[Jordan.]

I'm guessing half hate on him because he isn't that great a singer, the other half because there's a stigma against anyone who's young and good looking on the show because "THEY'LL GET THE FAN GIRL VOTE :@" so he'll never be given a chance really.

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

I'm guessing half hate on him because he isn't that great a singer, the other half because there's a stigma against anyone who's young and good looking on the show because "THEY'LL GET THE FAN GIRL VOTE :@" so he'll never be given a chance really.

shut up now

[Jamesy]

I find his singing voice pretty mundane and while he does have a decent body I personally don't find him attractive. I actually find him quite ugly to be honest. If you took his muscular build away I think a lot of people wouldn't have such a sexual attraction to him.

But I can see how younger people (teens) may like him. If people like his voice then people like his voice. I suppose it's all down to personal opinion at the end of the day.

[Vicky.]

Ugh I hate the 'x is goodlooking so everyone who dislikes them is jealous' argument so much

[mizzy25]

I dont see how he is good looking to be honest.His eyebrows go upwards when hes singing they have a life of their own. I didnt like him @ 1st as I thought that bigger guy was he called Paul with the brillaint voice? He should have got through over Sam, but I wamred to Sam this week. He does seem to be a very hard working lad and take nothing for granted, the look of pure relief every week when he gets through, awww. He isnt as good as singer as Luke or Nicolas but he can hold a tune.

[joeysteele]

Mock, I have not a single problem with Sam Callahan, I too cannot understand the negative reaction to him, as you say there are a lot more, far worse than him in there and even in the charts too.

Far from ruining songs,I have felt he has enhanced the 2 he has done the last 2 weeks and I also like his voice too and the way he sings,not a brilliant voice but always handled appropriately as to whatever song he is doing at the time and that makes for a good performance.

Furthermore, I love his attitude, he comes across as very easy going and I would believe he is really hardworking too.
I'd like to see him silence the critics and really go far in this series, for me he certainly deserves too and far more than many who are left already.

In fact the only person really murdering good songs at the moment is Abi in my view.

[MeMyselfAndI]

I agree that Rough Copy are mega overrated.

[Lee.]

I think he absolutely adores himself.. Which I dislike in a person, but mainly he's pretty dislikeable and he's pretty sh!t

[Me. I Am Salman]

Lee [x2]

[GiRTh]

I hope he wins.

[Santa's NaughtiNess]

He can't sing basically. Nice lad, but as a singer he leaves me cold.

[Ramsay]

He's the screaming definition of 'average'

[Santa's NaughtiNess]

Originally Posted by Karl

He's the screaming definition of 'average'

I don't like the way he blamed it all on Gary in the Xtra Factor.

[Marc]

He's desperately desperate.

[Santa's NaughtiNess]

I think Big Band week will be really bad for him.

[Marc]

I think any week will be bad for him because he has an awful singing voice

[Black Dagger]

THAT MONSTROSITY ON SATURDAY.. and his cunting horrible family now (like sam sister, stay classy digging him on twitter, your brother is some no-mark who will be gone in 3 months time), they all need to be shipped to the moon.

[Thotmas]

he's the kim kardashian of x factor init. He's got none-barely there talent but acts like he's owed fame/stardom.

[MeMyselfAndI]

He's amazing & his singing voice is underrated, I'd rather listen to him than like all of them bar Sam Bailey

[joeysteele]

I think his attitude to the show and his personality are good,I don't think he feels he is owed anything, he even admits himself he has not got the best voice in this series.

Gary is being really hard and unfair on him and he was the one who put Frankie Cocoza through to live finals, he could barely sing a note and was totally unprofessional too.
Odd how Gary was saying then, that you have to look at the whole package it isn't just about the voice.
However now he is saying it is only about the singing when he gets at Sam C.
Very hypocritical of Gary that.

I find Sam C's voice pleasing to listen to, he is generally in tune and he performs to the best of his ability putting a great deal of effort into his performances.

For some reason, he is getting a rough ride but at least he is not doing what Abi is doing week after week, song after song and just presenting the same style to every song she does.
He is varying his performances and I find that far more entertaining overall. It may well be that his vocals could be better overall but I would rather see him in concert than a good few of those who are still left in this series even.

[Santa's NaughtiNess]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

I think his attitude to the show and his personality are good,I don't think he feels he is owed anything, he even admits himslf he has not got the best voice in this series.

Gary is being really hard and unfair on him and he was the one who put Frankie Cocoza through to live finals, he could barely sing a note and was totally unprofessional too.
Odd how Gary was saying then, that you have to look at the whole package it isn't just about the voice.
However now he is saying it is only about the singing when he gets at Sam C.
Very hypocritical of Gary that.

I find Sam C's voice pleasing to listen to, he is generally in tune and he performs to the best of his ability putting a great deal of effort into his performances.

For some reason, he is getting a rough ride but at least he is not doing what Abi is doing week after week, song after song and just presenting the same style to every song she does.
He is varying his performances and I find that far more entertaining overall. It may wellbe that his vocals could be better overall but I would rather see him in concert than a good few of those who are still left in this series even.

He just doesn't grab me. But then no one else does, apart from Luke.

[Joelle.]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

I think his attitude to the show and his personality are good,I don't think he feels he is owed anything, he even admits himself he has not got the best voice in this series.

Gary is being really hard and unfair on him and he was the one who put Frankie Cocoza through to live finals, he could barely sing a note and was totally unprofessional too.
Odd how Gary was saying then, that you have to look at the whole package it isn't just about the voice.
However now he is saying it is only about the singing when he gets at Sam C.
Very hypocritical of Gary that.

I find Sam C's voice pleasing to listen to, he is generally in tune and he performs to the best of his ability putting a great deal of effort into his performances.

For some reason, he is getting a rough ride but at least he is not doing what Abi is doing week after week, song after song and just presenting the same style to every song she does.
He is varying his performances and I find that far more entertaining overall. It may well be that his vocals could be better overall but I would rather see him in concert than a good few of those who are still left in this series even.

Yeah everyone knows Gary Borelow is the biggest hypocrite on tv. His double standards when it came to Frankie and Chris Baloney were just laughable.

[Benji_]

Well put it this way...All the other acts left are better than him, he needs to pull it off this week or he's gone...we gave Abi another chance and she managed to succeed. Now we need to see if Sam C can do the same.

[Benji_]

I just don't think he's picking the correct choice of song...he's better off with a sweet soothing calm song to sing

[Santa's NaughtiNess]

Originally Posted by Benji_

I just don't think he's picking the correct choice of song...he's better off with a sweet soothing calm song to sing

I agree. Song choice is crucial.