[Firewire]

Without Boston Rob I probably would've enjoyed it more, he's overbearing as ****

[Firewire]

Originally Posted by TomC

Shii Ann is awesome in AS Definitely my fave

Ugh icon

[JerseyWins]

Episode 12 after the Alex blindside has been amazing (currently just got to the immunity challenge). Rob turning on Alex/Heidi/Jenna has really spiced things up even more than before... Heidi/Jenna/Rob/Christy have all been GREAT this episode. Jenna just won immunity. I'm also not sure whether Rob or Heidi will go now so this should be a suspenseful finish too.

EDIT: Actually I just realized it could only be a 3-3 tie if Christy voted Rob out anyway. But lol wtf @ this possibly turning into a Christy boot? I did NOT expect that if it happens.

[reece(:]

Shii-Ann and Jerri slayed AS

[JerseyWins]

WTF @ Jenna giving Heidi the immunity necklace. But Christy does go anyway. What a cluster**** at the end of this episode.

I'm close to 100% sure that Jenna will win. -I decided to look it up now since I was basically sure of it anyway and wanted to post about it.- I've thought this for a while (especially because I know she gets on All Stars; maybe a mistake on my part checking the cast ). Although I'm not sure exactly how deserving she is so far or how she manages to get to the end in her current situation but maybe that's why she wins. Idk how much the edit is giving it away exactly but it's mainly just that no one else seems to have a shot to win besides Rob and I already knew he doesn't win going into it.

Anyway, this season has been one of my favorites and I still look forward to the end game of this season despite knowing the winner.

[JerseyWins]

I think this might be my favorite F5/F6 ever as well. It's at least up there.

[JerseyWins]

Hmm maybe I shouldn't have looked at the winner yet because during this next episode I feel like I could've bought into a potential Matthew win. And now that Matthew won the IC I could've definitely seen Jenna possibly going, adding some suspense. (edit: nevermind, this wasn't a very realistic possibility in the edit anyway)

This episode has cooled down a bit but that's to be expected after two great episodes with back to back interesting blindsides especially for this point in Survivor history.

[JerseyWins]

All the reactions to Heidi hyping herself up as a mastermind.

[JerseyWins]

Amazon finale time.

*Butch is doing Egyptian dances*

Rob C: When this game is over Butch is gonna need to see a therapist. Even Matthew is saying "Butch is psychotic, he's crazy" and if Matthew is saying you're crazy, you're out of your freaking mind.

[JerseyWins]

Jenna's Jordan flu game?

[JerseyWins]

Yeah, Jenna's win makes perfect sense with her endgame. If I didn't know the result that'd be an intense battle at the final immunity challenge to see who takes Matthew to the end for the win. I wonder if Jenna even wins vs. Rob due to a "bitter" jury or something.

[JerseyWins]

Lmaooo, Heidi's question "Is there anyone on the jury that's more deserving to be in your position?" *they both say Rob* "I mean-... I just think that-... is that the only person?"
*silence*
Jeff: I think they covered it. Thanks Heidi.
Heidi: O-ok.. ok.

Heidi (and Jenna as well) got so much better towards the end.

Probably a top 5 season for me at least. Easily the best out of the first 6 seasons. Marquesas-Thailand-Amazon-Pearl Islands is a really nice run of seasons IF Thailand wasn't in there.

Cast Ranking:

1. Rob
2. Heidi
3. Shawna
4. Butch (feels random to put him in my top 5 but he was a gem in little parts throughout the season )
5. Christy
6. Jenna
7. Ryan
8. Matthew
9. Dave
10. Deena
11. Daniel
12. Alex
13. Janet
14. Jeanne
15. Roger
16. JoAnna

[JerseyWins]

The All Stars cast has improved over the past few seasons. Kinda looking forward to watching this now.

Final pre-season ranking going into it:

1. Boston Rob
2. Jenna L
3. Rob C
4. Ethan
5. Shii-Ann
6. Alicia
7. Kathy
8. Jenna M
9. Tina
10. Tom
11. Richard
12. Lex
13. Amber
14. Rudy
15. Susan
16. Rupert
17. Colby
18. Jerri

The Chapera tribe looks the best overall. Both Robs on the same tribe.

[JerseyWins]

I might regret starting to watch All Stars so late but here goes. I like that I'll be watching 2 All Star seasons at once now (kinda 3 counting BBCAN, if you count it as an All Stars season). It looks like the premiere is only 48 minutes anyway? I can't remember how long the other early seasons were but I'm pretty sure at least the last one or last few were 2 hours.

Anyway, I can't believe they did an All Stars season and didn't include Fairplay or Sandra yet they included Rupert as the only Pearl Islands representative.

[JerseyWins]

Half way through this episode and it's excellent so far, great drama on each tribe already and the tribe dynamics are shaping up nicely. Also, now I remember why I did like Tommy towards the end of Africa. He's killing me already after like 2 confessionals.

[JerseyWins]

Jeff: No one's gotten fire? So as Rudy says, the water is of no value?
Susan: I drank it.
Jeff: Navy Seal, how wise is that? Is that alright?
Rudy: Yeah
Jeff: So is it wise because it's the other tribe?
Rudy: Yeah



Yeah, I might've had Rudy all wrong. I'm enjoying him atm. Also, Sue & Richard are feeling a bit more like the Sue & Richard I preferred earlier on in Borneo but I could be wrong on any 3 of these. It's still very early obviously. Sue & Richard seem to be in danger though - maybe even Rudy too.

[JerseyWins]

Ok now I'm confused about who goes first. The only thing I remember in the edit for this tribe is that Jenna said a winner should be taken out first.

[JerseyWins]

Ok I was figuring Tina would go when the tribe lost and I'm fine with that... got a bit worried it would be Jenna for a second but then it was quickly obvious that wasn't going to happen.

The only thing I'm surprised about is that Tina went from 1st place to 1st out. I don't remember if that was mentioned at all in BvW and in theory the old woman that has won makes perfect sense as a first boot but I just expected her to last a little longer going into this season.

Anyway, amazing first episode.

[Macie Lightfoot]

Originally Posted by JerseyWins

Anyway, I can't believe they did an All Stars season and didn't include Fairplay or Sandra yet they included Rupert as the only Pearl Islands representative.

objectively speaking Rupert was the biggest star they ever had

[JerseyWins]

The only way that makes sense is if it's a fat joke.

[MB.]

...except the evidence is right there in him winning America's Tribal Council? From what I understand he was ridiculously popular, especially compared to someone like Sandra

[Macie Lightfoot]

or it makes sense in that he is literally the most popular Survivor ever.

[JerseyWins]

Did Richard literally not bring clothes with him for All Stars?

EDIT: Ok I finally see him with shorts on after I said that.

[JerseyWins]

Rudy: Putting up with the people is the survival part.

Rudy going is actually kind of a shame but I prefer Ethan anyway.

[JerseyWins]

- Susan is pretty fun/funny to watch when she's on the outs I think it's just that she kinda has this entitled behavior that's way more funny than annoying to watch when she's not in control.

- Boston Rob on Rob C: "It's like he's on a never ending coffee break"

- Rob C seems so irrelevant this time. One of the least entertaining people so far and he started out strong in particular in Amazon.

- Rupert is actually kinda funny as a madman. (regarding the shelter competition)

- Awwww Jenna </3