[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

Originally Posted by Smithy

I hope they get Adele she'd be amazing

[Locke.]

They've done a good job really. Kept the best judge on (Louie) and hired an even better replacement than the stupid bitch that quite (Danni). Would have been even better if Cheryl stayed, but they'll probably get a good replacement anyway.

[Marsh.]

Danni was the best judge the last series. Glad Cheryl's gone, she's gone stale and repetitive.

And I don't think Adele would work. Amazing voice but wasted on trash shows like this.

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

Same could be said about Cheryl in the US but they're giving her a chance

No

Cheryl has a much more successful music career than her both with GA and solo. Plus she has years of experience on UK XF. So its no comparison.

Tulisa has no experience and is relatively unknown. Plus you need a big name to replace a big name.

And Ndubz are not very big at all. Only in school playgrounds.

[Doogle]

I'm pretty sure the only older people that know of N-Dubz are just parents of chavvy kids.

[Sarah.]

I don't even know who she is.

[Harry!]

I might not even watch now. Dannii is the best judge. Such a shame .

[cub]

I don't think a 60 year old woman like Osbourne could possibly know what relevant in today's pop climate.

What was interesting last year were people like Cher Lloyd, Katie Waissel, Matt Cardle and Rebecca - especially Cher. I didn't support her enough last year and she was a really interesting act, along with Katie's bluesy voice.

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by cub

I don't think a 60 year old woman like Osbourne could possibly know what relevant in today's pop climate.

What was interesting last year were people like Cher Lloyd, Katie Waissel, Matt Cardle and Rebecca - especially Cher. I didn't support her enough last year and she was a really interesting act, along with Katie's crappy voice.

We all know music knowledge is just a "desired" aspect of the judging job not a requirement. Tv worthy and entertainment comes first. Cheryl didn't recognise an Elton John song last year, lol.

[Patrick]

People who disagree - Just sit down and be quiet for a minute.

Everyone says Tulisa is the best out of N-Dubz.
She's changed over the years.

2006 [Chav]



2009 [FIT]



2010 [Less Fit, but would still destroy her]



And stop this 'Oh X Factor is doomed now' bollocks.
It was going downhill anyway, it was turning from a talent show into some Reality Show that came along and ruined everybody's year.

It's all epic during April/May to August, everyone's in high spirits and stuff.

Then comes X Factor, the chavy fans who won't shut up about it, the media making it out as if the entire world must watch it - know what actually?

This surprised me, The Royal Wedding was less hyped about than X Factor was last year and the year before that.

Dull and over rated - Simon and Cheryl leaving was always going to kick it in the balls.
Dannii has gone too, no one likes Louis and alot of you [and it's either Homosexual or Snobby] audiences can't stand Tulisa.

It's brilliant, she'll cause rows with the contestants.
Can you imagine it?

Tulisa; 'You just can't sing'.
Black Girl from South London; 'You wut? WHO ARE YOU LUV' TO TELL ME I CAN'T SING? YOU WANT GO THERE BITCH? YOU BETTER [insertxfactorlogoonmouthhere] OFF!'

Can't wait.

Like I said, it was going to die anyway - this just means it'll die in a funnier way.

[Glenn.]

^^^
Arguments like that will drag The X Factor down in the dirt.

And at you would destroy her. Aren't you like 12?

[Patrick]

Originally Posted by Sarah.

I don't even know who she is.

Because you're probably 40.

[Patrick]

Originally Posted by Glenn

^^^
Arguments like that will drag The X Factor down in the dirt.

And at you would destroy her. Aren't you like 12?

X Factor already is in the dirt.

15 Actually.

Glenn, I know 13 Year old Dads.
Stop acting like it's 2001.

[cub]

I cannot see a young urban/pop artist taking advice from a 60 year old woman. It's unimportant that Cheryl didn't know an old Elton John song from 35 years ago. The important thing is she understood what is current TODAY.

[Jordan.]

Originally Posted by Zippy

No

Cheryl has a much more successful music career than her both with GA and solo. Plus she has years of experience on UK XF. So its no comparison.

Tulisa has no experience and is relatively unknown. Plus you need a big name to replace a big name.

And Ndubz are not very big at all. Only in school playgrounds.

Not in America she hasn't she was completley unknown, they didn't care she had a hit in the UK with songs they've never heard of.

Who exactly was Cheryl before XF? just a member of a girl group all her fame now came from the show. The only big hits shes had in the charts is after promoting it to 15 million people on XF, All her other tracks pretty much flopped.

Tulisa hasn't had success handed to her on a plate like Cheryl and not had a huge platform to promote her music. You listen to Tulisa live compared to Cheryl no question who is more vocally talented.

So it doesn't take success to still be talented. Its all unfair criticsm because of her background and music genre.

[cub]

Originally Posted by Patrick

15 Actually.

Quality.

[Judas]

Patrick your posts can come across as slightly rude at times; I understand you are just trying to say what you believe, and it may be in good humour but they all seem abit 'rant like' and aggresive. I thought you said recently when you returned you would have a calmer approach?

Anyway... I suppose it could be worse, it could of been someone who was ugly and knew nothing.

[Smithy]

slightly?

I've seen politer terrorists

[Glenn.]

Originally Posted by Patrick

X Factor already is in the dirt.

15 Actually.

Glenn, I know 13 Year old Dads.
Stop acting like it's 2001.

And its idiot kids like you with attitudes like that, that produce them drains on us, the taxpayers.

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

Originally Posted by Patrick

Because you're probably 40.

[Shaun]

Originally Posted by Patrick

Because you're probably 40.

She's younger than I.
To be quite honest there are going to be very few who know who she is - the band themselves have only had two top-5 singles, and one of those was a guest appearance on Tinchy Stryder's.

Not that Dannii Minogue was huge, mind.

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by cub

I cannot see a young urban/pop artist taking advice from a 60 year old woman. It's unimportant that Cheryl didn't know an old Elton John song from 35 years ago. The important thing is she understood what is current TODAY.

It's important a judge has a good understanding about a range of music.

The Elton John reference was an example that she knows very little outside of autotuned pop.

This will become more noticeable in the USA when she is faced with a broader range of music which is very popular over there and rarely seen here.

[Shaun]

"ah gorra be honest luv ah dunnae hav a cloo who Kennee Rogers is, leik"

[InOne]

Look, Tulisa release crappy mainstream urban slime, she clearly has no taste in music. The fact she is related to Dappy should've made the producers think

TBH I'm glad, it will kill TXF, go Tulisa, guest judge Dappy!

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Shaun

"ah gorra be honest luv ah dunnae hav a cloo who Kennee Rogers is, leik"

Lol, exactly.

Take the American Idol finalists. Imagine Cheryl's comments...

"Lovely hair, pet. You're like the next Joe McElderry". Cue tumbleweed.