily has the most fluid gameplay because no one was in a true power position the whole time, and it kinda bums me out that we're probably never going to have a season quite like that again.

I always forget PI But I enjoyed Micronesia more because I loved the female power and blindsides and everything <3