[AnnieK]

Originally Posted by Alf

Is it possible that he got beat up by doing something he wants to keep hidden, and made up this story to cover himself, is that possible?

Of course its possible. It's not what I asked though.....if it were an actor you were familiar with, liked and respected, would you feel as strongly about the need for proof?

[Alf]

Originally Posted by AnnieK

Of course its possible. It's not what I asked though.....if it were an actor you were familiar with, liked and respected, would you feel as strongly about the need for proof?

Depends on his story.

First we heard from TMZ that the attackers were wearing MAGA caps, then they deleted that part of the story.

It took the guys second statement to the Police to tell them that the attackers shouted "this is MAGA country"

The police have searched through lots of video in a security camera laden part of Downton Chicago, and haven't found any attack.

Two people walking around Downtown Chicago at 2.30 in the morning, on one of the coldest nights recorded, wearing ski masks and carrying a rope and a bottle of bleach, you'd think would stick out like a sore thumb?

[Mokka]

Originally Posted by Alf

Is it possible that he got beat up by doing something he wants to keep hidden, and made up this story to cover himself, is that possible?

Except that the timeline of the trip to the subway checks out with the video feed they have. Is it possible you're grasping at straws?

[Alf]

Originally Posted by Mokka

Except that the timeline of the trip to the subway checks out with the video feed they have. Is it possible you're grasping at straws?

Nobody is doubting that he went to subway, In fact we know that he still had his sandwich after the alleged attack.

[SherzyK]

Originally Posted by Alf

Nobody is doubting that he went to subway, In fact we know that he still had his sandwich after the alleged attack.

What satisfaction do you get from trolling?

[Alf]

If you people know the facts, then you should contact the Chicago PD, because they're struggling to solve this.

[Jordan.]

Guys he kept hold of his sandwich so the hospital confirming he was treated for a fractured rib and bruising are clearly lying

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

Guys he kept hold of his sandwich so the hospital confirming he was treated for a fractured rib and bruising are clearly lying

the Sandwich is the iron clad evidence they were waiting for

[Alf]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

Guys he kept hold of his sandwich so the hospital confirming he was treated for a fractured rib and bruising are clearly lying

The question that needs confirming is, how did he get those fractured ribs? The police have found nothing to back his story up.

[Matthew.]

Originally Posted by Alf

The question that needs confirming is, how did he get those fractured ribs? The police have found nothing to back his story up.

Oh idk, maybe because he was beaten up?

Bloody hell Alf, use your brain

[Alf]

Originally Posted by Matthew.

Oh idk, maybe because he was beaten up?

Bloody hell Alf, use your brain

Yeah you're right, I should use my brain by just shutting it down and accept what he says is the truth. I should know my place and not question anything. right?

[Jordan.]

Originally Posted by Alf

The question that needs confirming is, how did he get those fractured ribs? The police have found nothing to back his story up.

I mean they already confirmed the rope part and have two suspects so "nothing" are you sure?

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

I mean they already confirmed the rope part and have two suspects so "nothing" are you sure?

But his sandwich didn't get hurt

[Dash Darington]

Originally Posted by Jordan.

Guys he kept hold of his sandwich so the hospital confirming he was treated for a fractured rib and bruising are clearly lying

Smollett told fans that he wanted to clarify that following the attack, he was bruised but his ribs were neither cracked nor broken.
https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/03/enter...ert/index.html

A solid example of why all the people who are acting like they know what happened are talking out of their ass. Smug and completely wrong. He wasn't even admitted to a hospital. Wait for the facts.

[SherzyK]

Originally Posted by Dash Darington

Smollett told fans that he wanted to clarify that following the attack, he was bruised but his ribs were neither cracked nor broken.
https://www.cnn.com/2019/02/03/enter...ert/index.html

A solid example of why all the people who are acting like they know what happened are talking out of their ass. Smug and completely wrong. Wait for the facts.

He was still attacked nonetheless, why ignore the facts? The police did confirm that the attack did indeed happen, regardless of broken ribs or whatever. Do you not think this attack was unprovoked or even just a little bit cruel?

[Oliver_W]

Originally Posted by SherzyK

The police did confirm that the attack did indeed happen, regardless of broken ribs or whatever.

When? All I've seen confirmed was that he had a piece of rope around his neck, that he had some bruises, and that some people were outside at the same time.

[SherzyK]

Originally Posted by Oliver_W

When? All I've seen confirmed was that he had a piece of rope around his neck, that he had some bruises, and that some people were outside at the same time.

Well he didn’t beat himself up and get those bruises that’s for damn sure

[Dash Darington]

Originally Posted by SherzyK

He was still attacked nonetheless, why ignore the facts? The police did confirm that the attack did indeed happen, regardless of broken ribs or whatever. Do you not think this attack was unprovoked or even just a little bit cruel?

You've been asked repeatedly to substantiate that, and have failed to do so.

[SherzyK]

Originally Posted by Dash Darington

You've been asked repeatedly to substantiate that, and have failed to do so.

Why would I when the police already did?

https://www.mirror.co.uk/3am/celebri...-cops-13935765

[Oliver_W]

To be fair they're only suspects because they were out on the street at the same time, and it was a dark and icy night, can you think of any other ways he could have gotten bruises?

[Alf]

Originally Posted by Oliver_W

To be fair they're only suspects because they were out on the street at the same time, and it was a dark and icy night, can you think of any other ways he could have gotten bruises?

No! there can be no other way. His story must be believed to be true, evidence or not, and that's the end of it.

[Liam-]

The sandwich revolted and kicked **** out of him?

[Alf]

And not only did he keep hold of his sandwich while being beat up and got a rope put around neck, but he was also on the phone at the same time, as his manager has claimed to hear the attack over the phone.

[reece(:]

It’s disgusting yall are still defaulting that he is lying

[Twosugars]

Alf and Oliver say they're open minded but act like prosecution of the victim