[MarkWaldorf]

I feel so sorry for her. She's been pushed back to the end of the desk and if you look, there's quite a gap between her and Louis. I was looking back at videos from Saturday and it was full of banter from Louis/Cheryl/Simon and she was just sat there with a smirk on her face. I think she's only there for Stacey now tbh.

[Jords]

Theyre just jelous shes the better judge on the XFactor

[Jack_]

She's had enough, face says it all, looks very bored and I'm not surprised. Not her biggest fan but she hasn't been treated fairly at all this year and although I find her extremely boring, she's definitely been one of, if not the best judge on the panel this series.

Even if she doesn't quit, I think Simon may sack her anyway. Let's hope Sharon returns either way.

[Ninastar]

I just want to hug her and sit next to her and tell everything will be ok!!!

[Tom]

They're annoyed shes getting in the way of The Simon & Cheryl Show because she always wins most popular judge, so they probably think they can stick her on the end and people will forget about her

Simon hinted at sacking a judge next year to stop deadlock, I reckon Dannii won't sign back up and they won't replace her

[MarkWaldorf]

Yeah, I reckon she's probably not going to come back as opposed to getting sacked or what ever.

[Braden]

i want her to realize how much the public love her
she has been top of the most favourite judge poll for abit

[Jords]

Dannii is ther best judge, I really like her.
Cheryl is good as a character, but not really that great of a judge.
Simon is a good judge (bit of a hypocrite at times though) and is a good character.
^^^
Those 3 should stay

Louis however is just annoying, and he is such a bad judge! He always supports the Irish even if they are bad, very bias.

[MarkWaldorf]

I'd say get Louis out too but it didn't feel right when he was absent earlier in the series.

[Jords]

Originally Posted by MarkWaldorf

I'd say get Louis out too but it didn't feel right when he was absent earlier in the series.

Your so right, but if one of them had to go out them 4, id honestly pick him.

[alc09]

Someone on another board summed her up with the term 'talentless minger'

Don't really know why she is there in all honesty.

[Tom]

Originally Posted by alc09

Someone on another board summed her up with the term 'talentless minger'

Don't really know why she is there in all honesty.

because Cheryl wouldn't sign up for series 4 and Simon had already announced the big changes meaning he couldn't back track . Thats why we got lumbered with Amanda 'I've never had botox' Holden on BGT- because Cheryl didn't sign up for series 1!!

If Cheryl had signed up to XF4 Sharon might still be on the panel

[Jords]

Originally Posted by alc09

Someone on another board summed her up with the term 'talentless minger'

Don't really know why she is there in all honesty.

Stacey is still in, thats why she is still there

[Stacey.]

shes boring and rude... but she has her say when she feels like it. :/

[robb]

I'm pleased Sharon Osbourne has gone. She was just annoying at the end. As for Cheryl, I'm fed up already with the fake disagreements with Simon. It's obvious they love each other. Dannii (who has had 13 top 20 hits in the Uk, BTW) is the most well-balanced, and is slaughtering Cole in the fashion stakes.
Louis? Behaves live a complete buffoon at times.

[Z]

I really hope she stays, she's the only judge on the panel who does what she's meant to do - judge. Simon's a propaganda merchant; Cheryl's so passive she might as well be a robot and Louis acts like a politician; he comments on anything but the singing wherever possible ("you look like a popstar" et al)... She's being treated unfairly.

[Beastie]

I prefer 4 judges to 3 judges.. well unless we did go back to groups, over 25's and under 25's? umm?