[Crimson Dynamo]

It also goes the other way where no vicar, rabbi or nun should get any special reverential treatment above a street sweeper or newsagent.

[kirklancaster]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

It also goes the other way where no vicar, rabbi or nun should get any special reverential treatment above a street sweeper or newsagent.

Why do you just example Church of England, Judaic, and Roman Catholic religious figures? What's so exclusive about Imans?i Should they receive special reverential treatment then?

Oh.... I forgot.... They already do in the UK. Silly old Kirk.

[user104658]

Hold on, isn't this basically the plot of Men In Black?

[Crimson Dynamo]

I wonder what a religionist would do if they took their child to a doctor as the child was very ill and the doctor turned them away and told them to pray to their god to heal the child.?

I am thinking that in this instance they would not be that keen on prayer and the healing power of their chosen god.

[user104658]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

I wonder what a religionist would do if they took their child to a doctor as the child was very ill and the doctor turned them away and told them to pray to their god to heal the child.?

I am thinking that in this instance they would not be that keen on prayer and the healing power of their chosen god.

What's always confused me more than that, is that religious people are still distraught when their loved ones die (even if their loved ones were devout, too). I mean... if they really believe... then why? Is it just selfishness / because they will "be missed"? The level of grief makes that feel a bit unlikely, but surely they truly believe that their loved ones are now somewhere better, peaceful, and generally awesome? Shouldn't they be like "Ohhh yay! Lucky Bob!!". This is also not mocking - it's something I genuinely wonder about. Because I know that these people themselves DO really believe it and yet, they are devastated by losing loved ones.

My stance on it right now is that, basically, I think that (as irrational as I find religion) religious belief is a part of the rational mind; it's learned, consciously fully believed, even subconsciously very deeply embedded. But when it comes right down to a kick in the guts like losing someone, instinct kicks in and leaves the person devastated. On that most basic level, they "know" that that person is just gone. As that initial pain fades and the grieving process progresses they later start to reintroduce the idea that they will "see them again, one day".

[Crimson Dynamo]

Originally Posted by Toy Soldier

What's always confused me more than that, is that religious people are still distraught when their loved ones die (even if their loved ones were devout, too). I mean... if they really believe... then why? Is it just selfishness / because they will "be missed"? The level of grief makes that feel a bit unlikely, but surely they truly believe that their loved ones are now somewhere better, peaceful, and generally awesome? Shouldn't they be like "Ohhh yay! Lucky Bob!!". This is also not mocking - it's something I genuinely wonder about. Because I know that these people themselves DO really believe it and yet, they are devastated by losing loved ones.

My stance on it right now is that, basically, I think that (as irrational as I find religion) religious belief is a part of the rational mind; it's learned, consciously fully believed, even subconsciously very deeply embedded. But when it comes right down to a kick in the guts like losing someone, instinct kicks in and leaves the person devastated. On that most basic level, they "know" that that person is just gone. As that initial pain fades and the grieving process progresses they later start to reintroduce the idea that they will "see them again, one day".

Indeed. Wishful thinking is hardwired into our psyche as its evolutionary successful, or at least has been. When food was scarce, disease killed you and climate and animals killed you the hope that something big and all powerful would protect the good was a great way of dealing with the sh1t that came along. Survival of the fittest and strongest will always lead to the weak thinking "well when you die you will pay for this you swine.."

[user104658]

Originally Posted by LeatherTrumpet

Indeed. Wishful thinking is hardwired into our psyche as its evolutionary successful, or at least has been. When food was scarce, disease killed you and climate and animals killed you the hope that something big and all powerful would protect the good was a great way of dealing with the sh1t that came along. Survival of the fittest and strongest will always lead to the weak thinking "well when you die you will pay for this you swine.."

"Fortune favors the brave", I suppose. On those harsh nights with scarce food, someone who believed that something powerful was "watching their back" might be more likely to face their fear, venture out, make a kill and eat. Someone afraid and hopeless might simply cower in their cave and starve.

It's an interesting concept for the "inheritance" of early religion, at least.

[Nedusa]

Don't they do that already in some parts of Africa and Asia ?





.

[Northern Monkey]

I think religion came about due to a lack of knowledge.People even before the ancient Egyptians worshiped the sun,moon and stars because they had no clue what they were and they are so spectacular.I think the theories of all powerful beings and creators came later and then even later the concept of an afterlife evolved due to the 'wishful thinking' part.This has gradually transfered over to the newer religions such as Christianity,Judaism and Islam.Various ideas in the newer religions are taken straight from the ancient ones.