[Jack_]

Including CBB ones [mine are in bold]. Here's mine, out of the ones I've watched:

#01 - Pete
#02 - Brian Belo
#03 - Alex
#04 - Anthony
#05 - Chantelle
#06 - Josie
#07 - Sophie
#08 - Shilpa
#09 - Ulrika
#10 - Rachel

...and it's strange because out of all of those, only Alex, Pete, Chantelle and Brian were deserving winners [although they are all still debatable].

The rest are just quite simply undeserving. Says a lot really

[BBfan46]

The best HM nearly never wins.

[BBfan46]

1. Josie
2. Brian
3. Kate
4. Pete
5. Shilpa
6. Sophie
7. Nadia
8. Alex
9. Rachel
10. Anthony

[Maia]

Out of the ones I've watched:

1. Chantelle (CBB)
2. Josie
3. Sophie
4. Rachel
5. Pete
6. Shilpa (CBB)
7. Anthony
8. Brian Belo
9. Alex (CBB)
10. Ulrika (CBB)

[Grimnir]

BB

1. Rachel
2. Pete
3. Kate
4. Brian Belo
5. Sophie
6. Craig
7. Anthony
8. Brian Dowling
9. Cameron
10. Nadia
11. Josie

CBB

1. Chantelle
2. Alex
3. Mark
4. Jack
5. Shilpa
6. Bez
7. Ulrika

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by BBfan46

1. Josie
2. Brian
3. Kate
4. Pete
5. Shilpa
6. Sophie
7. Nadia
8. Alex
9. Rachel
10. Anthony

You seem to have missed Cameron, one of the Brian's, and most CBB winners. Or did you not watch those series?

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Grimnir

BB
1. Rachel

This is a joke, surely?

[headaball]

1. Not Josie
2. Not Josie
3. Not Josie
4. Not Josie
5. Not Josie
6. Not Josie
7. Not Josie
8. Not Josie
9. Not Josie
10. Not Josie
Whichever number is last. Josie

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

yeh best hm never wins :/

1) chantelle
2) josie
3) sophie
4) ulrika

watched from BB6 hated every other winner

[Raph]

1. Rachel
2. Pete
3. Anthony
4. Josie
5. Chantelle
6. Shilpa
7. Alex
8. Sophie
9. Brian B.
10. Ulrika

[BBfan46]

Originally Posted by Jack_

You seem to have missed Cameron, one of the Brian's, and most CBB winners. Or did you not watch those series?

I just left it at the Top 10, I'm feeling lazy.

[Jordan.]

Series 6 onwards:

1. Chantelle (CBB)
2. Pete
3. Sophie
4. Josie
5. Alex (CBB)
6. Anthony
7. Ulrika (CBB)
8. Shilpa (CBB)
9. Brian Belo
10. Rachel

[Raph]

Originally Posted by Jack_

This is a joke, surely?

You putting Rachel, a huge BB fan, below Ulrika, someone who has spent both times dying to get out is a joke, surely.

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by BBfan46

I just left it at the Top 10, I'm feeling lazy.

Oh okay, fair enough.

Originally Posted by Raph

You putting Rachel, a huge BB fan, below Ulrika, someone who has spent both times dying to get out is a joke, surely.

Nope...winners should be the housemate that made the biggest impact/were the most entertaining.

They were both complete bores but my a tiny margin Ulrika did something.

[Grimnir]

Originally Posted by Jack_

This is a joke, surely?

not a joke at all

along with Samanda and Emilia, Rachel is the nicest person I have watched in Big Brother and most deserving winner in BB history

so

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Grimnir

not a joke at all

along with Samanda and Emilia, Rachel is the nicest person I have watched in Big Brother and most deserving winner in BB history

so

She was also the most boring housemate in BB history...winners shouldn't be boring...it's not the 'Nicest Person Contest'...

[Grimnir]

Originally Posted by Jack_

Oh okay, fair enough.



Nope...winners should be the housemate that made the biggest impact/were the most entertaining.

They were both complete bores but my a tiny margin Ulrika did something.

entertaining is not the only condition on who wins

you could say Charley was most entertaining HM in BB8 but there is no chance in hell I vote for the bitch to win

[starry]

I only saw the last couple of weeks but Kate didn't seem too bad.

On CBB Alex did provide some entertainment even though he seemed very naive and a bit silly.

[Jack_]

Originally Posted by Grimnir

entertaining is not the only condition on who wins

It should be...this is an entertainment show, afterall. Where would we be without entertaining housemates?

Originally Posted by Grimnir

you could say Charley was most entertaining HM in BB8 but there is no chance in hell I vote for the bitch to win

Why not? If she was the most entertaining housemate, then she deserves to win...it's simple, really...

[Grimnir]

Originally Posted by starry

I only saw the last couple of weeks but Kate didn't seem too bad.

On CBB Alex did provide some entertainment even though he seemed very naive and a bit silly.

Alex was great mix of entertaining and being quite a nice guy

when he awoke in middle of night in his boxing stance was one of funniest moments in CBB history

[Vicky.]

1. Pete
2. Kate
3. Nadia

Thats it. I usually dislike the people who win. I must have a different taste in HMs to most

[Grimnir]

Originally Posted by Jack_

It should be...this is an entertainment show, afterall. Where would we be without entertaining housemates?



Why not? If she was the most entertaining housemate, then she deserves to win...it's simple, really...

I dont watch it same way you do

I have never called it an entertainment show

its a socio-psycho type experiment show with people we hate, people we love and people we laugh at

I can choose my winner any way I want, not just who has been "entertaining"

[MusicMan]

From BB5 onwards (excl. CBB3):

1. Josie BB11
2. Rachel BB9
3. Nadia BB5
4. Chantelle CBB4
5. Pete BB7
6. Brian BB8
7. Sophie BB10
8. Ulrika CBB6
9. John BBCH
10. Shilpa CBB5
11. Anthony BB6
12. Alex CBB7

[dannyboy]

1 Brian
2 Nadia
3 Sophie
4 Kate
5 Josie
6 Brian Belo
7 Rachel
8 Craig
9vAnthony
10 Pete
11 Cameron

Dont really know enough about CBB to include it.

[Raph]

Originally Posted by Grimnir

I dont watch it same way you do

I have never called it an entertainment show

its a socio-psycho type experiment show with people we hate, people we love and people we laugh at

I can choose my winner any way I want, not just who has been "entertaining"

This is exactly why Rachel Rice is a brilliant, brilliant winner.