[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by stewart64

Imagine if Katie had got on the tour having come nineth like Aiden. It would have been lynch mob time and a hate fest in the red top press.

I welcome the decision to put Aiden through, but this highlights the unfairness of Katie's commentary on this forum and in the media.

She put in one of the performances of the series on Sunday night, but the boo mob have stopped listening to her and she is unfairly labelled as vocally challenged. And judging by some of the comments this week on this forum, the neutrals are coming down on her side, because if the haters make stupid comments like she can't sing it will arouse a sense of justice and fair play amongst those who previously didn't care.

Time for redress. Get the Waissel vote out this weekend please, keep the Great one in. unless of course you want to keep Sunday special as the Waisselfactor.

whoes katie waissel?

[M X]

Katie's voice is so good, I wish people would just give her a proper chance!

[King Gizzard]

It's average at best.

[joeysteele]

Her voice is very average and that's even stretching things a bit, she also has little stage presence too.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

Her voice is very average and that's even stretching things a bit, she also has little stage presence too.

this.

[keithafc]

Can some one please explain WHY there is madness around her? All i say is a desperate wannabe who has no talent. She can't sing folks. She is a rubbish singer. So why is there this madness about her?

She is just desperate to make it in any way. Its sad really that she has even made it to week 7. At least Wagner is entertaining and actually loves the hate. Katie is just a sad sight to be honest.

[cub]

I like Katie. Now.

[Jords]

Haters gonna hate. People who say she only sings 'ok' or 'average' are kidding themselves because when she has done a good performance (all sing-offs bar the 'sod this' one,and 2nd + 3rd live performances) shes been great, she may not be your cup of tea but lets be honest about it!

[StGeorge]

Originally Posted by Jords

Haters gonna hate. People who say she only sings 'ok' or 'average' are kidding themselves because when she has done a good performance (all sing-offs bar the 'sod this' one,and 2nd + 3rd live performances) shes been great, she may not be your cup of tea but lets be honest about it!

That is true Jords, and IMO she was the better singer in the singoff with Aiden....but i still think she should of gone against Treyc.
I happened to like her voice when i first heard her, but my view has changed as its obvious she struggles to last throughout the whole song (compared with an audition piece), and her apparent desperation at singoff is nauseating.

My main gripe is that the production crew seemed to manipulate the show to keep her over Treyc which stinks. And, as much as i want to see Gamu deported due to visa irregularities, i feel the producers manipulated the show at the judges stage which has thrown a big spanner in the works regarding Katie & Cher's involvement to which the public are now revolting against. It has brought the whole show publicity it didnt need for the wrong reasons.