[Mrluvaluva]

I'm in!!

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Mrluvaluva
I'm in!!

Welcome on board.... glad to have in the club.

[Matt08]

I'll join, I did start up a Rhydian dislike club but it's that old, no-one probably noticed it http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/foru....php?tid=74002

[Mrluvaluva]

Lets trounce the "Rhydian rocks" fan club!!!

[Tom]

The X Factor is looking for someone who can be a global superstar and follow in the footsteps of Leona Lewis who is on track to do just that (and so is Shayne as well). By Rhydian winning, he will get 1 number 1 single and 1 number 1 album, then he will fall out of the mainstream charts and be a success in the classical world- much like Dannii Minogue in the dance world.

He has no long term career in the mainstream charts, although he will stick around. The X Factor is looking for someone who will still be hitting the top 5 or above in 5 years time, not someone who will release 1 or 2 singles then leave the mainstream charts. That is a waste of Ł1,000,000.

The only ones who could realistically get a good long term career from the remaining 5 are Leon and Hope.

I also think Simon will sign up Same Difference after his comments last night, but they will eventually end up on a Pop Party album and people will begin to laugh at them and think they are a novelty act until they vanish.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Matthew
I'll join, I did start up a Rhydian dislike club but it's that old, no-one probably noticed it http://www.thisisbigbrother.com/foru....php?tid=74002

I was looking for it but it must have dropped out of sight. Shall we merge the two membership lists and make the one club?

[Matt08]

Originally posted by Red Moon

I was looking for it but it must have dropped out of sight. Shall we merge the two membership lists and make the one club?

You can keep your club if you want. I think ost of the people who joined my club at the start now love Rhydian.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Matthew
You can keep your club if you want. I think ost of the people who joined my club at the start now love Rhydian.

Thanks Matthew.

If the people that still dislike him want to join this club they will be more than welcome.

[Sam]

I'll join!

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Sam
I'll join!

Welcome to the club.

We just need 4 more members and we have equalled the rival club!

[Red Moon]

Just done a banner for the club if anyone has space to use it.



Feel free to change the text as long as it has the words "Rhydian Sucks" in the text.

Maybe some graphic artist in the club could make one of those thin ones people seem to use as well.

[GiRTh]

Why shouldn't he win? Who says this is about pop music? Surely if it was about creating a pop star the show would not let the over 25's enter.

I don't see the point you guys are trying to make. The show is called the X-Factor not pop idol and is supposed to give people who don't have the chance an opportunity to become brofessional singers.

[Riz]

Originally posted by Red Moon

I would agree looking at the membership we all agree that he has talent but he really is on the wrong show. It's not that we hate him or dislike him, we just don't know why he is part of popular music talent show.

in that case sign me up lol

[Red Moon]

Welcome to the club.... it is always good to have new members.

[Mrluvaluva]

Originally posted by GiRTh
Why shouldn't he win? Who says this is about pop music? Surely if it was about creating a pop star the show would not let the over 25's enter.

I don't see the point you guys are trying to make. The show is called the X-Factor not pop idol and is supposed to give people who don't have the chance an opportunity to become brofessional singers.

What's a brofessional? Is it slang for a professional brother?

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Mrluvaluva

What's a brofessional? Is it slang for a professional brother?

It's a typo. Have you nowt better to do than correct my typo's.

Do you have a comment on the content of my post?

[Ann]

add me please red

[Nicky.]

:O How can anyone join this lol!

[Mrluvaluva]

Originally posted by GiRTh

Do you have a comment on the content of my post?

Yes. The X-Factor to me is about creating a star. Someone who will appeal to the masses and become really successful. A superstar if you like. Rhydian is not it imo.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Mrluvaluva

Yes. The X-Factor to me is about creating a star. Someone who will appeal to the masses and become really successful. A superstar if you like. Rhydian is not it imo.

If they want someone to appeal to the masses then why do they let 40 years old apply?

[Mrluvaluva]

Originally posted by GiRTh
If they want someone to appeal to the masses then why do they let 40 years old apply?

I have no idea. I also think that they should not have lowered the age limit this year. Just my opinion of course.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Mrluvaluva

I have no idea. I also think that they should not have lowered the age limit this year. Just my opinion of course.

So, would you prefer it to be more like American Idol? I would too.

[Z]

Originally posted by GiRTh

If they want someone to appeal to the masses then why do they let 40 years old apply?

Because people beyond the age of 25 buy music too. Rhydian is not fit for the pop charts - he's a classically trained opera singer. This point has been done to death, but that's the key element. It's why Ray got slated last year, because he was singing like Frank Sinatra every week. Should that have been a criticism? No. That's a good talent to have. But it doesn't sell in the pop charts - illustrated clearly by the fact he's disappeared.

[Red Moon]

Welcome to you latest two new members Ann and Sky-and-Tay.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Z
Because people beyond the age of 25 buy music too. Rhydian is not fit for the pop charts - he's a classically trained opera singer. This point has been done to death, but that's the key element. It's why Ray got slated last year, because he was singing like Frank Sinatra every week. Should that have been a criticism? No. That's a good talent to have. But it doesn't sell in the pop charts - illustrated clearly by the fact he's disappeared.

A good point. I totally agree but MrLuvaLuva thinks that this show should appeal to the masses. If so then why are there so many categories. Why dont they just pick the best twelve acts regardless of whether they're Male, female, over 25 or a group.