[Pyramid*]

Originally Posted by Mr XcX

Who says they WOULD GO IN A MENTAL HOSPITAL!!! They would get mental help and therefore would be able to live a happy life. You are a very silly person if you think they would get locked up for the rest of their days in a mental Hospital. ROFL

It would be a sight more respectful if you ceased insulting people by calling the 'a very silly person' simply because they have a view not akin to your own.

Re the BIB above. For you to offer such a comment and make such an assumption shows how staggeringly wrong you are, and shows how little knowledge you have of certain types and degree of mental illness. Receiving 'mental help' as you put it, is not the end to psychiatric illnessess, the help that is available and whether the 'help' is actually effective or not.

If you had any exprience of a person who suffered from manic depression along with a host of other mental illnessess for example: you'll understand that things such as ECT is available - it may reduce / dimish the suicide attempts, but there can be lasting effect of such treatment for example, brings about a host of other real issues for the person concerned - which in turn, bring about a whole new range of problems. It doesn't necessarily mean 'help' allows them to lead a happy life.

Your view on this, to me, seems naive to say the least.

[Pyramid*]

Originally Posted by Mr XcX

You are the one who know's nothing my dear.

Would you rather your mum kill herself??? She kept going which is the right thing to do.

I have survived open heart surgery after a fatal stabbing. I believe life is blessed. Suicide is WRONG and SELFISH.

Originally Posted by Mr XcX

I do not understand. Did she commit suicide??

Originally Posted by Chewy

Yeah, she did.

Originally Posted by Mr XcX

Well, she should have gotten help. Did your father help her?

.

Seriously - who do you think you are to post something as callous, patronising, ignorant and as arrogant as what you have posted above. You are discussing a member's loved one. Have some respect - if not for yourself, for the person you are replying to.

OH...and for what it's worth: you need to learn what the word, 'fatal' means.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Mr XcX

You have just proved my POINT!!!!!!!!!!!!!

You said you would leave someone to DIE!!! Correct.
Well, you just said yourself you regretted killing yourself. But you would leave the other individual to die.

Like I said you would help someone get help. Not leave them to die.

Plus YOU DID say that death is an easy option and do not deny it.

It is outragous for you to effectively say that someone who is depressed (even though you got medical help) to go and commit suicide

Originally Posted by Pyramid*

Seriously - who do you think you are to post something as callous, patronising, ignorant and as arrogant as what you have posted above. You are discussing a member's loved one. Have some respect - if not for yourself, for the person you are replying to.

This pretty much.

[Benjamin]

Originally Posted by Mr XcX

I agree with some points you make.

I think Suicide is Wrong in all cases, even in Euthansia.

I can't even be bothered to argue with you today.

EDIT: Actually yes I can. How dare you come on here and criticise people in such a disgusting and one sided manner? Honestly, I have seen some crap on here but this is one of the most disgusting and trollish threads I have ever seen. You may want to try and learn how to start respecting people's opinions and showing a little consideration to people's emotions sharpish or you will find yourself banned from this site.

Honestly, I'm actually really disgusted at some of your responses and comments on here.

[Smithy]

[Benjamin]

Originally Posted by Smithy

He's very close.

[Niall]

Originally Posted by ukturtle

He's very close.

[Mr XcX]

Originally Posted by Pyramid*

Seriously - who do you think you are to post something as callous, patronising, ignorant and as arrogant as what you have posted above. You are discussing a member's loved one. Have some respect - if not for yourself, for the person you are replying to.

OH...and for what it's worth: you need to learn what the word, 'fatal' means.

EXCUSE ME!!! I do know what it means FYI. I did flatline at one point so please do not be rude.

Plus, I have not been callous, patronising and ignorant. I thought the comment was very rude at first as they where saying I knew nothing about the topic.

[Mr XcX]

Originally Posted by ukturtle

I can't even be bothered to argue with you today.

EDIT: Actually yes I can. How dare you come on here and criticise people in such a disgusting and one sided manner? Honestly, I have seen some crap on here but this is one of the most disgusting and trollish threads I have ever seen. You may want to try and learn how to start respecting people's opinions and showing a little consideration to people's emotions sharpish or you will find yourself banned from this site.

Honestly, I'm actually really disgusted at some of your responses and comments on here.

What is so "disgusting" about my comments.

Do you want me to explain why I think it is wrong in all cases. I do respect other peoples opinions and I think as a moderator you should learn to respect mine. This is a thread about suicide. It is wrong.

[Mr XcX]

Originally Posted by ukturtle

He's very close.

I have done nothing wrong, all I have done is express my opinion.

[Niamh.]

Originally Posted by Mr XcX

I have done nothing wrong, all I have done is express my opinion.

you basically accused chewys dad/family of not looking after his mother properly, you said that my friends family didn't look after her properly either. How the ****** do you know?

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Mr XcX

What is so "disgusting" about my comments.

Do you want me to explain why I think it is wrong in all cases. I do respect other peoples opinions and I think as a moderator you should learn to respect mine. This is a thread about suicide. It is wrong.

You are entitled to your opinion, correct. But instead of accepting people's opposing viewpoints you feel the need to tell them how wrong they are and even make callous remarks which have a personal effect on one of the members.

Get a braincell. Or at least a bit of compassion.

[Benjamin]

Thread closed.