[Black Dagger]

THAT MONSTROSITY ON SATURDAY.. and his cunting horrible family now (like sam sister, stay classy digging him on twitter, your brother is some no-mark who will be gone in 3 months time), they all need to be shipped to the moon.

[Ithinkiloveyoutoo]

he's the kim kardashian of x factor init. He's got none-barely there talent but acts like he's owed fame/stardom.

[MeMyselfAndI]

He's amazing & his singing voice is underrated, I'd rather listen to him than like all of them bar Sam Bailey

[joeysteele]

I think his attitude to the show and his personality are good,I don't think he feels he is owed anything, he even admits himself he has not got the best voice in this series.

Gary is being really hard and unfair on him and he was the one who put Frankie Cocoza through to live finals, he could barely sing a note and was totally unprofessional too.
Odd how Gary was saying then, that you have to look at the whole package it isn't just about the voice.
However now he is saying it is only about the singing when he gets at Sam C.
Very hypocritical of Gary that.

I find Sam C's voice pleasing to listen to, he is generally in tune and he performs to the best of his ability putting a great deal of effort into his performances.

For some reason, he is getting a rough ride but at least he is not doing what Abi is doing week after week, song after song and just presenting the same style to every song she does.
He is varying his performances and I find that far more entertaining overall. It may well be that his vocals could be better overall but I would rather see him in concert than a good few of those who are still left in this series even.

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

I think his attitude to the show and his personality are good,I don't think he feels he is owed anything, he even admits himslf he has not got the best voice in this series.

Gary is being really hard and unfair on him and he was the one who put Frankie Cocoza through to live finals, he could barely sing a note and was totally unprofessional too.
Odd how Gary was saying then, that you have to look at the whole package it isn't just about the voice.
However now he is saying it is only about the singing when he gets at Sam C.
Very hypocritical of Gary that.

I find Sam C's voice pleasing to listen to, he is generally in tune and he performs to the best of his ability putting a great deal of effort into his performances.

For some reason, he is getting a rough ride but at least he is not doing what Abi is doing week after week, song after song and just presenting the same style to every song she does.
He is varying his performances and I find that far more entertaining overall. It may wellbe that his vocals could be better overall but I would rather see him in concert than a good few of those who are still left in this series even.

He just doesn't grab me. But then no one else does, apart from Luke.

[Benji_]

Well put it this way...All the other acts left are better than him, he needs to pull it off this week or he's gone...we gave Abi another chance and she managed to succeed. Now we need to see if Sam C can do the same.

[Benji_]

I just don't think he's picking the correct choice of song...he's better off with a sweet soothing calm song to sing

[Mystic Mock]

Admittedly he was terrible last Saturday, but I still think that Abi and Rough Copy are worse than him overall, and his voice isn't as ordinary as Nicholas's voice.

And btw I did like Abi's performance on Saturday so she's gone above the other two for me who are just so boring to watch, and in Rough Copy's case they can't even harmonize very well with each other imo.

[Mystic Mock]

Admittedly he was terrible last Saturday, but I still think that Abi and Rough Copy are worse than him overall, and his voice isn't as ordinary as Nicholas's voice.

And btw I did like Abi's performance on Saturday so she's gone above the other two for me who are just so boring to watch, and in Rough Copy's case they can't even harmonize very well with each other imo.

[Joelle.]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

I think his attitude to the show and his personality are good,I don't think he feels he is owed anything, he even admits himself he has not got the best voice in this series.

Gary is being really hard and unfair on him and he was the one who put Frankie Cocoza through to live finals, he could barely sing a note and was totally unprofessional too.
Odd how Gary was saying then, that you have to look at the whole package it isn't just about the voice.
However now he is saying it is only about the singing when he gets at Sam C.
Very hypocritical of Gary that.

I find Sam C's voice pleasing to listen to, he is generally in tune and he performs to the best of his ability putting a great deal of effort into his performances.

