[Ryan244]

This years Danyl maybe ?

[Kate!]

Agree 100% with the OP. All four girls were talented and Kelly had d tough choice, but Misha came aross as arrogant and full of herself. She was the one contestant I didnt see even a trace of vulnerability in and I just cant warm to her at all. Would rather Amelia stayed, but unfortunately her performance let her down. Dont agree with the previous post implying Rebecca Ferguson was false however, she was a very sweet nervous and humble girl, similar to Leona, and deserved to do well.

[Doogle]

I didn't think Rachel was arrogant.

The problem is, there's confident and arrogant. She has that "Im better than you" look and feel about her that puts me off her.

[Kerry]

Originally Posted by Doogle

I didn't think Rachel was arrogant.

The problem is, there's confident and arrogant. She has that "Im better than you" look and feel about her that puts me off her.

It might not be her but she's reminding me so much of another contestant :/

[Doogle]

Rachel Hylton (2008)? She was arrogant But she wasn't in the bottom 2 much.
Rachel Adedeji (2009 I think) was always in the bottom 2 though.

[Kerry]

Thats it!! The first one! I thought it was too recent to be Adedeji

[MusicXian]

I thought Sophie and Janet were better than Misha anyway.

[Kerry]

[Jords]

Originally Posted by ~Kerry~

I liked her, found Hylton very 'real' if cocky at times.

[Black Dagger]

Love it if she is in the B2 with Frankie in a few weeks and they kick out her smug ass.

Amelia was robbed.

[Visage]

I got this impression when it was announced she was through, she nodded her head in appreciation to Kelly then there was this look she gave to Sophie or Amelia that looked like she was above them. Very cock-sure of herself.

That's how I saw it.

[Wildcat!]

Originally Posted by Visage

I got this impression when it was announced she was through, she nodded her head in appreciation to Kelly then there was this look she gave to Sophie or Amelia that looked like she was above them. Very cock-sure of herself.

That's how I saw it.

Funny, because I saw it as, "good luck guys", And she didnt try to make a fuss of her going thru, to not upset the other girls.

Amelia on Xtra factor, said that Mischa was like a mother to her. Funny!

[Visage]

Originally Posted by Wildcat!

Funny, because I saw it as, "good luck guys", And she didnt try to make a fuss of her going thru, to not upset the other girls.

Amelia on Xtra factor, said that Mischa was like a mother to her. Funny!

Oh? I even rewind that bit too because I couldn't believe she gave that look (as I saw it)

It's great when you see something in someone and someone else comes along and sees just the opposite.

I haven't seen any Xtra factor so don't know what any of the contestants have said or who they are close to.

[Niamh.]

How did she? I must have missed something Personally, If I was up there I think I would have kept my excitement at being through in too, out of respect for the girl who wasn't.

[Black Dagger]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

How did she? I must have missed something Personally, If I was up there I think I would have kept my excitement at being through in too, out of respect for the girl who wasn't.

She just gave Sophie and Amelia a real dirty glare, when she got through, it was like she thought 'HA, I'm better than you both.'

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Black Dagger

She just gave Sophie and Amelia a real dirty glare, when she got through, it was like she thought 'HA, I'm better than you both.'

I'm sure that's not what she meant though. Didn't someone say her and Amelia got on really well and that she was like the mother of the house?

[AndyEssex1]

I love girls like Rihanna and Alicia Keys but I'm just not a fan of the "Aretha style" that a lot of black women singers have.
Mischa is a lot like Rachel Hilton from 3 years ago.
She isn't nice to look at when she is singing - she snarls. Her hair and styling is awful.
Kelly has a "sister thing" going on with her, which you would expect.
She is a blatant Missy Elliot rip-off. Surely the judges know, but don't want to say.
....but she probably has the best voice in the show if comes down to power and range.

[Jordan.]

I haven't noticed it

[MeMyselfAndI]

I don't like the pig, although she unfortuneatly is a great singer

[Colbert-Bump]

Is her fashion icon Minnie Mouse?

[Marc]

I'd much rather a cocky person than somebody who pretends that they aren't that good but know that deep down they really are e.g. Janet

[MusicXian]

I think the problem of Janet is not about how good she think she is, it's just that she's a really shy and nervous person, which is understandable. I was like that when younger too. I used to crap myself at the thought, even at uni when doing presentations in front of people and such stuff. So imagine for Janet who is clearly a nervous person at performing in front of thousands in the arena and millions at home.

Like with everyone though she will get better at performing the more she does it. Still nervous which is always a good thing, but being able to manage the nerves and shyness.

[Marc]

Janet has tonnes of YouTube videos of herself singing though. That's not what somebody with a 'shy' personality trait would do. She knows she's good and her 'vulnerable/shy/little mousey/delicate' ways bug the hell out of me.

Same with Leona when she was on; just accept that you're good and stop annoying me

[MusicXian]

Posting videos on youtube is fair enough, lets not forget even though she is posting these videos the world she is still in her own bubble and able to control whats going on. I could do something similar and pick and choose what goes on the net. At the end of the day though, performing in front of people with not much control if anything does go wrong is obviously something that makes some people nervous, like herself.

So far even when asked by the judges or Dermot 'How do you think you did' She has remained humble with the same answers, 'I dont know' or 'glad the crowd like it' (like after aerosmith cover) because she does just seem to be the type of person who clearly doesnt know how good she can be or at the very least doesn't want to big herself up by saying so. Why should she anyway? If she was the type of person who said 'I am awesome, I was brilliant just then' its quite obvious most people in Uk hate this trait. However its a good thing she is nothing like that. Its what makes her appealing to many viewers.

[MusicXian]

Amelia was easily top 3 potential. She did have a huge fan club already. I do think its a mistake, but Kelly was going to make a bad choice whoever went because alot of people like every 1 of them. That said I think Amelia had the 2nd biggest fanbase out of the 4 thus far in the competition, Sophie the least, but Kelly really likes Sophie and so do I.