[Raph]

We've had 5 now, how would rank each season's final 4 lineup?

BBCAN1: Emmett, Gary, Jillian and Talla
BBCAN2: Heather, Jon, Neda and Sabrina
BBCAN3: Ashleigh, Brittnee, Godfrey and Sarah
BBCAN4: Cassandra, Kelsey, Pacs Bros and Tim
BBCAN5: Demetres, Ika, Karen and Kevin

For me:
1) BBCAN5 (Kevin, Ika, Demetres and Karen, respectively)
2) BBCAN1 (Emmett, Talla, Jillian and Gary, respectively)
3) BBCAN2 (Neda, Sabrina, Jon and Heather, respectively)
4) BBCAN3 (Sarah, Godfrey, Ashleigh and Brittnee, respectively)
5) BBCAN4 (Cassandra, Tim, Pacs Bros and Kelsey, respectively)

BBCAN5 has had such a good endgame imo, all deserving in their own right to be there!

Overall top 4 individual rankings: (cause I'm bored)
1. Sarah BBCAN3
2. Kevin BBCAN5
3. Neda BBCAN2
4. Cassandra BBCAN4
5. Godfrey BBCAN3
6. Emmett BBCAN1
7. Talla BBCAN1
8. Ika BBCAN5
9. Sabrina BBCAN2
10. Demetres BBCAN5
11. Jillian BBCAN1
12. Ashleigh BBCAN3
13. Karen BBCAN5
14. Jon BBCAN2
15. Tim BBCAN4
16. Heather BBCAN2
17. Gary BBCAN1
18. Pacs Bros BBCAN4
19. Brittnee BBCAN3
20. Kelsey BBCAN4

Totals (higher the worse it was, or lower the better for the optimists out there):
BBCAN1: 41
BBCAN2: 42
BBCAN3: 37
BBCAN4: 57
BBCAN5: 33 - WINNER!

[Calderyon]

^ Percentage of the whole cast deemed bad/a failure by one?

[Wizard.]

BBCAN2: Heather, Jon, Neda and Sabrina

[DouglasS]

1] BBCAN1 (Gary, Talla, Emmett and Jillian, respectively - all top 5 housemates though imo, although Emmett was a bit of a gamebot he did deserve to be there - I liked all)
2] BBCAN2 (Sabrina, Jon, Heather and Neda, respectively - Sabrina was great TV post jury so couldnt help but root for her, Heather and Jon are two of the most rootable contestants ever, and Neda played a goood game in that season - I liked all)
3] BBCAN3 (Sarah, Britnee, Godfrey and Ashleigh respectively - Sarah is my favorite ever winner, Brit and God were my next two favorite houseguests and so these 3 are perfect and without Ashleigh it'd be #1, but Ashleigh was kinda dull and just rode off showmances and I didn't like her alliance, and so she kinda pulls it down, better her than Pilar/Zach tho)
4] 1) BBCAN5 (Demetres, Ika, Karen and Kevin, respectively - although for me this is a brilliant top 4 for this season, I haven't like the contestants this season as much as others which is why its fourth. Demetres and Ika clearly both deserve it and have run this season and I've enjoyed them. Karen makes good TV so I'm glad shes there, I think Kevin has got extremely lucky with comp wins, which is not what makes a good big brother player imo - this game is meant to involve some social aspects/skill which he seems to have avoided by chance...]
5] 5) BBCAN4 (Cassandra, Tim, Kelsey/Pacs - Cass and Tim were worthy and both great - however Kelsey/pacs are the two worst contestants out of the 20 listed so far, they're both awful and terrible and so the fact they're present EASILY makes this the WORST final 4 without a doubt]

[Calderyon]

BBCAN3: Ashleigh, Brittnee, Godfrey and Sarah
BBCAN2: Heather, Jon, Neda and Sabrina
BBCAN1: Emmett, Gary, Jillian and Talla
BBCAN4: Cassandra, Kelsey, Pacs Bros and Tim
BBCAN5: Demetres, Ika, Karen and Kevin

1. Neda BBCAN2
2. Emmett BBCAN1
3. Godfrey BBCAN3
4. Sarah BBCAN3
5. Jillian BBCAN1
6. Kevin BBCAN5
7. Brittnee BBCAN3
8. Talla BBCAN1
9. Tim BBCAN4
10. Jon BBCAN2
11. Sabrina BBCAN2
12. Heather BBCAN2
13. Demetres BBCAN5
14. Cassandra BBCAN4
15. Gary BBCAN1
16. Pacs Bros BBCAN4
17. Ashleigh BBCAN3
18. Kelsey BBCAN4
19. Karen BBCAN5
20. Ika BBCAN5

[JerseyWins]

Gonna grade everyone from 1-10 as F4 houseguests and use the total to rank the seasons:

(Houseguests ranked from best to worst as well)

1) BBCAN1: Emmett [10], Jillian [10], Talla [10], Gary [5] (Emmett, Jillian & Talla are ridiculously close and I could pretty easily switch them around to Talla>Jillian>Emmett on a different day but I think this is kinda more of my consensus... such a great F4) = 35
2) BBCAN2: Jon [10], Heather [10], Sabrina [6], Neda [4] = 30
3) BBCAN3: Godfrey [10], Brittnee [9], Ashleigh [6], Sarah [1] = 26
4) BBCAN5: Kevin [9], Karen [8], Ika [5], Demetres [2] = 24
5) BBCAN4: Paqs Bros [10], Tim [8], Kelsey [4], Cassandra [1] = 23

Something like that. Feels about right for what I would've said without using the numbers.

[reece(:]

Bb1 > bb2 > bb3 > bb5 > bb4

[LemonJam]

1. Gary
2. Karen
3. Jon
4. Brittnee
5. Sarah
6. Talla
7. Heather
8. Godfrey
9. Neda
10. Jillian
11. Emmett
12. Cassandra
13. Sabrina
14. Ashleigh
15. Kesley
16. Demetres
17. Paqs Bros
18. Ika
19. Kevin
20. Tim

so overall...

1. BB1
2. BB3
3. BB2
4. BB5
5. BB4

which is also how I'd probably rate the seasons tbh