[Jordan.]

Anyone can flail around a stage and sing terribly, that doesn't make them talented.

[waterhog]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

Anyone can flail around a stage and sing terribly, that doesn't make them talented.

I think what you are all forgetting is they are on a reality tv show - and if people are tunning in to watch some reality tv - (what ever you class that as) should they have to watch endless routines of self promoting deadwood ? could channel 5 not have a side channel promoting them 24 -7 with all info on about them available on the internet where people and fans can watch them until they can not take any more ?

should we keep big brother for what it is about - a social experiment of people living in a house together to see how they interact ?

[Crimson Dynamo]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

Anyone can flail around a stage and sing terribly, that doesn't make them talented.

how many times have you been on the biggest musical competition in the world?

ie Eurovision

They have also been on the X Factor and NOw CBB

sure, they are failures

[Jordan.]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

how many times have you been on the biggest musical competition in the world?

ie Eurovision

They have also been on the X Factor and NOw CBB

sure, they are failures

Still trying to find the part that makes them talented

[chuff me dizzy]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

Still trying to find the part that makes them talented

Im looking too ,still can't find it either, if you find it before, please let me know

[Denver]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

Still trying to find the part that makes them talented

You support Nicola so you have no right to drag peoples talent

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Adam.

You support Nicola so you have no right to drag peoples talent

it his opinion so he has a right to drag who ever he wants.

[Jordan.]

Originally Posted by Adam.

You support Nicola so you have no right to drag peoples talent

When did I say I support housemates based on their talent?

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

how many times have you been on the biggest musical competition in the world?

ie Eurovision

They have also been on the X Factor and NOw CBB

sure, they are failures

You won't see successful pop stars go on CBB?

[DouglasS]

Originally Posted by LukeB

You won't see successful pop stars go on CBB?

Dappy was a successful pop star I'd say, he'd had a #1 within the past year or so - Mutya was still very current and popular when she went in also - There are countless examples of sucessful popstars entering the Big Brother House

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by DouglasS

Dappy was a successful pop star I'd say, he'd had a #1 within the past year or so - Mutya was still very current and popular when she went in also - There are countless examples of sucessful popstars entering the Big Brother House

That was years ago but then his career died out so went on CBB.

[DouglasS]

Originally Posted by LukeB

That was years ago but then his career died out so went on CBB.

He'd had a #1 at the end of 2011 and then was entering the Celebrity Big Brother house at the very start of 2013, hardly a long time in terms of pop careers where people takes years to create album.

Like I said Mutya had quite a few hits from her album, including 'Real Girl' and entered the house just under 2 years after also.

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by DouglasS

He'd had a #1 at the end of 2011 and then was entering the Celebrity Big Brother house at the very start of 2013, hardly a long time in terms of pop careers where people takes years to create album.

Like I said Mutya had quite a few hits from her album, including 'Real Girl' and entered the house just under 2 years after also.

but he wasn't actually that successful, he wasn't a big name or that famous. he went on CBB to save his 'career' because the newpapers made out he is some vile person (they didn't lie) that's why he acted nice and fake but it didn't work, his career is still a flop.

[chuff me dizzy]

Originally Posted by LukeB

That was years ago but then his career died out so went on CBB.

Same as Jedward then

[Crimson Dynamo]

Originally Posted by LukeB

You won't see successful pop stars go on CBB?

sigh, yes

I mean you would never see someone from say the Jacksons, one of the most successful groups EVER go on CBB

right?

[Denver]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

sigh, yes

I mean you would never see someone from say the Jacksons, one of the most successful groups EVER go on CBB

right?

Or you know some who had one of the most popular songs of the 80s

[hot2go]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

sigh, yes

I mean you would never see someone from say the Jacksons, one of the most successful groups EVER go on CBB

right?

or Alexander O'Neal, Marc Owen, Pete Burns, Martin Kemp ......

[The Penguin]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

sigh, yes

I mean you would never see someone from say the Jacksons, one of the most successful groups EVER go on CBB

right?

Imagine if Michael Jackson came into CBB when he was alive. That would be so surreal.

[hot2go]

[QUOTE=The Penguin;9189343]Imagine if Michael Jackson came into CBB when he was alive. That would be so surreal.[/Q

Imagine the contraband he'd have smuggled in.....Botox in the bathroom, Class A's in the living Room, Class B's in the kitchen and Class 5C in the Snug.

[Beso]

Originally Posted by LukeB

You won't see successful pop stars go on CBB?

You are.right, you would never get a jackson enter the house..no siree.

Edit..should always read whole thread before being cocky.

[The Penguin]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

Anyone can flail around a stage and sing terribly, that doesn't make them talented.

They are entertainers who created an image that works fairly well. It's much better than what Nicola does. Being a Page 3 girl requires no talent whatsoever.

[DouglasS]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

Anyone can flail around a stage and sing terribly, that doesn't make them talented.

Not everyone has their charisma, there is a reason they were put through to the live shows, because they have it. They have the ability to make people talk, laugh and smile, which is why they got votes, and why they have had a successful career.

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by DouglasS

Not everyone has their charisma, there is a reason they were put through to the live shows, because they have it. They have the ability to make people talk, laugh and smile, which is why they got votes, and why they have had a successful career.

in ireland but not the UK, they only had one song that reached top 2 but then they flopped.

[DouglasS]

Originally Posted by LukeB

in ireland but not the UK, they only had one song that reached top 2 but then they flopped.

Considering they're renowned for not being the best singers, having a single reach #2 is amazing. Their career here hasn't flopped, its just changed - they became regular TV personalities on shows like Celebrity Juice. Singing isn't the only aspect of their career.

[hot2go]

Originally Posted by LukeB

in ireland but not the UK, they only had one song that reached top 2 but then they flopped.

Well they have a big fan base in Germany, Sweden and Korea as well as a massive one in Ireland....but the subject wasn't about how much talent they have but rather how little some of their critics have by comparison...I don't consider reaching number two in the UK Singles charts a flop but in comparison what position in the music charts, or the book charts or the Eurovision Song Contest has Callum, Bianca or Nicola ever achieved ?
Jedward are so correct to say that these people are in no position to take the moral high ground and judge others by their talent or success when they have none.