[Zippy]

I actually have Madonnas entire catalogue of songs. When you look at the amount of hits and number of classic ballads, classic pop songs, classic club songs etc etc its actually astonishing.

Then you have Gaga with her one note sound. A sound which actually belongs to Redone. She may well go on to create a more diverse catalogue of music over the years but so far she's a one note wonder.

And her little monsters can go follow each other off a cliff.

[bbfan1991]

Originally Posted by Zippy

I actually have Madonnas entire catalogue of songs. When you look at the amount of hits and number of classic ballads, classic pop songs, classic club songs etc etc its actually astonishing.

Then you have Gaga with her one note sound. A sound which actually belongs to Redone. She may well go on to create a more diverse catalogue of music over the years but so far she's a one note wonder.

Gaga actually writes her own songs though, RedOne helps to put the sound together.

Madonna would need someone in the studio to put the sound of her music together also, she like LG wouldn't have any idea to do that kind of stuff.

[Niall]

Originally Posted by Zippy

I actually have Madonnas entire catalogue of songs. When you look at the amount of hits and number of classic ballads, classic pop songs, classic club songs etc etc its actually astonishing.

Then you have Gaga with her one note sound. A sound which actually belongs to Redone. She may well go on to create a more diverse catalogue of music over the years but so far she's a one note wonder.

And her little monsters can go follow each other off a cliff.

So Yoü & I is a 'one note' RedOne song is it?

Please.

['Conor]

i have all of Celebration on my ipod

[Rob]

got to be lady gaga

[Z]

Madonna. She broke new ground that Lady GaGa can never break by virtue of Madonna coming along first; there is nothing left for a female pop artist to do that will open up a new territory of self expression because it's been done by other women, decades ago. Lady GaGa, to her credit, is a phenomenon and she deserves all the success she has attained thus far; her music doesn't really appeal to me but there are a couple of songs I enjoy, and if you're not splitting opinions then you're never going to reach the pinnacle of the music business. I think the gimmicks are rather tiring and I find the weirdness a bit over the top; you can't entirely fake being an odd person but it's very easy to exaggerate that, and I find her persona quite grating for that reason, because in some clips I've seen of her she seems quite funny and down to earth (American Idol) and at other times she's forcibly awkward and impossible to warm to (Jonathan Ross on one occasion, but quite funny on another occasion) - so I don't know what to make of her. Her voice is superior to Madonna's, but Madonna came first and did so much more for music than Lady GaGa ever will.

[Stu]

I voted for Lady GaGa because I enjoy her sound more.

Simple.

[MTVN]

Gaga, I preferred her earlier stuff though

[Doogle]

Not just saying this cos I love GaGa, but I've never ever liked Madonna.

[Niall]

Originally Posted by Locke.

What?

[InOne]

Was gonna say Madonna, but she messed my main man Sean Penn about. Bitch

[King Gizzard]

Adele

[Ninastar]

Madonna

[InOne]

Originally Posted by Ninastar

Madonna

[Ninastar]

im joking, i voted GaGa <3

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by Ninastar

im joking, i voted GaGa <3

don't play games this is serious

*reports*

[Ninastar]

Originally Posted by Zippy

don't play games this is serious

*reports*

im sorry!! *goes back in time and changes vote*

[Josy]

Originally Posted by Zippy

don't play games this is serious

*reports*

I voted Madonna.

[GypsyGoth]

[Jords]

I love the Gaga at the moment