For some reason, he is getting a rough ride but at least he is not doing what Abi is doing week after week, song after song and just presenting the same style to every song she does.
He is varying his performances and I find that far more entertaining overall. It may well be that his vocals could be better overall but I would rather see him in concert than a good few of those who are still left in this series even.

Yeah everyone knows Gary Borelow is the biggest hypocrite on tv. His double standards when it came to Frankie and Chris Baloney were just laughable.

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by Benji_

I just don't think he's picking the correct choice of song...he's better off with a sweet soothing calm song to sing

I agree. Song choice is crucial.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Josy

He cant sing

This ^

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by Niamh.

This ^

I don't like his attitude and that is the reason i don't like him anymore.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Nathan

he looks as if he tries too hard, it doesn't come naturally/looks like he's about to explode at any moment

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by MeMyselfAndI

he doesn't appeal to the middle aged women also, as Nicholas has that covered and he is a better singer than a lot in the competition, he seems really nice anyway

When did you appoint yourself as spokesperson for the middle aged women of the UK

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by Cherie

When did you appoint yourself as spokesperson for the middle aged women of the UK

Agreed. Everyone has a different taste in music. I'm 40, but i like Luke and can't stand Nicholas.

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by Vanessa

Agreed. Everyone has a different taste in music. I'm 40, but i like Luke and can't stand Nicholas.

Not a big fan of Nicholas either, I cringed during disco week for him.

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by Cherie

Not a big fan of Nicholas either, I cringed during disco week for him.

Loved him in the auditions, but he has no stage presence or charisma whatsoever.

[GiRTh]

A bit off topic but my observations from having not watched the show but picking up on what you guys are saying.

We have Sam C who cant sing, Nicolas who has no stage presence, Abi who does the same thing every week, Hannah who is talented but not likeable, Sam B who is 36 so Simon definitely doesn't want her to win and Rough copy but Simon already has 1D and Union J so he doesn't want another group. So we are left with Tamera and Luke but Tamera has been in the bottom two so is unlikely to win.

So Luke to win then!!!!!

Am I about right? Have I missed anyone out?

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

A bit off topic but my observations from having not watched the show but picking up on what you guys are saying.

We have Sam C who cant sing, Nicolas who has no stage presence, Abi who does the same thing every week, Hannah who is talented but not likeable, Sam B who is 36 so Simon definitely doesn't want her to win and Rough copy but Simon already has 1D and Union J so he doesn't want another group. So we are left with Tamera and Luke but Tamera has been in the bottom two so is unlikely to win.

So Luke to win then!!!!!

Am I about right? Have I missed anyone out?

I want Luke in the final. For me he's the only one who has the whole package. Sam B is brilliant, but she doesn't wow me.

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

A bit off topic but my observations from having not watched the show but picking up on what you guys are saying.

We have Sam C who cant sing, Nicolas who has no stage presence, Abi who does the same thing every week, Hannah who is talented but not likeable, Sam B who is 36 so Simon definitely doesn't want her to win and Rough copy but Simon already has 1D and Union J so he doesn't want another group. So we are left with Tamera and Luke but Tamera has been in the bottom two so is unlikely to win.

So Luke to win then!!!!!

Am I about right? Have I missed anyone out?

3 black guys though, edgier than JLS, I think they could do okay, they need to tone down the "we smashed it" comments, and be a bit more humble.

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by Cherie

3 black guys though, edgier than JLS, I think they could do okay, they need to tone down the "we smashed it" comments, and be a bit more humble.

I love Rough Copy, but they're getting a bit cocky lately. That could cost them their place on the show.

[Brother Leon]

They've always been "cocky"..it's what makes them. Better than l this shy fake humble rubbish so many contestants conjure up to pick up votes.

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by Brother Leon

They've always been "cocky"..it's what makes them. Better than l this shy fake humble rubbish so many contestants conjure up to pick up votes.

I know, but it's a bit over the top now. I don't like it and i say it as a massive fan.

[GiRTh]

Are they any good? No point being cocky if they're garbage.