[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by MTVN

Maybe Zee could devise a system where the number of nominations each member receives is multiplied by their post count, and then divided by the number of months they have been a member, thus giving a reflection of general contribution to the forum, and then in round two this can be used as a handicap system by which points are worth more or less accordingly, then after that you add each members previous positions in the top 50 - if there are any - together, and divide those by the number of previous competitions they have been a part of to ensure the overall result is also an indication of how each members has become more or less appreciated over time

That would be much fairer I think

That is a terrible idea, that suggests that older members are somehow better and contribute more... and many just don't.
It is or personal opinion of who we like on the forum, not a measure dictated by longevity.

[lostalex]

I think there has been a mistake, I officially withdrew before the game even started. Please give my place to someone else.

[Josy]

Kizzy he was joking

[Drew.]

[Black Dagger]

Originally Posted by Kizzy

That is a terrible idea, that suggests that older members are somehow better and contribute more... and many just don't.
It is or personal opinion of who we like on the forum, not a measure dictated by longevity.

He was just joking, Kizzy

[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by Josy

Kizzy he was joking

WHY YOU LITTLE!!!...

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by lostalex

I think there has been a mistake, I officially withdrew before the game even started. Please give my place to someone else.

Aah Lostalex, did you pm Zee though to say you wanted to opt out, everything had to be done by private message.

I think also anyone wanting to not be in the 50 had to pm him by midnight tonight too.
Up to you obviously but I hope you stay in.

[MTVN]

Yes far it be from me to have to explain my own joke but I devised that pointlessly complicated system because of these two comments

Originally Posted by Marc

I imagine this is really stressful for Zee so I wouldn't wanna suggest something that might make it more complicated than it already is

Originally Posted by Novo

please don't complicate things for him Marc

And now I can't help but feel the whole thing was a miserable failure

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by MTVN

failure

[lostalex]

I said it to Zee in the pre-game thread like a week ago. And it's not midnight here yet. I'll PM him and let him know.

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Kizzy

6/10
08 marsh, mizzy, girth and fruitcake I love you!

[Kizzy]

Originally Posted by 08marsh

[Z]

DRAMA IN THE COURTROOM! Lostalex has withdrawn.

Round 1 is open again!

[Glenn.]

[Z]

Niamh I haven't counted your nomination but I will if you resend it and it's the first one in to change anything, otherwise it'd be unfair

[Glenn.]

Do we all have to re-vote Greg?

[Z]

Nope, nominations sent in prior to closing are still valid, but with lostalex withdrawing it leaves one spot left to fill, so anyone who has yet to nominate can now do so. Pity this is at 1am but perhaps an early riser will claim the decisive nomination.

[Brother Leon]

Well. Time to decide it I suppose...

[Z]

Round 1 is now closed. Again.

[Glenn.]

****ing hell

[Black Dagger]

<3

[Z]

I can announce that the deciding vote did not put just ONE member through... it put TWO members through. We now have a top 51.

[Glenn.]

[Ramsay]

oh me oh my

[Black Dagger]

OOOOOOOOH.