[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Macie Lightfoot

STOP, Michael has the energy and charisma of a raisin.

But so does Joe! That's my point, if an attractive male is a must, I'd rather look at Michael...Joe does nothing for me

[TomC]

Originally Posted by Jack_

But so does Joe! That's my point, if an attractive male is a must, I'd rather look at Michael...Joe does nothing for me

At least Joe's face moves lol

[TomC]

Originally Posted by Macie Lightfoot

wow this sounds awful!

Aw it could be worse? I thought you liked Wentworth and Aubry? And at least it's not ****ing Domenick or Zeke etc

Originally Posted by Jack_

What's their obsession with Joe? If we're gonna have an attractive male archetype couldn't we have Michael

NO! See below:

Originally Posted by Macie Lightfoot

STOP, Michael has the energy and charisma of a raisin.

[MB.]

Originally Posted by TomC

I thought you liked Wentworth

Is this the same Troy we're on about?

[TomC]

Originally Posted by MB.

Is this the same Troy we're on about?

lol i just assume everyone does bc...what's not to like in Kellegend Wentworth

[JerseyWins]

Originally Posted by Macie Lightfoot

STOP, Michael has the energy and charisma of a raisin.

And the abs of one too

[LukeB]

Originally Posted by Jack_

What's their obsession with Joe? If we're gonna have an attractive male archetype couldn't we have Michael

:

Daddy Ben >

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by LukeB

Daddy Ben >

this BETTER be a joke or you're going on my ignore list

[Natalie.]

Originally Posted by LukeB

Daddy Ben >

Spoiler:

[LukeB]

Aubry

The captain choices are alright it could have been better but at least we aren't getting Ozzy to fail again, Zeke and other awful peope.

[JerseyWins]

Joe is soooo overrated & I like a decent amount of the "Golden Boy" characters (ie Malcolm's a greeeat one)

[reece(:]

Malcolm > Joe by light years

[Natalie.]

Aubry

It could have been worse

[DrunkerThanMoses]

Didn't Joe date worthless as well?

Wouldnt shock me if they replace aubry with game changer Sierra Dawn Thomas for a cat fight

[Wojtek]

Queen Kelley

David is the only one I don't like, but it could've been worse.

[JerseyWins]

These 4 are confirmed right? Not rumored?

It feels like slightly random selections but maybe it makes more sense with more revealed.

[reece(:]

so Nerds vs Jocks theme or?

[AarynGriesfan]

Congrats on finding a worse idea than even Redemption Island was. http://insidesurvivor.com/rumor-seas...nd-title-34310

[Headie]

I thought Redemption Island was over. Finished. FINISHED. END! /carole

This show is a parody of itself at this point!

[reece(:]

Only here for it if it saves Aubrey and Wentworth

[Headie]

Originally Posted by reece(:

Only here for it if it saves Aubrey and Wentworth

Joe to be voted out Day 3 and return Day 37 with an endurance comp win?

[MB.]

Probst can go to the Island of Extinction and bloody well stay there!

[Macie Lightfoot]

So someone (read: Joe) could win two endurance challenges and the fire-making challenge and then win the game.

This isn't even Survivor anymore, this is complete garbage.

[JerseyWins]

The Redemption Island twist really is awful and this sounds like a carbon copy but even worse. No weekly duels? So they can just wait and wait on the island and then eventually come back, after winning one comp I guess? Not sure how that'll work.

Here's the thing, even if it helps a person I like, I just don't really care about it because it tarnishes their potential win anyway. It gives them more screen time but meh. And in the worse scenario, if someone I don't like comes back then that just becomes frustrating/exhausting to go through them being the target all over again / needing to win IC's or find idols. It makes things repetitive and makes the evictions feel less important.

[JerseyWins]

Returnees in general are simply better done in Big Brother because the format gives them a bit more opportunity to make a comeback in the game (if they have at least 1-2 allies that keep them safe, or two chances to win power in HOH and veto).